The crab cakes are very good. All crab. The fries are also amazing if you like lightly crispy fries with a soft potato-y inside.
Melissa Saverino
The freshest, tastiest clams on a half shell that I have ever had! Super friendly staff. Ate them out of the back of my SUV, but still amazing!
Danielle Kalafut
Best guy ever / gave us 2 oysters for appetizer tooo go delicious
Stephen M.
He was very helpful and knowledgeable about what kind of fish we would enjoy for our family while visiting the area. The fish and shrimp was incredibly fresh and he even threw in a few extra shrimp just to make our day a little better!
Joseph Kim
Amazing shellfish, fresh and deliciously prepared.
Rick Tse
Good value for money and excellent service
Jodie Defato
Amazing experience!!Customer service is above and beyond!! Chris was super amazing shucking our daily oyster and clam orders. Extremely nice, helpful, and of course the seafood was amazing!! Looking forward to next year already!
Kevin Caballes
Tom lob or the soft shell crab sandwich!
Lee West
Do not miss this place! My favorite place to get lunch in montauk. Order either the tuna or swordfish filet on a salad. Can’t speak for any other order but these are A+
Minji Jung
Amazing fresh oysters and littlenecks! Better than any restaurant we’ve been to in Montauk - had to go back for more right after trying our first dozen :) There were no seating available but the food was nicely packaged so you could bring them to any picnic spot around town.
Great place to enjoy fresh oysters and clams. Stuff is super friendly. Their smoked fish spread is a must have. Great selection of crackers, olives, spreads and seasoning. Definitely coming back!
Lorraine A.
Pass on the Scottish farm raised salmon. Disappointing. No flavor. Soft texture. Lesson learned, only buy local.
Deb C.
Montauk is lucky to have this new fish market right in town. It's clean as a whistle, and the fish is as local and fresh as it gets. Peterson's makes it easy to quickly grab all you'd need to throw together a last minute, no fuss, gourmet meal that will be sure to impress your guests. It's obvious that the owners take a lot of pride in their business. I'll definitely be a repeat customer. They have the best shrimp and cocktail sauce. In fact, everyone in my family agrees that it's the best we've ever had!
Robert Aaronson
Fresh Local Seafood Hand Picked by Wes Daily.We also enjoyed the Steak he carries..highly recommend this Market!!!
John Termini
These guys are friendly, knowledgeable, service is great, they are fisherman so they know their fish and it’s a good vibe. Support local.
The crab cakes are very good. All crab. The fries are also amazing if you like lightly crispy fries with a soft potato-y inside.
The freshest, tastiest clams on a half shell that I have ever had! Super friendly staff. Ate them out of the back of my SUV, but still amazing!
Best guy ever / gave us 2 oysters for appetizer tooo go delicious
He was very helpful and knowledgeable about what kind of fish we would enjoy for our family while visiting the area. The fish and shrimp was incredibly fresh and he even threw in a few extra shrimp just to make our day a little better!
Amazing shellfish, fresh and deliciously prepared.
Good value for money and excellent service
Amazing experience!!Customer service is above and beyond!! Chris was super amazing shucking our daily oyster and clam orders. Extremely nice, helpful, and of course the seafood was amazing!! Looking forward to next year already!
Tom lob or the soft shell crab sandwich!
Do not miss this place! My favorite place to get lunch in montauk. Order either the tuna or swordfish filet on a salad. Can’t speak for any other order but these are A+
Amazing fresh oysters and littlenecks! Better than any restaurant we’ve been to in Montauk - had to go back for more right after trying our first dozen :) There were no seating available but the food was nicely packaged so you could bring them to any picnic spot around town.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great place to enjoy fresh oysters and clams. Stuff is super friendly. Their smoked fish spread is a must have. Great selection of crackers, olives, spreads and seasoning. Definitely coming back!
Pass on the Scottish farm raised salmon. Disappointing. No flavor. Soft texture. Lesson learned, only buy local.
Montauk is lucky to have this new fish market right in town. It's clean as a whistle, and the fish is as local and fresh as it gets. Peterson's makes it easy to quickly grab all you'd need to throw together a last minute, no fuss, gourmet meal that will be sure to impress your guests. It's obvious that the owners take a lot of pride in their business. I'll definitely be a repeat customer. They have the best shrimp and cocktail sauce. In fact, everyone in my family agrees that it's the best we've ever had!
Fresh Local Seafood Hand Picked by Wes Daily.We also enjoyed the Steak he carries..highly recommend this Market!!!
These guys are friendly, knowledgeable, service is great, they are fisherman so they know their fish and it’s a good vibe. Support local.