Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

92 Dolson Ave, Middletown
(845) 343-7482

Recent Reviews

Chris Carde

Had the pleasure of getting served by Gabe! What an awesome guy, made my experience great! Shout out to you !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ric Gee

Custard life!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kathy Sullivan

Was not closed refused order 0 stars

Joe Santoro

Always a great spring & summer spot!

Fancy Feast

Very good but the concrete feels like concrete in my stomach and makes me bloated and dead tired.

Faheem Abdul-Karim

An unexpected delight. Prices are cheap and the custard on top of the Italian ice is a must have

Lilly J Huertas

Delicious soft served and a variety of flavors hard ice cream...i had a small cup of orange and cream ice cream with hot fudge, yummy! can't wait to go back .

CLONEINK

I've been taking the family to Rita's for years but today was the first time I felt that I wouldn't be going back. My cashier was Leia and she was condescending and rude. I used it as a teaching experience for my kids on what not to do when working in the customer service field. When your kids notice someone being rude it says a lot. Leia needs a lesson in how not to conduct yourself even when you're having a bad day...

Tonya Crawford

Great please staff is very friendly. Please update your current hours online. I drove 25 mins based off your hours listed and you guys were closed. It currently states that you are open until 10:30 pm. I got there at 9:15. Very annoying.

Hanna Marcolina

Gelati is delicious and refreshing on a hot summer day. Very polite staff and great service

Elijah Rahman

This is the best ice cream I have ever had!!!?

claudia howell

If u want to get ripped off and small portions go there. Sure they will be outta business soon

Jake E.

Definitely a good custard. But the prices are very high. Too high.

Omar S.

My wife and I just drove 30mins to come to this location and when we pulled into the parking lot at 8:20pm we saw two people standing at the window being served and as soon as we approached the front of the place we saw the two people leaving and the person inside quickly shut the window shutter as if we didn't see them. I'm not really sure why the hours listed on google and yelp and pretty much everywhere states that they're open till 9pm when they aren't, except for the two people that where there before us who apparently must've had some special Rita privileges. At the very least the person inside could've just apologized and told us that they're closed instead of pretending like we didn't see them by shutting the blinds. So maybe instead of making people find out that your location is closed by making the trip to your location, I strongly suggest that you change the hours listed for your business because that is a sure way to lose potential customers.

Cristal Bravo

The worker got my oder wrong and gave me a small instead of a large

Load More

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

92 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY 10940
(845) 343-7482