What a great Lobster Roll. Kim & Clint our fantastic. Looking forward to going there again soon.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Rogue Guyver
Absolutely excellent gem in Montauk! Locally owned and sourced sea food caught daily by family that has been doing it right for generations. Open year round . They also have homemade famous clam pies, smoked fish dip, lobster rolls and more. I recommend stopping by ! A++
Maria A
Just wow! Such a pleasant surprise! Wild oysters, perfectly opened.. and delicious lobster rolls. An authentic an honest stop! 100% recommend the visit!
Monika
Bennett Shellfish is truly a hidden gem in the local area! The owner Kim is incredibly friendly and genuine, making you feel right at home. The oysters here are hands down the best I've ever had—so fresh and bursting with the flavor of the sea. The warm service provided by the kim makes the whole experience even more delightful. Highly recommended for all seafood lovers! 🦪💯
Bennett Shellfish is truly a local treasure store! Kim, the proprietress, is so nice. Not only is she kind and friendly, but she always makes people feel at home. The oysters here are truly the best I have ever tasted. You can feel the freshness and the taste of the sea in every bite. Kim's warm service made the whole experience even more perfect. Highly recommended to all friends who love seafood! 🦪💯
Tod Schild
Family owned seafood store operating out of their own home. Prices are very fair. Given its location in the now super expensive Montauk, New York area. Always fresh, always good. Try the two for one lobster roll. It’s the best deal on the East End.
Matthew Babich
Kimberley was extremely kind and hospitable. Lobster rolls and tuna were fresh and delicious. A must stop when in mtk!
Linda Anderson
No fish visible, limited choices. I was being helped, someone else walked in and I was then completely ignored. Very disappointing place. Plenty of others to choose so pass this one up.
C M
Cute lil place prices were good too
Jessica Pallotta
Delicious and the owners are such sweethearts!! We will definitely be back!
Erica Reven
WOW! First of all, you can’t beat the price! 2 lobster rolls for $30! One of the restaurants in town sells one lobster roll for $50 and chances are, it’s not as good as this! So fresh and delicious!! And wonderful customer service!
Absolutely awesome if you like your lobster roll cold it’s the absolute best out east ! The star of the show was the smoked fish dip! Don’t miss it !
Scott Jenkins
The best bang for the buck in Montauk …… 2 for 1 lobster rolls at an affordable price. Generous servings of fresh lobster on fresh potato bread.
If you’ve never had a clam pie ……… try one ! It’s a Montauk delicacy.
kristen loyek
Does not get better than this!! Best lobster rolls in Montauk plus the best price!! 2 for $30??? You can’t get one for that anywhere else! They also have amazing fresh catches , I love getting their tuna and make some poke bowls or sashimi! Recently got some live lobsters from them and they were HUGE and so sweet!! Plus the owners Kimberly & Clint are the sweetest couple. They’ve been here for 14 generations!!! Love them and it’s a weekly stop for me and my husband xx tita!!
anne sessler
what can i say than : always the BEST, the FRESHEST, the cleanest, the nicest. so so glad to know them, their place, and their seafood --the only kind we like to eat and know is freshhhhhh. delicious, delightful and plain ole fabulous
jordan elguera
Encountered the rudest lady today. Was going to enjoy a nice lobster roll because we’ve heard great things but were turned off by this employee. Happy to take my business elsewhere.
What a great Lobster Roll. Kim & Clint our fantastic. Looking forward to going there again soon.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Absolutely excellent gem in Montauk! Locally owned and sourced sea food caught daily by family that has been doing it right for generations. Open year round . They also have homemade famous clam pies, smoked fish dip, lobster rolls and more. I recommend stopping by ! A++
Just wow! Such a pleasant surprise! Wild oysters, perfectly opened.. and delicious lobster rolls. An authentic an honest stop! 100% recommend the visit!
Bennett Shellfish is truly a hidden gem in the local area! The owner Kim is incredibly friendly and genuine, making you feel right at home. The oysters here are hands down the best I've ever had—so fresh and bursting with the flavor of the sea. The warm service provided by the kim makes the whole experience even more delightful. Highly recommended for all seafood lovers! 🦪💯
Bennett Shellfish is truly a local treasure store! Kim, the proprietress, is so nice. Not only is she kind and friendly, but she always makes people feel at home. The oysters here are truly the best I have ever tasted. You can feel the freshness and the taste of the sea in every bite. Kim's warm service made the whole experience even more perfect. Highly recommended to all friends who love seafood! 🦪💯
Family owned seafood store operating out of their own home. Prices are very fair. Given its location in the now super expensive Montauk, New York area. Always fresh, always good. Try the two for one lobster roll. It’s the best deal on the East End.
Kimberley was extremely kind and hospitable. Lobster rolls and tuna were fresh and delicious. A must stop when in mtk!
No fish visible, limited choices. I was being helped, someone else walked in and I was then completely ignored. Very disappointing place. Plenty of others to choose so pass this one up.
Cute lil place prices were good too
Delicious and the owners are such sweethearts!! We will definitely be back!
WOW! First of all, you can’t beat the price! 2 lobster rolls for $30! One of the restaurants in town sells one lobster roll for $50 and chances are, it’s not as good as this! So fresh and delicious!! And wonderful customer service!
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely awesome if you like your lobster roll cold it’s the absolute best out east ! The star of the show was the smoked fish dip! Don’t miss it !
The best bang for the buck in Montauk …… 2 for 1 lobster rolls at an affordable price. Generous servings of fresh lobster on fresh potato bread.
If you’ve never had a clam pie ……… try one ! It’s a Montauk delicacy.
Does not get better than this!! Best lobster rolls in Montauk plus the best price!! 2 for $30??? You can’t get one for that anywhere else! They also have amazing fresh catches , I love getting their tuna and make some poke bowls or sashimi! Recently got some live lobsters from them and they were HUGE and so sweet!! Plus the owners Kimberly & Clint are the sweetest couple. They’ve been here for 14 generations!!! Love them and it’s a weekly stop for me and my husband xx tita!!
what can i say than : always the BEST, the FRESHEST, the cleanest, the nicest. so so glad to know them, their place, and their seafood --the only kind we like to eat and know is freshhhhhh. delicious, delightful and plain ole fabulous
Encountered the rudest lady today. Was going to enjoy a nice lobster roll because we’ve heard great things but were turned off by this employee. Happy to take my business elsewhere.
Loading...