Montauk Seafood Company is an absolute must-visit every time I’m in Montauk. As a seafood market, it goes above and beyond. The clams are outstanding—consistently fresh and flavorful. Chris is a real mensch; he’s incredibly friendly, helpful, and accommodating, making every visit a memorable experience with his warm demeanor and excellent service.
This market truly has everything you need for an incredible seafood meal. If we’re lucky enough to stay somewhere with a kitchenette, I always grab a few dozen clams to make spaghetti alle vongole—it’s become a tradition.
Montauk Seafood Company is hands-down my favorite seafood market anywhere. If you’re in Montauk, do yourself a favor and stop by. Support this gem of a business—you won’t regret it. I absolutely love this place!
Scott Paladini
Fresh seafood to take home. Friendly/helpful guy at the counter.
Ari T
I’ve ordered steamed and cracked lobster in a tray from here three times this summer and it got better each time! Absolutely fresh and delicious. Reasonably priced. Probably the best price you’ll get in town. The 2+ pound lobsters are quite the royal experience.
Theres also lemon. butter, cocktail sauce, and more for sale to complete your dining experience. Grab a tray and head out to the beach to dig in with no shame.
D A
So good and the man who was working there was so kind ??
Mr. Sook
I can personally vouch there seafood is Fresh because it gets flown in non stop flights from Northern Pacific. It’s not sitting on a boat or truck for week or 2 in transit .
Rachel Rapisarda
Such a nice family owned shop with great, fresh food - a must visit!
Екатерина Зеленина
Perfect oysters - incredibly fresh and tasty. Amazing lobster rolls - full of lobster salad. And the most important great thing is people who works there. They were so nice! They helped me with decision around what to take (and they were right!). And also they helped me to take my food to car.
Jason Belkin
Honestly, EVEYTHING is delicious here! You actually can not go wrong. #eatlikealocal
Patrick Saverino
Came back here after our great experience last year. Tried the oysters this time around and they were also delicious!! Better than anything we have had in a restaurant, and so fresh! Will be back tomorrow for more!
Mari
The crab cakes are very good. All crab. The fries are also amazing if you like lightly crispy fries with a soft potato-y inside.
The freshest, tastiest clams on a half shell that I have ever had! Super friendly staff. Ate them out of the back of my SUV, but still amazing!
Danielle Kalafut
Best guy ever / gave us 2 oysters for appetizer tooo go delicious
Joseph Kim
Amazing shellfish, fresh and deliciously prepared.
Rick Tse
Good value for money and excellent service
Jodie Defato
Amazing experience!!Customer service is above and beyond!! Chris was super amazing shucking our daily oyster and clam orders. Extremely nice, helpful, and of course the seafood was amazing!! Looking forward to next year already!
Montauk Seafood Company is an absolute must-visit every time I’m in Montauk. As a seafood market, it goes above and beyond. The clams are outstanding—consistently fresh and flavorful. Chris is a real mensch; he’s incredibly friendly, helpful, and accommodating, making every visit a memorable experience with his warm demeanor and excellent service.
This market truly has everything you need for an incredible seafood meal. If we’re lucky enough to stay somewhere with a kitchenette, I always grab a few dozen clams to make spaghetti alle vongole—it’s become a tradition.
Montauk Seafood Company is hands-down my favorite seafood market anywhere. If you’re in Montauk, do yourself a favor and stop by. Support this gem of a business—you won’t regret it. I absolutely love this place!
Fresh seafood to take home. Friendly/helpful guy at the counter.
I’ve ordered steamed and cracked lobster in a tray from here three times this summer and it got better each time! Absolutely fresh and delicious. Reasonably priced. Probably the best price you’ll get in town. The 2+ pound lobsters are quite the royal experience.
Theres also lemon. butter, cocktail sauce, and more for sale to complete your dining experience. Grab a tray and head out to the beach to dig in with no shame.
So good and the man who was working there was so kind ??
I can personally vouch there seafood is Fresh because it gets flown in non stop flights from Northern Pacific. It’s not sitting on a boat or truck for week or 2 in transit .
Such a nice family owned shop with great, fresh food - a must visit!
Perfect oysters - incredibly fresh and tasty. Amazing lobster rolls - full of lobster salad. And the most important great thing is people who works there. They were so nice! They helped me with decision around what to take (and they were right!). And also they helped me to take my food to car.
Honestly, EVEYTHING is delicious here! You actually can not go wrong. #eatlikealocal
Came back here after our great experience last year. Tried the oysters this time around and they were also delicious!! Better than anything we have had in a restaurant, and so fresh! Will be back tomorrow for more!
The crab cakes are very good. All crab. The fries are also amazing if you like lightly crispy fries with a soft potato-y inside.
Restaurantji Recommends
The freshest, tastiest clams on a half shell that I have ever had! Super friendly staff. Ate them out of the back of my SUV, but still amazing!
Best guy ever / gave us 2 oysters for appetizer tooo go delicious
Amazing shellfish, fresh and deliciously prepared.
Good value for money and excellent service
Amazing experience!!Customer service is above and beyond!! Chris was super amazing shucking our daily oyster and clam orders. Extremely nice, helpful, and of course the seafood was amazing!! Looking forward to next year already!
Loading...