Juicy Seafood

731 NY-211, Middletown
(845) 692-8808

Recent Reviews

Tori T

This place is great! It is clean, has attentive staff, and the food was nice. I went here on Christmas Day for a nice meal with family, and we ordered a large tray of seafood. Since we spent more than 100$, we got a free pound of crab legs! We had a great time!

Jordan Milite

Went on Christmas, they were very nice and had great service. We also spent over 100 bucks and got a free pound of crab. I would recommend getting the platter for 2 people for 4-5 people. This is what we did and with 5 people, we still did not finish. Great portions, service, and atmosphere

Nikki Weslowski

I was hesitant to go by previous reviews. However this place was soooo good! Staff was so friendly and accommodating. Food was so good and price was great. $130 two adults and a child. Can’t beat it. So much food! Everything was cooked perfectly and flavor was delicious. Will definitely be coming back!

Sean Cannon

Came here for my wife’s birthday on a Thursday night. The food was excellent and the service was the best. Very friendly family owned place. They tolerated our rambunctious children, which we really appreciated. I definitely recommend this place.

Bronx DJ Larry

This is a small cajun style restaurant on route 211 serving the boil bags of seafood. Friendly, clean, and prompt service. The cocktails are not my cup of tea. The food is very good.

Kenya Torres

This was my first time at this restaurant and I have to say it's really nice in the inside. When I arrived there was hardly any business. I found my own seat and I was greeted with a nice young lady. The customer service was really nice. She made me an amazing virgin Pina colada drink (which I am come back for but not sure because they charged me $6 for a drink with no alcohol I wonder how much it would have cost with it.While looking at the menu I noticed at the bottom of the menu it stated you are not able to get your money back. When I read that That should have been a read flag for me but I am review expert so I wanted to get the full experience so I can share with all of you. Well I took a chance with catfish and chips and calamari as a app.. My calamari came first and I have to say it was hot but with some cleat like sauce which to me didn't go with calamari. The calamari tasted like it was the frozen line in the bag there was season nothing just fried with this sauce and it wasn't good. I took it home to see if I can hook it up with Mariana sauce. Now the catfish came out. The catfish also had no seasoning on it and it too tasted like it was frozen it was not fresh at all the fries was OK nothing to brag about. The only thing that was good was the tartar sauce and my drink.Now what top off my experience was this. I received my bill which was $30 which was ok but they added there tip to it of $4.68 mind you on this same menu it stated if it's 5 or more tip will be added to your bill. I ate by myself nobody was with me. Mind you I was going to tip the waitress because even thou the food sucked she was pleasant, sweet, very inviting I wanted to tip her $7 but considering they add there tip there was no reason to. When she went to pay it she said do you want the change and I said yes. My question to myself was why would I not you already added your tip why would I pay more.I would not come back her and I would not.recommend anyone else. I believe by the menu stating no money back they may have had issues with other customers because there food is not good and it's frozen products thats why it's there. But I took a chance because I am a Google reviewer and I like to share places and my experience. Hope this helps someone don't waste your money just go to Red Lobster on 211 ?

Christine Toledo

My daughter loves seafood boil mukbang videos , so for her birthday I bought her here since she’s never had a seafood boil. A friend recommended this place & it did not disappoint .Fried fish was incredibly light & fresh, calamari was delightful,The seafood boils were seasoned amazingly well , my son doesn’t like seafood & got some chicken tenders w fries & he also left very satisfied . Our server was incredibly attentive , place was very clean w cute decor . Definitely will be back , great experience overall.

Ronique P.

Price is high in regards to quality. Food isn't fresh, taste like store boxed. Service is okay but quality and quantity of food decreased dramatically. I would not recommend.

Hector Gonzalez

I love it, I'll be brutally honest, I've never never had fried shrimp and catfish as fresh as this. My friends recommended it to me. It's definitely a great place to get some seafood. The fried rice is amazing also. Definitely going back

harold w.

The clam soup had very little clams in it and the scallops tasted like they came from a box not very tasty but the fries were ok

Debbie J.

Food ok, expensive, need more help waitress took our order, kitchen help brought our food, could have used another drink couldn't get thier attention, had to wave them down to get the check won't go back

Kisha Robinson

The seafood was fresh and tasted good as well. The only issues I have is that they charge separately for the butter sauce, which should come complimentary since the food is on the expensive side. And most seafood bags I've had come with sausages, but that was a separate charge as well. For $45 for crab legs and shrimp I definitely don't think it should be an extra charge and sausages should be included.

Tracey Olulenu

This was my first time at this location for late lunch. We ordered one drink each, which I must say was very good. The food came out relatively fast and was good. I will return.

Amy W.

Ordered king crab & shrimp boil...only got 1 crab leg with it & paid $48! I thought they were bringing the rest out but that was it. The portions were small & I left hungry. Service was just mmm eh, didn't come check on us not 1 time. Only plus is the drink was good.

Tiffany N.

The catfish basket was seasoned very well and included 3 large pieces of fish. I ordered onion rings to go with it. They were also good. I ordered it over the phone and it was ready in 10 minutes. The price was also good. I would definitely get it again.

Load More