Naturally Good Market

779 Montauk Hwy, Montauk
(631) 668-9030

Recent Reviews

Julie C.

What we had from Naturally Good was good, but we went there twice and both times had issues getting what we ordered. The first day they were out of several items and that wasn't communicated to us until after we went up to the counter and tried to order again. On the 2nd day, I called in an order ahead of time and then experienced several issues and we almost missed a boat because of it. The manager/owner was kind in trying to rectify the problem, but it really left us scrambling. The food itself is solid though, especially "the kim" breakfast sandwich.

Melissa M.

Love this place! So many vegan accommodations and delicious food. I do wish they didn't upcharge for all the vegan items but out in montauk, as a vegan, you take what you can get. Staff super friendly and helpful as well. Looking forward to going back in a few months.

njrafter

A great natural foos market and deli. I had the Bruce, a yellow fin tuna salad sandwich on sprouted wheat bread. My husband a The Monster, a double serving of the Bruce, on a GF wrap. We both enjoyed it. We ordered a side order of guacamole and chips, which was smaller than expected for $11. But otherwise definitely recommend it.

Lola F.

Fresh and well made healthy food for the beach or take it outside and sit in the back. Wait can be long so call in your order. Smoothies are the best and lots of gluten free and meat free options for breakfast and lunch. I love the mini muffins and a hot coffee and the grab and go salads are great for the beach. Soups in the fall are usually pretty good as well.

Julia A.

This place is superb with not a long wait, great juices, breakfast options, and to go salads. Amazing customer service and nice cashiers. Prefer to go here, rather than Joni's when in Montauk!

Ed R.

Our go to spot for organic breakfast in Montauk. Great food, very convenient, and comfortable outdoor seating in the back. Can't go wrong here.

Kelly O.

Can only speak to the smoothies but they were DELICIOUS. We got the berry hydrating and the funky monkey- both were perfection. Great little spot.

Julia21136

i got one smoothie there and it was all right. They have amazing selection, i wish i stayed and tried other flavors

Emily R.

DO NOT COME HERE IF YOU HAVE A FOOD ALLERGY! I have celiac and I came here for a gluten free bagel with cream cheese and bacon. It was tiny. The next day we go back to give it another chance and the girl tells us the "fakin bacon" isn't gluten free, so the day before we had eaten gluten without knowing it. They advertise as a health food store but we could've gotten really sick!! Skip if you have a food allergy!!!

Archana P.

Back to basics. Simple food done right. The menu is large, no major frills. Everything is consistently high quality and delicious. Easy, breezy, yummy.

Sam B.

I don't like there customers service! My first time going there one lady gave me attitude for asking for my online order and I was asking very nicely if I could pick up my food. Then the second time I wanted to give it another try, I was waiting for a couple minutes outside the window to pick up my online order over the window, but no one showed up, so I walked in thinking it was allowed since I couldn't get there attention no one gave me any service so I grabbed my food and left, they saw me there, but acted like I wasn't so I wouldn't bother to give any stars food is okay not the best but I have more than 5 years of customer service experience and this was the worst on my list. They were not busy at all both times I was the only customer there and 4 staff, just sad there getting all these poor reviews and not doing anything to fix there mistakes because it keeps happening by seeing others reviews.

Christina Ward

Loved the salad

Ethan R.

Amazing smoothies and great vegan snacks and pastries! Will definitely be back and would recommend to anyone looking for some healthy options!

Kirsten Smith

Great variety of organic dishes, delicious!

Mandi S.

It's crazy to think I was born and raised on Long Island, but I've never been to "The End". We drove out here on my birthday with my hubs and little one. After exploring the beautiful lighthouse and beach area, we were hungry!!! Not much open at this time of the year - in fact, we visited the lighthouse on the last day of the season when the inside museum and gift shop would be open until spring! Thanks to Yelp, this place came up - vegetarian fun fare with a few things to satisfy meat eaters too? Sign me up! I opted for the Cajun tofu sandwich. My son got the chicken quesadilla and my hubs got a spicy black bean burrito. I added a hot chai for myself with almond milk and we grabbed a fruit smoothie too. A fruit smoothie in the cold you're thinking! Ahh, throw caution to the wind once in awhile! The Cajun tofu was 5/5, fantastic! Perfectly cooked and great seasoning. The sauce it came with was also really tasty. My son said his quesadilla was "better than Chipotle" and coming from a Chipotle loving 5 year old, that's saying a lot! The hubs loved his too. They all came with chips, which I'm not a big fan of corn chips but these weren't too bad. Still, the boys were a fan and ate them up (we even had a bit left over to bring home that were snacked on the next day). The smoothie was average and so was the chai. I usually prefer a little more body to my chai, but I appreciate that this chai wasn't overly sweet like many can be. It was a bit pricey but hey - this is Montauk so it's to be expected. The quality of the food was good and it was fresh and tasty. Next time we drive sunrise till we hit water, we'll be back here again. Sorry for no pics - it was chilly and we were eating our food on a bench trying to balance boxes, sandwiches and napkins.

Load More