Yummy's Pizza - Monsey

54 NY-59, Monsey
(845) 356-0335

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Cheese Crust Deep Dish Cheese Pizza
Pasta Pizza by the Slice
Extra Cheese Slice Pizza
One Mozzarella Sticks
Regular Cheese Pizza
Baguette with Fish
Mushroom Calzone
Baked Ziti Pasta
Vegetable Pizza
Margarita Pizza

Menu

Pies
Regular Pie Pizza
Pie (Size 18 )
Regular Slice Pizza
Personal Regular Pizza
Personal (Size 10 Inch)
Personal Ziti Pizza
Size 10 Inch
Personal Grandma's Pizza
10 Inch pizza with fresh Mozzarella, steamed tomato, basil, garlic and parmesan cheese
Vegetable Pie
18 Inch vegetable pie topped with peppers, onions, squash, and sweet carrots! its worth a try for sure.
Personal Margherita Pizza
Tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, fresh basil, salt, and extra virgin olive oil.Pie Size 18 Inch ,Personal Size 10 Inch
Extra Cheese Slice Pizza
One slice with extra cheese
Jalapeno and Olive Slice Pizza
slice of pizza topped with olives and Jalapenos
Margherita Slice Pizza
White Mozzarella , Basil, garlic, red sauce and parmesan cheese
Grandma's Slice Pizza
fresh mozzarella, steamed tomat, basil, garlic and parm.
French Fries Slice Pizza
Slice pizza topped with French Fries.
Extra Cheese Pie
18" Pizza with Double cheese.
Sicilian Pie
Size 18 Inch
Zitti Pie
Size 18 Inch
Personal White Pizza
10 Inch Pizza with Mozzarella and Ricotta cheese (no red sauce)
Grandma's Pie
Cooked in olive oil-coated pan topped with classic cheese and tomato sauce.Pie Size 18 Inch ,Personal Size 10 Inch
Margherita Pie
Tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, fresh basil, salt, and extra virgin olive oil.Pie Size 18 Inch
Mushroom Pie
18 Inch Pizza topped with sautéed mushrooms
White Pie
18 Inch Pie with Mozzarella and Ricotta cheese (no red sauce)
Jalapeno and OlivePie
Classic cheese & olives.Pie Size 18 Inch ,Personal Size 10 Inch
Spinach Pie
Size 18 Inch
French Fries Pie
18 Inch pizza topped with crispy French fries and spicy mayo upon request.
Personal Olive Pizza
Personal ( Size 10 Inch)
Personal Jalapeno and Olive Pizza
10" pizza topped with green olives and jalapenos.
Personal French Fries Pizza
Size 10 Inch
Cheese Crust Pie
An 18 Inch extra cheese pie with more cheese stuffed inside the crust!
Eggplant Pie
18 Inch pie topped with golden fried breaded eggplant
Personal Eggplant Pizza
10 Inch personal pie topped with golden fried breaded eggplant !
Personal Mushroom Pizza
10 Inch Pizza
Personal Spinach Pizza
Size 10 Inch
Personal Vegetable Pizza
Size 10 Inch
Personal Extra Cheese Pizza
10 Inch personal pie with double mozzarella.
Ziti Slice Pizza
Sourdough Personal Pie
We have now Sourdough personal pie pizza (10 inch) avaviable at store.
Sourdough Personal pie with any topping!
Vegetables,Olives,mushrooms,spinish corn or fried onions.
Eggplant Pizza Slice
White Pizza Slice
Vegetable Slice Pizza
Regular Pie
Sicilian Slice Pizza
Spinach Slice Pizza

Falafel
Whole Pita Falafel
Scrumptious pita bread filled with Israeli salad, dill pickle chips and the purest falafel balls. served with Tahina on the side
Falafel Wrap
Made from ground chickpeas, fava beans, or both. Herbs, spices, and onion relatives are commonly added to the dough. It is a well-known Middle Eastern
One Falafel Balls
Made from ground chickpeas, fava beans, or both. Herbs, spices, and onion relatives are commonly added to the dough. It is a well-known Middle Eastern
Falafel Platter
Made from ground chickpeas, fava beans, or both. Herbs, spices, and onion relatives are commonly added to the dough. It is a well-known Middle Eastern

Fish
Fish and Fries
Served with salad.
Grilled Salmon
Served with steamed vegetables or fresh seasoned salad.

Salads
Greek Salad
Feta cheese, olives, eggs and anchovies. Made from the freshest and finest ingredients chopped daily.
Caesar Salad
Served with a side of dressing.

Calzone
PizzaCalzone
VegetableCalzone
SpinachCalzone
Calzone stuffed with a mixture of sautéed spinach, onions ricotta cheese and mozzarella.
Cheese Calzone
Made with ricotta and mozzarella cheese.

Side Orders
French Fries - Mixed - spicy and Regular - Large
Mixed - spicy and Regular -Our delicious french fries are deep fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!
Regular French Fries - Large
Our delicious french fries are deep fried 'till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection!
One Mozzarella Sticks
One cheesy Mozzarella sticks with a crispy coating Deep fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Virtually guaranteed to be a table favorite! Served with a side of sauce.
One Garlic Knots
A classic snack, our garlic knots are strips of pizza dough tied in a knot, baked, and then topped with melted butter, garlic, and parsley. Served with a side of sauce.
Spicy French Fries-Large
Cheese Fries-Small
French fries & luxurious melted cheese. A diner classic you can enjoy at home – now that's luxury.
Cheese Pretzel
Cheese Fries-Large
French fries & luxurious melted cheese. A diner classic you can enjoy at home – now that's luxury.

Beverages
Soda Can
Cold Drink
perfectly chilled beverage of your choice!
Slush -Small
Slush- Large
PASSION FRUIT, STRAWBERRY or CAPPUCCINO.
Water

Desserts
Slush -Small
Slush- Large
PASSION FRUIT, STRAWBERRY or CAPPUCCINO.
Soft Ice Cream Cup
Ice Pop
Sandwich Ice Cream

Pastas
Baked Ziti Pasta
Personal Dish (kosher) of ziti Pasta and a Neapolitan-style tomato based sauce characteristic of Italian-American cuisine topped with a medley of melted cheese.
Fettuccini Alfredo Pasta
Personal Dish (kosher) - Fettuccine Alfredo is an Italian pasta dish of fresh fettuccine tossed with butter and Parmesan cheese. As the cheese melts, it emulsifies the liquids to form a smooth and rich sauce coating the pasta.

Soups
Vegetable Soup

Sandwiches
Bagel Sandwich with Tuna
Served with salad.
Fish sandwich.-Flounder
Flounder Fish (Kosher) -Flounders are a group of flatfish species. They are demersal fish, found at the bottom of oceans around the world
Bagel Sandwich with Cream Cheese
Served with salad.
Baguette Sandwich with Tuna
classic Tuna on a toasted baguette add a note if you would like lettuce, tomatoes and pickle chips.
Impossble Burger
(kosher) Impossible Foods' burger is made from genetically modified soy, served with small fries. Specify in the notes if you want American cheese (dairy) or no cheese (pareve) comes with lettuce & tomatoes (onions are optional and frequently included.

Wraps
Falafel Wrap
Made from ground chickpeas, fava beans, or both. Herbs, spices, and onion relatives are commonly added to the dough. It is a well-known Middle Eastern
Tuna Wrap
Tuna wrap with lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and onions (specify toppings)

Photos

Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+43 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+42 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Best pizza in town! Yummy Pizza in Monsey serves amazing, fresh pizza, and their homemade jalapeño calzone is absolutely delicious. Friendly staff, great service, and a cozy atmosphere make it a perfect spot for a bite. Highly recommend!
October 2025
After leaving a nearby mall with a pizza place that was way too crowded and overpriced, we found Yummy's nearby. And what a find it was! The prices were much more reasonable, the owner and staff super-friendly, and the pizza was amazing.

Loved the thin crust crispy slices and the gluten-free option for our little one. Definitely recommend.
September 2024
My Family has been going to Yummy's since it opened. We consider ourselves regulars due to the delicious items on the menu, with new items continuously being added. The warm welcome we receive by both Jimmy and David, you would think I am a celebrity.
For our Grandchildren's birthday party we let them choose which pizza store they want to go to, the response is always YUMMY"s.

Wishing you continued success and Hatzlacha on your upcoming...
April 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Kosher Castle - 43 NY-59
Kosher, Fast Food, Chinese, American, Asian
Sheli's in the Square - 59 NY-59
Kosher, Pizza
Chick 'N Chuck - 59 NY-59
Kosher

Yummy's Pizza - Monsey

54 NY-59, Monsey, NY 10952
(845) 356-0335