Coney Island Cafe
10 Railroad Ave, Middletown
(845) 343-3714
Customers' Favorites
Banana Bread Toasted with Butter
Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
Loaded Hot Dog with Fries
Coney Island Chili Dog
Omelette and Home Fries
Chipotle Bacon Burger
Egg Scramble Bowl
Grilled Reuben
French Dip
1/2LB Hand Pressed Burger
Cheeseburger American
Bacon Cheeseburger
Spicy Philly Burger
Smoke House Burger
Cajun Bacon Jack Burger
Veggie Burger
2 Eggs
Two Eggs Omelette
Two Eggs Omelette W/ No Potatoes
All Day Breakfast
Avocado Toast
Avocado toast with sunny side up egg served with homefries
English Breakfast
Huevos Rancheros
Oatmeal
Eggs Quesadillas
Appetizers & Soup
Mozzarella Sticks
Soup Of The Day
Chili Cheese Fries
Chili Con Carne
Loaded Potato Skins
Bacon Cheese Fries
Say Hello To The Benedicts
Chipotle Bacon Benedict
Classic Benedict
Irish Benedict
Beverages
Coffee
Juice
Tea
Frozen Lemonade
Fountain Soda
Hot Chocolate
Chocolate Milk
Milkshakes
Smoothies
Breakfast Specials (6AM-11AM)
Egg Sandwich - BS
Chef's Special Breakfast Omelettes - BS
French Toast - BS
2 Eggs - BS
Waffles - BS
Pancakes - BS
Cincinnati Style Chili
Five Way
Four Way
Three Way
Coney Island Combos
Greek Gyro Combo
Coney Cheesesteak Combo
Chicken Wings
Coney Island Chili (2)Dog Combo
Chicken Tenders Combo
Coney Island Hot Dogs
New Yorker Dog
Chicago Dog
Coney Island Chili Dog
Manhattan Dog
Mexican Dog
Philly Dog
Plain Dog
Red Onion Sauce Dog
Southwestern Dog
Delicious Melts, Paninis & Wraps
Chipotle Chicken Wrap
Turkey BLT Wrap
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Hickory Chicken Melt
Tuscan Roast Beef Panini
Crispy Chicken Wrap
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Turkey Melt
Delicious Pastas
Chicken Parmesan Pasta
Chicken Broccoli
Chicken Penne Alla Vodka
Shrimp Pasta
Dessert
Cheesecake
Chocolate Cake
Banana
Brownie
Cake Bread
Cannoli
Cookie
Flan
Ice Cream
Jello
Pudding
Rice Pudding
Sweet Almonds
Tres Leches
Egg Sandwiches & Wraps
Egg & Cheese Sandwich
Bacon, Tomato, Avocado
Mediterranean Wrap
Chef Special Wrap
Meat Lover's Egg Wrap
Sausage With Steak Sandwich
Western Egg & Cheese Sandwich
Extras
Bacon
Onions
Fried Onions
Chili Sauce
Cheese
Jalapenos
Onion Sauce
Sauerkraut
Slaw
Fried Pepper
Glorious Salad
Avocado Chicken Salad
Caesar Salad
Chef's Salad
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Tuna Salad
He-Man Breakfast
Grand Slam
NY Strip Steak
Three Meat Spicy Skillet
Hot Open Entrees
Meatloaf
Sirloin Of Beef
Turkey
Virginia Style Ham
Kids Lunch
Cheeseburger(Kids)
Chicken Tenders(Kids)
Grilled Cheese(Kids)
Hot Dog(Kids)
Spaghetti With Meatballs And Sauce(Kids)
Lunch Specials (12PM-8PM)
Coney Island Hot Dog (2) Combo
Fried Fish Sandwich - LS Combo
Crispy Chicken Sandwich Combo
Cheese Quesadilla
Chicken & Rice Platter - LS Combo
Chipotle Chicken Wrap - LS Combo
Coney Cheesesteak - LS Combo
Coney Island Hot Dog (1) Combo
Cowboy Burger - LS
Fish & Chips - LS Combo
Greek Gyro - LS Combo
Tuna BLT - LS
Mexican Fiesta
Classic Mexican Burrito
Fajita Quesadillas
Chicken & Black Bean Quesadilla
Veggie Quesadillas
Pancakes, Waffles & French Toast
Three Pancakes
Pancake Deluxe
Short Stack Pancakes
Short Stack French Toast
French Toast Deluxe
Strawberry Fields French Toast
Original Waffle
Chocolate Chip Waffle
Waffle Slam
Strawberry Fields Waffle
Blueberry Pancakes
Blueberry Waffle
Banana Bread French Toast
Chocolate Chips Pancakes
French Toast
Sides
Home Fries
Corned Beef Hash
Croissant
Assorted Muffins
Avacado
Bacon(Sides)
Toasted Bagel
Toasted Bagel w/Cream Cheese
Buttered Roll
Buttered Toast
Cole Slaw
Croissant w/Cream Cheese
English Muffin
French Fries
Fries w/Mozzarella & Gravy
Grits
Ham
Mac & Cheese
Mashed Potatoes
Onion Rings
Sausage
Sweet Potato Fries
Turkey Sausage
Bagel w/ Butter
Chili Sauce
Potato Chips
Signature Omelette
Farmers Omelette
Cheese Omelette
Grecian Omelette
Omelette
Spicy Avocado Omelette
Tex Mex Omelette
Vegetarian Omelette
Western Omelette
Signature Sandwiches
Chicken Avocado Sandwich
Corned Beef Pastrami Sandwich
French Dip Sandwich
Grilled Reuben Sandwich
Tasty Sandwiches
Chicken BLT Sandwich
Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato Sandwich
Roast Turkey Sandwich
Roast Beef Sandwich
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Egg Salad Sandwich
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
Tuna BLT Sandwich
Triple Deckers
Sliced Ham Triple Decker
Sliced Roast Beef Triple Decker
Sliced Turkey Triple Decker
Photos
+43 photos
+42 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Ordered pick-up before opening time. Unfortunately the homemade cornbeef hash definitely set in a fridge uncovered ( tasted sour) over medium eggs were over done. While the price when ordering through clover is much cheaper then ordering pickup through DD. If You are an early eater this is not the place. Homefries lacked seasoning more of a simple boil potato ?.
May 2024
Eaten here several of times when I used to live in Middletown. From their chili dogs to their Reuben sandwiches. Also tried their burgers. Haven't eaten any breakfast items. Overall food was delicious and service was excellent. Been quite awhile since last stopping in at Coney Island cafe! Yeehaw! Yeehaw!?
July 2023
Had a good meal here!We got an omelette that was fluffy and flavorful; and a steak, good amount of food compared to the price.They refill your coffee which is appreciated.Place was clean and it seems well organized, it’s clear people working there do care to do a good job.Will be back!
May 2023
You May Also Like
El Punto Lounge & Bar - 97 North St
![]()
Lounges, Pubs, Hookah Bar
Quinnz Pinz - 13 Railroad Ave
![]()
Bowling, Burgers, Escape Games, Arcades
Sara Bakery - 89 North St
![]()
Bakery