The Ott'rageous Cookie Co., LLC
Lexington Way, Middletown
(845) 656-2707
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Lexington Way, Middletown
(845) 656-2707
Best cookies I've ever had! Stop by and see Ray today Goshen Farmers Market
Delicious cookies!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Found these guys at the Goshen Farmers market. Best cookie ever ! ! !Ray is the man !
Mint Chocolate Chip, felt like I was having the ice cream. Sooo GOOD!! ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS ?
WOW WOW WOW I just purchased two small bags of cookies at the popular Stormville flea market. The lemon white chocolate chip is DELICIOUS. I haven’t tried the peanut butter chocolate chip cookie yet. I’m hiding from kids while enjoying these cookies!
Amazing mint chocolate chip cookies!!
This business has the absolute best home-made chocolate chip cookies that are made fresh daily. Definitely stop by the Emporium in Middletown on weekends and pick up some cookies, there are tons of flavors. Highly recommend ?
Super yummy cookies that are moist & fresh. The bad news.... you can't just eat one! Keep it up, you are awesome.
Yum! Some of the best cookies I’ve had. They have a ton of flavor options. I got the mint chocolate chip and m&m ones, both were amazing!
Cookies are indeed swagger
Restaurantji Recommends
First off,WHO DOESNT LOVE COOKIES?BUTTTTTThe Ott'rageouss Cookie Co. has THE BEST tasting cookies my husband and I have ever had! With flavors I've never seen or tasted before! The orange creamsicle is by far our favorite, and the chocolate chip is literally ottrageous. I honestly cannot wait for an event where I can have the cookies as a station. This is a must go to kind of shop!
Have you ever wanted to write a review for something, and the only thing you could say is. YUM YUM YUM...... The cookies are fantastic! The owners are one of a kind, and the shop is super cute! Stop by and try these cookies.... my favorite is M&M, Mint Chocolate, Chocolate Chip, Kit Kat.... need I say more!!
This small cookie business has the best mint Chocolate Chip cookies. I make a special trip on the weekends to buy the cookies they make. I always feel like I am eating heaven in a cookie! IF you have not tried the cookies, you need to.
Love their mint chocolate chip and oatmeal cookies. They’re very rich & tasty cookies.
Loading...