Gosman's Clam Bar

484 W Lake Dr, Montauk
(631) 668-2549

Recent Reviews

Sort by
leslie cafiso

Lunch n drinks at TOP SIDE. Beautiful view , with boat in n out of the channel

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chowder

Marisa

Convenient spot to grab fast food on the water, however the lobster bisque was more like a meat sauce and made me extremely sick

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 4

MIKE Mayers

Fish and Chips were good. Calamari are good too. Anything lobster is priced very high. I'd probably stick to the above 2 dishes and maybe fries.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Adrian Alonso

Disappointing! The fried seafood combo had literally 2 prawns, a piece of fish (which was quite tasteless), fries and lots of fried clams which was mostly batter, and none of it was warm. The lobster roll was ok, except you don't get a single chunk of lobster (like the really proper ones you would get in Maine or Cape cod) as this is all a mix of shredded lobster with lettuce and condiments... where are the pieces of lobster or claws??? Worst of all, the price is ridiculously expensive for what you get.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Lane Romano

Ordered a lobster roll - lobster itself was good, tasted alittle fishy but I’m used to it (if you know what I mean ?).

It was served on a martins potato roll, which really was detrimental to the experience and left me pissed off. $38 dollars for a lobster roll on a martins potato roll is ridiculous. Place should be avoided, I’d order the lobster roll but prepare to bring your own roll.

Keith Alpert

I went to the clam bar today, craving fried clams. Ordered the fried clam plate for myself and my 2 guests and was extremely disappointed. Barely tasted any clam through the breading. I grew up loving fried clams, have not had them in a while, and was so excited for them. What a let down.

Kai Eggert

Seafood at it's best

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephanie Sanmartin

Awesome food!

Carol Russotto

It has gotten SO much better since my last review. The only thing is I wished the person who cleaned the tables was around .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Chowder, Fish and Chips, French Fries

Brandon Alex

Top 5 worst food we’ve had at a restaurant, ordered a ton of dishes each one was worse than the other. New England clam chowder was a disgusting brown with tons of herbs tasted terrible, the grilled shrimp was just pan seared and tasted terrible, the fried clams were all tiny bits of breading and no clams and tasted terrible, the hot dog was over cooked dry and a stale bun, the muscles were bland and tasted horrible, the salmon was neutral, the French fries were not bad, just really nasty food. Beautiful setting and quick service. Very upset that we wasted a meal here.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Diane McConnell

The view is beautiful, server behind the take out was lovely. We ordered 1 lobster bisque and 1 New England Clam Chowder. Both were horrible.I can't tell which was worse. Both went in the garbage. Will head elsewhere for a meal.Sorry Gossmans.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 2

Joshua S

went for lunch. the seafood diavolo beat my expectations with tasty sauce and the waiter/service was decent. just high priced for what it is so minus one star for that. didnt get drinks so cant comment.

tocker O

Way overpriced. It has potential for drinks as you watch ships pass, but don’t waste your time or money to eat here. Huge restaurant but had lots of open tables for good reason.Lobster: $40 snd wasn’t as advertised or ordered. Supposed to be 1.5lbs, but was more like a pound. Very over cooked. Meat couldn’t be separated from the shell.Dozen Mussels: 3-4 mussels were missing. Not a big deal if you’re paying $10-12 for a dozen, but it costs $20. Brought the shortfall to the attention of the waiter who was annoyed so he took his time to return with more. Had the audacity to ask ‘Really? You want 3-4 mussels’.Overall, great potential but failed miserably. Don’t think anyone cared.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 1

Chi Vu

Great view of the harbor, this place is the spot to watch boats and yachts sailing by. The seafood was fresh, we had a lobster and it was absolutely lovely.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

James Oswald

Had a great steak and mashed potatoes here. Service was very good.

Loading...