Herb's Market

778 Montauk Hwy, Montauk
(631) 668-2335

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jessica Haenel

That’s gotta be hands down best fried chicken

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Caroline Dudley

This is your sign from the universe to get the European sandwich. The sandwiches here are no joke. Don’t sleep on this deli, they mean business, holy moly!!!

Food: 5

Sara Villegas

There aren't many options for things but you find the basics, it's fine for something basic that you need. We went in autumn, this may be why.

David Bera

Very slow and rude. Left after 15 minutes

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Rich H.

A Montauk institution, best fried chicken on the island! But be prepared to pay!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Fried Chicken

Devin Byrnes

I wanted to like this spot, it had an old school deli vibe. 2 of the del counter workers were cool. The taller Latina was on her headset and working in slow motion. Made us a "grilled cheese " in the toaster over for $9. The exhaust hood was in bad need on a cleaning, place just seemed pricey and the workers, with the exception of ( the latin guy ,w/ a goatee) behind the counter,seemed checked out. Sloppily wrapped sandwiches, lil hustle,care or personality. Place charges premium prices though

Robin Shapiro

Nice to be able to close at 4:00 when closing time is 5:00. Not much choice here either. Glad that Hooked was open or there would have been nothing for dinner.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Fried Chicken

Timothy Cullinan

Best fried chicken...

Robert Bacchi

A bit pricey but excellent product quality. Sandwiches are excellent as is the fried chicken.

Barney Simon

The people are always nice The service is prompt The quality of the food is always excellent.

Justa Foodie

Friendly staff. Great quality beef that we cooked on the grill and enjoyed their homemade potato and corn salads

Top Math

Be careful the workers here only care about getting food out not about how it tastes, they are careless with orders forget items often and constantly mix up my order, you can make the same quality food at home for cheaper just visit IGA instead or go to Goldbergs

Suzanne Schmitt

The BEST egg sandwich ! My brother and sister owned a deli 20 years, and you nailed it !!!

pina sarlo

Always a great go too!! Fresh and fast!!

Tony Perry

Loved my sandwich mmm

Loading...