This is our go to whe. We are out in Montauk. We usually do lunch but this time we did dinner and wow were we blown away.
We had a salmon dinner with creative and ample sides and also a penne with fennel which the pink vodka sauce was in my opinion best I ever had .. also had the portobello burger with this pesto and fig sauce that blew me away .
Honestly for all the new and choices joints in Montauk for the Price point, serving size and QUALITY ..maybe skip the usual tourist traps by the water and try this local town gem. We ha e consistently eaten there for 15 years and never ever disappoints.
Keep doing what ya doing NG see you in 2026
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lynette Kamimura
Great spot for casual vegan eats or an iced tea/iced coffee when we're in Montauk
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Hang Le
One of the cashiers was very rude and I hope I’m wrong, but she made me feel that I’m being discriminated against by my race (I’m the only Asian in the whole restaurant at that time)! I went there for the first time to get breakfast and I had an egg tortilla with avocado. The food was good so I decided to come back for lunch. I picked up a tuna sandwich and a chicken wrap, and got in line to get checked out. Despite being the first in line, the cashier told me that somebody else will check me out, and proceed to check out for a group behind me. I had to wait and two groups behind me were already being checked out, until another cashier came back and offered to check me out! This experience is very frustrating! I hope nobody else has to experience what I went through, and I wrote this comment to let people aware of this so they can avoid this restaurant! Hope you all have a great day! And the places you go to offer you fair service!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Neha A
Just rating for the food. It's completely cold and doesn't taste great. If you're looking for bagels, they only have 1 type. Coffee wasn't good either. I'm actually surprised at the 4.5 star rating.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Regina Martinez
I tried their sandwiches and everything was super fresh and organic. The staff was really friendly, and the flavor was great. Quick service and perfect packaging for takeout.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
richard duenas
Great food , nice staff. Nice outdoor area to eat! Tofu scramble burrito is the best I've had yet. Near all.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Talia DiLandro
What an amazing little gem! Love anywhere that offers plenty of options for those of us with food allergies and sensitivities. Stopped here twice on my brief stay in Montauk this week. Just about everything I had was excellent. The egg salad was phenomenal, the blondie and carrot cake in a cup were both delicious. The beet salad and tuna wrap were so good and fresh. Service was lovely, very warm and friendly staff. Should you ever want to open a location in Queens, I will be a loyal customer LOL!
One small area with room for improvement, I wasn’t crazy about was the chocolate chip cookie, it was pretty hard and lacked flavor which surprised me because everything else I had was so full of flavor/moist etc. Won’t take off a star for this as it wouldn't ever deter me from coming back. Things happen.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barney Simon
Why did it take me so long to try this place? Nothing elaborate, just good honest food. Our group has the vegetable chili, and a couple of the sandwiches. Everyone was impressed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robin Shapiro
Great salads and prepared foods. Baked goods less than desirable.
Naturally Good is primarily a charming place where you can feel like a home away from home in Italy – the coziest café and health food store in all of Montauk. I truly hope to return soon to enjoy the best Pumpkin Spice cappuccino ever! It was truly a pleasure! Silvia☺️
Teal Stacy
First off, the cashiers are incredibly rude. I ordered three decaf espresso shots over ice with water because they don’t have decaf coffee. It was $7, more than a latte. I had already paid and I asked why it was $7. They charged me $2 extra for one extra shot and a $1 extra for the larger cup. I said, you’re charging me a $1 extra when I’m only getting more water. I said only do 1 shot and please refund me the the 3rd and just give me the smaller cup, I’m not paying $1 extra for more tap water. The woman said was refunding me $3 at the register. I asked her if she needed my card to scan it and she said no it would go through without it. It never went through because she is a liar and just made it up. Very bad business practice and ethics.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
T Jacobs
First off, the cashiers are incredibly rude. I ordered three decaf espresso shots over ice with water because they don’t have decaf coffee. It was $7, more than a latte. I had already paid and I asked why it was $7. They charged me $2 extra for one extra shot and a $1 extra for the larger cup. I said, you’re charging me a $1 extra when I’m only getting more water. I said only do 1 shot and please refund me the the 3rd and just give me the smaller cup, I’m not paying $1 extra for more tap water. The woman said was refunding me $3 at the register. I asked her if she needed my card to scan it and she said no it would go through without it. It never went through because she is a liar and just made it up. Very bad business practice and ethics.
This is our go to whe. We are out in Montauk. We usually do lunch but this time we did dinner and wow were we blown away.
We had a salmon dinner with creative and ample sides and also a penne with fennel which the pink vodka sauce was in my opinion best I ever had .. also had the portobello burger with this pesto and fig sauce that blew me away .
Honestly for all the new and choices joints in Montauk for the Price point, serving size and QUALITY ..maybe skip the usual tourist traps by the water and try this local town gem. We ha e consistently eaten there for 15 years and never ever disappoints.
Keep doing what ya doing NG see you in 2026
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great spot for casual vegan eats or an iced tea/iced coffee when we're in Montauk
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
One of the cashiers was very rude and I hope I’m wrong, but she made me feel that I’m being discriminated against by my race (I’m the only Asian in the whole restaurant at that time)! I went there for the first time to get breakfast and I had an egg tortilla with avocado. The food was good so I decided to come back for lunch. I picked up a tuna sandwich and a chicken wrap, and got in line to get checked out. Despite being the first in line, the cashier told me that somebody else will check me out, and proceed to check out for a group behind me. I had to wait and two groups behind me were already being checked out, until another cashier came back and offered to check me out! This experience is very frustrating! I hope nobody else has to experience what I went through, and I wrote this comment to let people aware of this so they can avoid this restaurant! Hope you all have a great day! And the places you go to offer you fair service!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Just rating for the food. It's completely cold and doesn't taste great. If you're looking for bagels, they only have 1 type. Coffee wasn't good either. I'm actually surprised at the 4.5 star rating.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
I tried their sandwiches and everything was super fresh and organic. The staff was really friendly, and the flavor was great. Quick service and perfect packaging for takeout.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Great food , nice staff. Nice outdoor area to eat! Tofu scramble burrito is the best I've had yet. Near all.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
What an amazing little gem! Love anywhere that offers plenty of options for those of us with food allergies and sensitivities. Stopped here twice on my brief stay in Montauk this week. Just about everything I had was excellent. The egg salad was phenomenal, the blondie and carrot cake in a cup were both delicious. The beet salad and tuna wrap were so good and fresh. Service was lovely, very warm and friendly staff. Should you ever want to open a location in Queens, I will be a loyal customer LOL!
One small area with room for improvement, I wasn’t crazy about was the chocolate chip cookie, it was pretty hard and lacked flavor which surprised me because everything else I had was so full of flavor/moist etc. Won’t take off a star for this as it wouldn't ever deter me from coming back. Things happen.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Why did it take me so long to try this place? Nothing elaborate, just good honest food. Our group has the vegetable chili, and a couple of the sandwiches. Everyone was impressed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great salads and prepared foods.
Baked goods less than desirable.
Great tofu scramble burrito and great coffee
Restaurantji Recommends
Great Fish Tacos!!! And awesome local owners
Really nice vegan tofu Cajun wrap!
Naturally Good is primarily a charming place where you can feel like a home away from home in Italy – the coziest café and health food store in all of Montauk. I truly hope to return soon to enjoy the best Pumpkin Spice cappuccino ever! It was truly a pleasure!
Silvia☺️
First off, the cashiers are incredibly rude. I ordered three decaf espresso shots over ice with water because they don’t have decaf coffee. It was $7, more than a latte. I had already paid and I asked why it was $7. They charged me $2 extra for one extra shot and a $1 extra for the larger cup. I said, you’re charging me a $1 extra when I’m only getting more water. I said only do 1 shot and please refund me the the 3rd and just give me the smaller cup, I’m not paying $1 extra for more tap water. The woman said was refunding me $3 at the register. I asked her if she needed my card to scan it and she said no it would go through without it. It never went through because she is a liar and just made it up. Very bad business practice and ethics.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
First off, the cashiers are incredibly rude. I ordered three decaf espresso shots over ice with water because they don’t have decaf coffee. It was $7, more than a latte. I had already paid and I asked why it was $7. They charged me $2 extra for one extra shot and a $1 extra for the larger cup. I said, you’re charging me a $1 extra when I’m only getting more water. I said only do 1 shot and please refund me the the 3rd and just give me the smaller cup, I’m not paying $1 extra for more tap water. The woman said was refunding me $3 at the register. I asked her if she needed my card to scan it and she said no it would go through without it. It never went through because she is a liar and just made it up. Very bad business practice and ethics.
Loading...