Five Guys

469 NY-211, Middletown
(845) 394-2640

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Little Bacon Burger and Fries
Bacon Double Cheese Burger
Double Cheeseburger
Little Cheeseburger
Little Cajun Fries
Their Cheeseburger
Bacon Cheeseburger
Fresh Cut Fries
Five Guys Style
Regular Fries

Menu

Five Guys Favorites
Coke Bottle
Delicious and refreshing, one-of-a-kind taste to complete your meal.
Sprite Bottle
Crisp, clean, lemon-lime taste.
Simply Lemonade
All-natural lemonade, made with cane sugar.

Burgers
Hamburger
Fresh, hand-formed patties hot off the grill and placed on a soft, toasted sesame seed bun. Choose as many toppings as you want. 
Cheeseburger
American-style cheese melted between fresh patties and placed on a soft, toasted sesame seed bun. Choose as many toppings as you want.
Bacon Burger
Hand-formed patties hot off the grill, layered with strips of crispy apple-wood smoked bacon and placed on a soft, toasted sesame seed bun. Choose as many toppings as you want. 
Bacon Cheeseburger
Fresh patties hot off the grill with American- style cheese and crispy apple-wood smoked bacon. Placed on a soft, toasted sesame seed bun. Choose as many toppings as you want. 
Little Hamburger
Fresh, hand-formed patty hot off the grill. Add as many toppings as you want. 
Little Cheeseburger
Fresh, hand-formed patty hot off the grill with American- style cheese. Add as many toppings as you want.
Little Bacon Burger
Fresh, hand-formed patty hot off the grill with strips of crispy apple-wood smoked bacon on top. Add as many toppings as you want.
Little Bacon Cheeseburger
Fresh, hand-formed patty hot off the grill with American- style cheese and strips of crispy apple-wood smoked bacon on top. Add as many toppings as you want.

Dogs
Kosher Style Hot Dog
All-beef hot dog, split and grilled lengthwise for a caramelized exterior with any of your favorite toppings.
Cheese Dog
All-beef hot dog, split and grilled lengthwise for a caramelized exterior with a layer of American- style cheese on top and any of your favorite toppings.
Bacon Dog
All-beef hot dog, split and grilled lengthwise for a caramelized exterior with a layer of apple-wood smoked bacon and any of your favorite toppings
Bacon Cheese Dog
All-beef hot dog, split and grilled lengthwise for a caramelized exterior, American-style cheese on top, a layer of apple-wood smoked bacon and any of your favorite toppings.

Sandwiches
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Slices of American style cheese melted on an inside-out sesame seed bun with toppings of your choice and grilled until golden brown.
BLT Sandwich
Strips of crispy apple-wood smoked bacon from one of America's last smokehouses, fresh tomato slices, mayo and hand-shredded lettuce on a soft, toasted sesame seed bun.
Veggie Sandwich
Freshly grilled onions, mushrooms and green peppers layered with lettuce and tomatoes on a soft, toasted sesame seed bun. Or start with the bun and build your own from scratch. Not a veggie burger.
Veggie Cheese Sandwich
Freshly grilled onions, mushrooms and green peppers layered with lettuce, tomatoes and slices of American style cheese on a soft, toasted sesame seed bun. Or start with the bun and cheese and build your own from scratch. Not a veggie burger.

Fries
Little Fries
Freshly made boardwalk-style fries, cooked in pure, cholesterol-free, 100% peanut oil. Cut fresh and cooked twice – firm on the outside and mashed potato on the inside.
Regular Fries
Freshly made boardwalk-style fries, cooked in pure, cholesterol-free, 100% peanut oil. Cut fresh and cooked twice – firm on the outside and mashed potato on the inside.
Large Fries
Freshly made boardwalk-style fries, cooked in pure, cholesterol-free, 100% peanut oil. Cut fresh and cooked twice – firm on the outside and mashed potato on the inside.
Little Cajun Fries
Freshly made boardwalk-style fries, cooked in pure, cholesterol-free, 100% peanut oil, and then showered with a heavy dose of Cajun spice. Cut fresh and cooked twice – firm on the outside and mashed potato on the inside. 
Regular Cajun Fries
Freshly made boardwalk-style fries, cooked in pure, cholesterol-free, 100% peanut oil, and then showered with a heavy dose of Cajun spice. Cut fresh and cooked twice – firm on the outside and mashed potato on the inside. 
Large Cajun Fries
Freshly made boardwalk-style fries, cooked in pure, cholesterol-free, 100% peanut oil, and then showered with a heavy dose of Cajun spice. Cut fresh and cooked twice – firm on the outside and mashed potato on the inside. 

Drinks
Coke Bottle
Delicious and refreshing, one-of-a-kind taste to complete your meal.
Coke Zero Sugar
Real Coca-Cola flavor without any sugar.
Diet Coke Bottle
No calories, always refreshing.
Sprite Bottle
Crisp, clean, lemon-lime taste.
Simply Lemonade
All-natural lemonade, made with cane sugar.
Dasani
Purified water, enhanced with minerals for a pure, fresh taste.

Milkshake
Milkshake
Handspun vanilla milkshakes with or without whipped cream. Choose as many of our free mix-ins as you like.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+49 photos
Photo credit: nextdoor
+48 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Five Guys is 5 stars. The burgers are the best in the area and the fry servings are very generous. The staff is quick and very professional. The store is a blast from the past (in a good way) and the music is the best soundtrack to any meal.
August 2025
I have been to this location in person and it’s amazing and service is wonderful, how order online is a entire different story, I’ve ordered online 3 out of the 4 times at this location and 3 times the burger has been messed up, soggy, wrong topping, cheese when I didn’t want it just a whole mess when ordering online, if you wanna go here GO IN PERSON! At least the fries were good 4/4 I’ve ordered them
July 2025
Great food at this location! Only gripe I had was with crew members not having great communication with each other regarding what orders are in or out. Stood around for a couple minutes after getting my burger and fries and only until after I said something about a shake did the guy hand off my receipt to the guy upfront making shakes. He had no idea and didn’t have the courage to ask me if he could help me. All good tho! Food was spectacular and I’m sure this is only a one...
April 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

You You Asian Cuisine - 465 NY-211
Asian, Chinese, Japanese, Sushi, Vegetarian
McDonald's - 481 NY-211
Fast Food, Burgers, Coffee & Tea
Taco Bell - 492 NY-211
Fast Food, Mexican

Five Guys

469 NY-211, Middletown, NY 10940
(845) 394-2640