It‘s a nice Italian restaurant. The pizza and the caprese sandwich were both amazing. I really recommend going.
Tracy Rummans
We are literally here, at the restaurant. The food was fantastic! Lasagna, the Alla Vodka sauce, Rigatoni Bolognese were all fantastic! Service was great and attentive!! Highly recommend!
Veronica Gomez
Pizza was dried and spicy. I got the pepperoni one, my friend got Calabrese eggs and they were pretty good actually. Service was good. Waiter was good. I just wish the pizza was good.
mark loschiavo
Tuscan Italian, Fantastic, great staff, incredible food and atmosphere
BK Sung
Delicious food, great and welcoming service, quick delivery of food, good vibe. All of these make this restaurant special.
Meg A. Watt
This place is fab. The food and service were top notch.
Mike Ivers
The espresso martinis are a must. And the ricotta !
Gina
I was just there the other evening. I had the pepperoni pizza. It was very good and the service was good.
Sabrina Rogers
I visited this restaurant back in May with my husband on a Wednesday afternoon, and we had a great experience. Since it wasn’t too busy at that time, we were seated quickly, and the service was attentive and friendly throughout.
The food was genuinely fantastic—we loved every dish we tried. We got the arancini and calamari as our appetizers, and shared the tartufo pizza and penne bolognese. My husband always tries a local beer wherever we go, and I usually go for sangria/spritz if it’s on the menu—in this case I got the peach spritz and it was so refreshing!
Whenever we’re back in Montauk, this will definitely be our go-to lunch spot. Prices were what you’d expect for Montauk, on the higher end, but for a day trip, it felt well worth the splurge.
Mengtong Guan
It’s a lovely restaurant with delicious food in a historical architecture. Only thing I notice that’s not perfect is ventilation of their kitchen, you might end up with smelling like food on your clothes for a few days after visiting.
I was out at The End for a night and stopped in for dinner. This is such a cute restaurant right in the heart of Montauk proper. There are rounded windows all the way around the restaurant giving it a very spacious feel. The food was really good; the pasta, the polenta and pizza were all excellent in their own right. Our waitress was attentive and very pleasant.
Really good food and atmosphere. Their pizza is so good, a nice treat all the way out east. Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
carlos borges
The food here is absolutely fantastic—this is hands-down one of our favorite restaurants anywhere. We’ve been loyal fans of Alimentary Beach since it first opened and make it a point to visit every time we’re in Montauk. The ingredients are top-notch, the service is warm and welcoming, and the wine list is excellent. Unlike many spots in this part of Long Island, they don’t overcharge, which is refreshing.
Do yourself a favor and order the whipped ricotta—it’s out of this world. The meatballs are also a standout, and the Caesar salad is a winner, with a light, non-creamy dressing that’s just right. The shrimp with polenta is hearty and delicious, making it a perfect appetizer to start your meal.
Honestly, I’d drive all the way from the city anytime just to enjoy a meal here and soak in the great vibes. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pierre L
Friendly place, simple food but delicious. Stop here without heaitation
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Joaquin Melo
One of my favorite places in montauk just get better and better with the time , GM Gianni, has put together a wine list that is out of the beaten path. Great snacks and pizza cheers to that 👏🥂🥂
It‘s a nice Italian restaurant. The pizza and the caprese sandwich were both amazing. I really recommend going.
We are literally here, at the restaurant. The food was fantastic! Lasagna, the Alla Vodka sauce, Rigatoni Bolognese were all fantastic! Service was great and attentive!! Highly recommend!
Pizza was dried and spicy. I got the pepperoni one, my friend got Calabrese eggs and they were pretty good actually. Service was good. Waiter was good. I just wish the pizza was good.
Tuscan Italian, Fantastic, great staff, incredible food and atmosphere
Delicious food, great and welcoming service, quick delivery of food, good vibe. All of these make this restaurant special.
This place is fab. The food and service were top notch.
The espresso martinis are a must. And the ricotta !
I was just there the other evening. I had the pepperoni pizza. It was very good and the service was good.
I visited this restaurant back in May with my husband on a Wednesday afternoon, and we had a great experience. Since it wasn’t too busy at that time, we were seated quickly, and the service was attentive and friendly throughout.
The food was genuinely fantastic—we loved every dish we tried. We got the arancini and calamari as our appetizers, and shared the tartufo pizza and penne bolognese. My husband always tries a local beer wherever we go, and I usually go for sangria/spritz if it’s on the menu—in this case I got the peach spritz and it was so refreshing!
Whenever we’re back in Montauk, this will definitely be our go-to lunch spot. Prices were what you’d expect for Montauk, on the higher end, but for a day trip, it felt well worth the splurge.
It’s a lovely restaurant with delicious food in a historical architecture. Only thing I notice that’s not perfect is ventilation of their kitchen, you might end up with smelling like food on your clothes for a few days after visiting.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I was out at The End for a night and stopped in for dinner. This is such a cute restaurant right in the heart of Montauk proper. There are rounded windows all the way around the restaurant giving it a very spacious feel. The food was really good; the pasta, the polenta and pizza were all excellent in their own right. Our waitress was attentive and very pleasant.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meatball Appetizer, Burrata Pie, Gluten Free Spaghetti Pomodoro
Really good food and atmosphere. Their pizza is so good, a nice treat all the way out east. Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food here is absolutely fantastic—this is hands-down one of our favorite restaurants anywhere. We’ve been loyal fans of Alimentary Beach since it first opened and make it a point to visit every time we’re in Montauk. The ingredients are top-notch, the service is warm and welcoming, and the wine list is excellent. Unlike many spots in this part of Long Island, they don’t overcharge, which is refreshing.
Do yourself a favor and order the whipped ricotta—it’s out of this world. The meatballs are also a standout, and the Caesar salad is a winner, with a light, non-creamy dressing that’s just right. The shrimp with polenta is hearty and delicious, making it a perfect appetizer to start your meal.
Honestly, I’d drive all the way from the city anytime just to enjoy a meal here and soak in the great vibes. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Friendly place, simple food but delicious. Stop here without heaitation
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
One of my favorite places in montauk just get better and better with the time , GM Gianni, has put together a wine list that is out of the beaten path. Great snacks and pizza cheers to that 👏🥂🥂
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burrata Pizza with Prosciutto
Loading...