John's Of Arthur Ave

19 W Main St, Middletown
(845) 467-4712

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Family Size 1 2 BBQ Chicken 1 2 Plain Pizza
1 2 Chicken Supreme 1 2chicken Bacon Ranch
Slice of Family Size BBQ Chicken Pizza
Grill Chicken Salad Balsamic Dressing
House Special Eggplant Pizza
Eggplant and Pesto Pizza
Cheese Pizza Personal 12
Rony Heart Shaped Pizza
Shrimp Special Pie
Garlic Knots Pizza

Menu

Arthur Ave. Style Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily. Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Mozzarella cheese, bacon, chicken, and yummy ranch dressing. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
12" Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Personal. Mozzarella cheese, bacon, chicken, and yummy ranch dressing. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
12" Pizza Margherita
Personal. Crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, and olive oil. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
Pizza Margherita
Crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, and olive oil. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
12" White Pizza
Fresh ricotta, grande mozzarella, pecorino Romano and Parmigiano Reggiano. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
White Pizza
Fresh ricotta, grande mozzarella, pecorino Romano and Parmigiano Reggiano. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
House Special Eggplant Pizza
Cheese and tomato pie topped with fried eggplant, fresh ricotta, pecorino, Parmigiano, and basil. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
12" ' House Special Eggplant Pizza
Personal. Cheese and tomato pie topped with fried eggplant, fresh ricotta, pecorino, Parmigiano, and basil. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
12" ' Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Personal. Buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Topped with BBQ sauce, mozzarella, and chicken meat. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
12'' BBQ Chicken Pizza
Personal. Topped with BBQ sauce, mozzarella, and chicken meat. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
Sunday Pizza
Sauce and mozzarella with sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, and pecorino. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
12" Sunday Pizza
Personal. Sauce and mozzarella with sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, and pecorino. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
Chicken alla Vodka Pizza
Served with chicken. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
12" Chicken alla Vodka Pizza
Personal. Served with chicken. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
Sausage, Pepper, and Onions Dinner Pizza
Pizza sauce, mozzarella, sweet fennel sausage, grilled peppers, and onions. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
12" Sausage, Pepper, and Onions Dinner Pizza
Personal. Pizza sauce, mozzarella, sweet fennel sausage, grilled peppers, and onions. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily. Topped in our homemade creamy Alfredo sauce with chicken.
12" Chicken Alfredo Pizza
Personal. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily. Topped in our homemade creamy Alfredo sauce with chicken.
Broccoli Rabe and Sausage Pizza
Crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, sweet fennel sausage, garlic, and broccoli rabe. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.
12" Broccoli Rabe and Sausage Pizza
Personal. Crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, sweet fennel sausage, garlic, and broccoli rabe. Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande mozzarella. Our mozzarella is made fresh daily.

Sicilian Pizza
Gramma Pizza
Thin crust pan pizza with crushed tomatoes, basil, homemade mozzarella, and olive oil.
Sicilian Pizza
Deep-dish pan pizza with cooked tomato sauce and aged mozzarella.

Appetizers
Buffalo Wings
Cooked wings of a chicken coated in Buffalo sauce. Mild, hot, or BBQ. Add dressing for an additional charge.
Mozzarella Sticks
Deep-fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside.
Fried Calamari
Your choice of garlic-basil aioli or marinara.
Homemade Meatballs
Served with tomato sauce, pecorino, and basil.
Grandma's Meatballs
Homemade tomato sauce, fresh ricotta, pecorino, and basil.
French Fries
Our delicious french fries are deep-fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection. Substitution upon request. Add dressing for an additional charge.
Garlic Knots
6 pieces. Rolled baked garlic bread. Served with marinara.
Chicken Fingers
Breaded or battered crispy chicken. Served with a side of honey mustard or BBQ sauce. Add dressing for an additional charge.
Antipasto
A neighborhood selection of dry-cured meats, pickled vegetables, and our own homemade mozzarella.
House Special Pepperoni Garlic Bread
Topped with mozzarella, pecorino, Parmigiano and pepperoni.
Mozzarella Caprese
Fresh, homemade mozzarella, olive oil, sea salt, fresh basil, tomatoes, and balsamic reduction.
Broccoli Rabe
Sauteed garlic, olive oil, and a touch of pepperoncini, hot chili flakes.
Plain Garlic Bread
Bread, topped with garlic, and herb seasoning, baked to perfection.
Eggplant Appetizer
Individual. Homemade eggplant cutlets, tomato sauce, Parmigiano Reggiano, and fresh basil.
Sweet Fennel Sausage
Side.

Salads
Pear Salad
Served with organic mesclun, cranberries, candied walnuts, Gorgonzola, and balsamic vinaigrette.
Caesar Salad
Caesar dressing, garlic croutons, and pecorino.
Arthur Ave. Special Salad
Mixed Italian salad, salami, pepperoni, provolone, romaine lettuce, chickpeas, pepperoncini, Kalamata olives, pickled red onions, tomatoes, and red wine vinaigrette.
Mango Avocado Salad
Romaine, cucumbers, tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella.
Tomato Avocado Salad
Romaine, cucumbers, and fresh mozzarella.
House Salad
Romaine, tomatoes, house-pickled red onions, Kalamata olives, and house vinaigrette.
Chef Salad
Romaine, turkey, ham, provolone, tomatoes, house-pickled red onions, Kalamata olives, and house vinaigrette.

Calzones
Ricotta and Homemade Mozzarella Calzone
Served with melty mozzarella and creamy ricotta. Served with tomato sauce.
Pepperoni Calzone
Served with pasta sauce and mozzarella cheese. Served with tomato sauce.
Prosciutto Calzone
Served with prosciutto. Served with tomato sauce.
Broccoli Rabe Calzone
Served with broccoli rabe. Served with tomato sauce.
Ham Calzone
Made with ricotta, provolone, and mozzarella cheese. Served with tomato sauce.
Chicken Calzone
Spread chicken mixture over cheese. Served with tomato sauce.

Hero Sandwiches
Italian Combo Hero
Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and house dressing. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Boneless breast of chicken with marinara sauce, Parmesan, and melted mozzarella. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Philly Cheese Steak Works Hero
Steak, cheese, and caramelized onion sandwich.
Bronx Bomber Stromboli Hero
Ham, salami, pepperoni, aged mozzarella, peppers, and onions are rolled and baked in our own pizza dough with dipping sauce. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Tuscan Fried Chicken Cutlet Hero
Served with lettuce, tomatoes, and garlic-basil aioli. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Philly Cheese Steak Hero
Served with mushrooms.
Pollo Prosciutto Hero
Grilled chicken, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, and marinated red peppers with fresh basil. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Balsamic Eggplant Special Hero
Fried eggplant, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, and balsamic vinaigrette with fresh basil.
Meatball Parmigiana Hero
Served with marinara sauce, meatballs, and Parmesan cheese. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Broccoli Rabe and Sausage Hero
Served with tomato sauce and pecorino. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Sausage, Peppers, and Onions Hero
Served with tomato sauce. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Veal Parmigiana Hero
Veal cutlets, tomato sauce, and Parmesan cheese. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
Topped with eggplant slices, Parmesan cheese, and marinara sauce. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Cheeseburger and Fries Hero
Grilled or fried patty with cheese on a bun. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Balsamic Fresh Mozzarella Hero
Soft, fresh, homemade mozzarella, roasted red peppers, balsamic vinaigrette, and fresh basil. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Shrimp Parmigiana Hero
Served with shrimp and Parmesan cheese. Add toppings for an additional charge.
Sausage Parmigiana Hero
Topped with sausage and Parmesan cheese. Add toppings for an additional charge. Add toppings for an additional charge.

Wraps
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Lettuce, tomatoes, and ranch dressing.
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
Romaine, Caesar dressing, and pecorino.
Fajita Wrap
Chicken, onions, peppers, and Swiss.
Steak Wrap
Peppers, onions, and cheese.
Turkey Wrap
Bacon, cheddar, red onions, apple, lettuce, tomatoes, and Russian dressing.

Arthur Ave. Pasta Shop
Penne alla Vodka
Shallots, prosciutto, tomatoes, basil, and cream.
Penne Portobello
Sauteed portobello mushrooms, Marsala Parmesan cream sauce, and imported white truffle oil.
Baked Ziti
Baked with tomato sauce, ricotta, and homemade mozzarella.
Penne Alfredo
Parmesan cream sauce.
Cheese Ravioli
From terranova bakery in the bronx. Tomato sauce and pecorino.
Homemade Lasagna
Individual. Stacked layers of pasta packed with meat and cheese, covered in red sauce. Pro tip: go for the crispy edge pieces.
Spaghetti with Tomato Basil Sauce
Homemade tomato sauce, and pecorino.
Baked Stuffed Shells
Served with ricotta, mozzarella, and tomato sauce.
Penne with Broccoli Rabe and Sausage
Narrow tube-shaped pasta.
Spaghetti with Garlic and Oil
Garlic, olive oil, and pecorino.
Baked Manicotti
Homemade ricotta-filled crepes baked with tomato sauce, pecorino, and mozzarella.

Arthur Ave. Pasta Shop a la Carte
Penne alla Vodka a la Carte
Shallots, prosciutto, tomatoes, basil and cream.
Homemade Lasagna a la Carte
Stacked layers of pasta packed with meat and cheese, covered in red sauce. Pro tip: go for the crispy edge pieces.
Baked Ziti a la Carte
Baked with tomato sauce, ricotta, and homemade mozzarella.
Penne with Broccoli Rabe and Sausage a la Carte
Served with broccoli rabe and sausage.
Baked Manicotti a la Carte
Homemade ricotta-filled crepes baked with tomato sauce, pecorino, and mozzarella.
Spaghetti with Garlic and Oil a la Carte
Garlic, olive oil, and pecorino.
Cheese Ravioli a la Carte
From Terranova bakery in the Bronx. Tomato sauce and pecorino.
Spaghetti with Tomato Basil Sauce a la Carte
Homemade tomato sauce and pecorino.
Penne Alfredo a la Carte
Parmesan cream sauce.
Penne Portobello a la Carte
Sauteed portobello mushrooms, Marsala Parmesan cream sauce, and imported white truffle oil.
Baked Stuffed Shells a la Carte
Served with ricotta, mozzarella, and tomato sauce.

Little Italy Entrees
Chicken Parmigiana
Tomato sauce and homemade mozzarella with spaghetti.
Eggplant Parmigiana
Tomato sauce and homemade mozzarella with spaghetti.
Eggplant Rollatini
Filled with ricotta and homemade mozzarella. Served with spaghetti tomato basil sauce.
Chicken Francese
Herb butter and lemon sauce over spaghetti.
Chicken Marsala
Served with mushrooms and Marsala wine sauce over spaghetti.
Shrimp Scampi
Served with lemon garlic sauce.
Chicken Scarpariello
Sauteed chicken, sausage, hot vinegar peppers, Italian herbs, and pan sauce over spaghetti.
Veal Parmigiana
Tomato sauce and homemade mozzarella with spaghetti.

Little Italy Entrees a la Carte
Chicken Marsala a la Carte
Served with mushrooms and Marsala wine sauce.
Eggplant Rollatini a la Carte
Filled with ricotta and homemade mozzarella. Served tomato basil sauce.
Chicken Francese a la Carte
Herb butter and lemon sauce.
Chicken Parmigiana a la Carte
Tomato sauce and homemade mozzarella.
Chicken Scarpariello a la Carte
Sauteed chicken, sausage, hot vinegar peppers, Italian herbs, and pan sauce.
Eggplant Parmigiana a la Carte
Tomato sauce and homemade mozzarella.
Veal Parmigiana a la Carte
Tomato sauce and homemade mozzarella.
Shrimp Scampi a la Carte
Served with lemon garlic sauce.

Kids Menu
Kid's Chicken Fingers
Breaded or battered crispy chicken. Served with fries. Add dressing for an additional charge.
Kid's Penne Pasta
Narrow tube-shaped pasta. Served with butter and cheese.
Kid's Spaghetti
Pasta with a tomato-based red sauce. Served with 1 meatball.
Kid's Ravioli
Served with sauce.

Desserts
Cannoli
Delicious tube of fried dough, filled with a sweet, creamy ricotta filling.
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Rich, indulgent chocolate dessert.
Ricotta Cheesecake
Rich creamy cake.

Beverages
20 oz. Soda
Your choice of soda.
2 Liter Soda
Your choice of soda.
Brisk Iced Tea
2 Liter. No espresso, no milk.
Pure Leaf
20 oz. Your choice of flavor.
Seltzer Water
20 oz.
Juice
20 oz. Your choice of flavor.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+7 photos
Photo credit: google
+6 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Ordered a Balsamic Eggplant Special Hero that my son picked up for me and OMG it was so GOOD. The eggplant was perfect and not heavily breaded, it was perfect, like scilian style. Thank you so much!!!!
February 2026
I've been ordering from here since it first opened. I always order the tomato avocado salad with grilled chicken, dried cranberries and walnuts, used to be around $14.00. The price has now skyrocketed and today I paid an additional $7.50 for the last 2 items, cost me more for a handful of cranberries and walnuts, than an entire piece of chicken...nearly $24.00 total! I honestly don't think I can bring myself to go back now! Oh and Robert makes the best pizza and always...
December 2025
Quality + Value + Customer Service. John’s has been my go-to pizza spot since I’ve moved to Middletown. Gourmet GIANT slice (think buffalo chicken, bbq chicken or white slice etc) for only $4.75. I’m always full after 1 slice. I’m from NYC so have eaten at more pizzerias than I can count. John’s gets 5 stars🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟for a no-frills local neighborhood pizza spot! (my photos don’t do it justice 😂)
October 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Hanami Japanese Restaurant - 21 W Main St
Sushi, Asian Fusion, Sushi Bar, Japanese, Asian
Olivia's Empanadas - 12 W Main St
Dominican, Latin American, Vegan
DeStefano's Olde Erie - 7 W Main St
Pubs, Italian, Seafood, American

John's Of Arthur Ave

19 W Main St, Middletown, NY 10940
(845) 467-4712