Bluestone Lane Montauk Coffee Shop

786 Montauk Hwy, Montauk
(718) 374-6858

Recent Reviews

Kari Feick

Door says daily 7-4.... doors locked at 1314 in the afternoon. Just drove here for no reason

Max Hernandez

Best coffee in the world. We stopped by here on a weekend trip from LES. Amazing vibes and staff , coffee just as equally matched ✅

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sydney Segar

I genuinely love the team this year. I have been going for a few years now. I am remembered by name each time, and have been lucky to befriend them. Great coffee too:)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Griffin Knapp

Coffee was really not good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Worse bacon egg croissant ever. Arrived in 1hr and 20 minutes after ordered. Overnight oats wasn't even 1/4 cup. Awful!!!

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tiara Solomon

Watery latte. But what was most concerning was the barista tipping herself after the last patron forgot to complete the tipping screen. Yikes!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1

Laura Johnson

We stopped here twice for coffee while we were in town and it didn’t disappoint. We tried out their new coconut water cold brew and it was tasty!

Fred Smith

Closed at 9.45 am.

Sarah P.

I thought this coffee shop was okay but nothing special. We were so hot so decided to drop by for some coffee. I ordered one of their iced drinks with frozen ice cream. It was kind of like an affogato. Honestly, it wasn't that great and I ended up throwing half the drink away. It wasn't as sweet as I expected and I felt like it was more bitter than I wanted it to be.

Phoebe Glynn

I absolutely love your location down by Penn station, I love the BLATE. They didn't have it here and I built the sandwich which was perfectly fine and a smoothie. It tasted good however the service was horrible, we saw about 4 people get their entire meals before I even got my smoothie. My partners wrap took about 20 minutes and the chef was on her phone in between making her meal. I love your locations, this one was just a little disappointing

NYCWorld

Great coffee (flat white extra espresso and an iced mocha), tasty banana bread, and excellent service.

Sarah B.

I came in and asked for the blueberry protein smoothie but without the protein. The worker was so rude and told me they don't substitute in smoothies - I said all you have to do is just not put in the protein . She finally agreed. She then proceeded to put oat milk in it(the menu says almond milk) and when I told her I'm allergic and don't drink oat milk she gave me attitude and said the menu is wrong. The smoothie was disgusting and I got the worst stomach ache from it. That employee should be fired because she's rude and lazy. Bye Felicia

Susie J.

The avocado on the avocado toast was completely underripe and the "toast" was a slice of bread. The coffee was amazing, though.

P L.

Great breakfast joint. The bacon egg and cheese is on another level with the special sauce, a must try. Don't be afraid of the people waiting inside, the line goes by quick. You can also order yourself on the tablet on the right. I will definitely come back everyday.

James V.

Great for coffee on the go. Not much indoor space but a few tables are outside . Nonetheless the coffee is fantastic . Def try the nitro oat cream cold brew. I'm a black coffee drinker but this caught my eye and was phenomenal.

Load More

Bluestone Lane Montauk Coffee Shop

786 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954
(718) 374-6858