Montauk Market Café and Deli

805 Montauk Hwy #1, Montauk
(631) 668-2071

Recent Reviews

Alessandra Alves Matos

I had the best taco bowl ever.Its more than enough for one person to eat.The place is so clean, and the service is great!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Whitney T.

My visit to Montauk Market left me utterly disappointed and frustrated. I ordered their 'avocado toast,' only to discover an egg on top, triggering my severe allergy. When I returned to have it remade, I was appalled to find a clerk carrying a dog in the kitchen—an unacceptable practice for food safety.Despite explaining my allergy and discomfort with their handling of pets near food preparation areas, the clerk adamantly refused a refund, insisting I should have known about the egg. This refusal was coupled with an attempt to charge me for hot water, a basic service I expected to complement my purchased tea.The confrontational attitude and the disregard for customer safety and satisfaction were unsettling. As a person of color, I couldn't shake the feeling that prejudice may have influenced their treatment.I implore anyone considering Montauk Market to reconsider. The lack of regard for allergies, food safety, and customer respect is disheartening. Avoid this establishment if you value proper food handling and a welcoming environment.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jennifer Lazo

Amazing Food & Drinks, Great Service!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Liz

Very disappointed, Chicken cutlet Sandwich was like leather, absolutely inedible!!!!! Worse Sandwich I ever had!!!

Food: 1

Frank Kingsley

Fair selection, workers were nice. Pastries half off after 4-5ish. Good prices too. I liked this deli/grocery

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marco Avila Paredes

Excelent attention & delicious food

b jalette

Third time I’ve been here. The recipes are authentic and delicious! ???. Their fresh pico and homemade hot sauces are so, SO good! Heavenly!Great, sunny area upfront to relax and have breakfast. Staff super-kind, too Highly recommend!!

Marc Le Sieur

Great smoothie menu with possible extras, friendly early morning service. Good value breakfast on location.

ben jalet

Third time I’ve been here. The recipes are authentic and delicious! ???. Their fresh pico and homemade hot sauces are so, SO good! Heavenly!Great, sunny area upfront to relax and have breakfast. Staff super-kind, too Highly recommend!!

Noe Rose Travels

Very nice little store with lots of healthy menu choices. I had the Buddha Bowl and that was good. Worth the stop!

Prince Chowdhury

Price is Way too much ! Arizona this is supposed to be 1$ , they charged 3.80$ , I am shocked ! And everything I have seen overpriced ! The food may be good , I wouldn’t recommend for price range! ToO high!

Larry B.

If their sandwiches were a little better I would be going back there, but they cheap out on ingredients and don't make sandwiches with passion

Yesenia G.

Still my go to place! Breakfast wraps, smoothies, sandwiches, amazing baked goods, this place has it all! Great drinks selection and bagged ice too so pack the cooler and head to the beach.

Daniel Kent

Everything from the cold drinks to the sandwiches are over priced. Huge rip off for what it is , even for Montauk.

philip konop

Great family store with things to enjoy and good breakfast.

Load More