We had a great meal here last night. We enjoyed the kale salad, the fluke sashimi and the shrimp tacos. All were prepared really creatively with excellent ingredients. It was such a pleasant surprise to find such a good meal. Also had a really great cocktail. We were in Montauk for the weekend, and this was our first time to this restaurant. We will definitely come again. Take a look at the menu on the restaurant's website because the one on OpenTable was not accurate. Prices were lower at the restaurant website and were the accurate ones.
The service was awesome but the food was just ok. I don't think I would pick this place again. The only thing that was great was the appetiser kale salad and the French fries. It was disappointing
Toni Negron
This was the best experience! The food was amazing and we had such a fun time. As soon as you walk in the staff was so welcoming! Ashley took care of us and made our night! She was so warm and fun. We had the absolute best night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Morgan Siegel
This place is amazing. Great food with one of the only real smash burgers in town. Also great are their Buffalo Chicken Bites (basically an elevated version of boneless Buffalo wings) with a fancy blue cheese dip. Whatever you do don't sleep on any of their desserts! The head chef and owner Frankie makes some of the most delicious delectable desserts on Long Island! Anything on their dessert menu is straight fire!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookie
Diana Brody
This is my favorite restaurant in the hamptons. The food is always soooo good and the service is great. Highly recommend, I send all my friends here when they go out to montauk!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
CyndeeL
I highly recommend this restaurant. The food was unbelievable the service was exceptional the atmosphere of the restaurant is very warm ,cozy clean and very inviting. Everything from appetizers, main course and desserts were spectacular. Oh and can't forget the choice of great cocktails. They are having bingo Sunday night at 7 can't wait to go. Hope to see a you all there , you won't regret it.
Daniel Chayes
The main entrees took 2 hours to come out, they spilled a drink on two of our dinner members, they added 20% gratuity and wouldn’t let us take it off, wouldn’t compensate us for the two hour wait for food, and the waiter was offended that we even asked. To add to it, half our guests hated their meal. Probably because half of it was sitting in the kitchen for an hour and then microwaved before being served.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Anthony Lanieri
Over the summer I dined at South Edison in Montauk multiple times and it was truly an exceptional experience. I’ve been looking to write this review for some time now!The menu featured an array of dishes that not only showcased culinary creativity but also highlighted the use of fresh, high-quality ingredients. Each bite was a burst of flavors, leaving a lasting impression.The ambiance at South Edison is unparalleled – a perfect blend of coastal charm and a laid-back atmosphere. The rustic yet modern decor creates a welcoming space that complements the seaside location. Whether you're looking for a romantic evening or a casual meal with friends, the restaurant's vibes cater to all.The service was impeccable, with a staff that exuded professionalism and genuine warmth. From recommendations to attentiveness, the team at South Edison made sure every aspect of our dining experience was top-notch.Overall, South Edison is a gem in Montauk, offering not just a meal but a memorable culinary journey. The combination of amazing food, great vibes, and excellent service makes it a must-visit for anyone seeking a delightful dining experience on the East End.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Alaska, Truffle Fries, Scallop Ceviche, Street Corn, Seared Rare Yellowfin Tuna, South Ed Baked Clams, Duck Fat Fries, Seared Yellowfin Tuna, Scallop Crudo, Scallops with Mushrooms, Lemongrass Local Fluke a La Plancha
Yigit Gungor
The food is okay overall, nice environment, good service, but the gluten free chocolate chip cookie with hazelnut gelato is would literally make me drive out here.Dietary restrictions: They have a huge gluten free menu.
keep an eye on the chef !!!! Frank amazing food great ideas wonderful drinks.. I had black and blue. scallops duck fat fries and rick shrimpDietary restrictions: I am gluten, soy dairy, and egg free… Frank marked up a menu for me. He’s so accommodating and wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Duck Fat Fries, Scallop Crudo
Michael Pisula
Friendly staff. Food was interesting and local but there was a very large group (half of restaurant) so the food came out cold. Would give them another chance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
LarryM
First time dining at South Edison. It was recommended to me by a friend. The staff were friendly and professional. They made you feel like they were there for you. Great starting point by offering a creative, delicious and wide variety of cocktails. My group went with ordering several appetizers. Some of the apps that stood out were the fried olives (I never had fried olives. Which were good.), Crispy Rock Shrimp (Delicious! Better than shrimp.), Duck Fat Fries, Lamb Empanadas (S. Edison hit this one out of the park! Mmmmm Mmmm) and the Buffalo Chicken Bites ( the sauce was outstanding!). If you're ever in the neighborhood and you want some delicious and creative cocktails and good food. This is one of those places you need to try.
Larry
First time dining at South Edison. It was recommended to me by a friend. The staff were friendly and professional. They made you feel like they were there for you. Great starting point by offering a creative, delicious and wide variety of cocktails. My group went with ordering several appetizers. Some of the apps that stood out were the fried olives (I never had fried olives. Which were good.), Crispy Rock Shrimp (Delicious! Better than shrimp.), Duck Fat Fries, Lamb Empanadas (S. Edison hit this one out of the park! Mmmmm Mmmm) and the Buffalo Chicken Bites ( the sauce was outstanding!). If you're ever in the neighborhood and you want some delicious and creative cocktails and good food. This is one of those places you need to try.
KimberlyG
Our daughter has Celiac disease and this was the spot for our family. Everything was offered mainly gluten free which was such a comfort for us. The duck was impeccable. Will be back for our next trip to montauk ?.
We had a great meal here last night. We enjoyed the kale salad, the fluke sashimi and the shrimp tacos. All were prepared really creatively with excellent ingredients. It was such a pleasant surprise to find such a good meal. Also had a really great cocktail. We were in Montauk for the weekend, and this was our first time to this restaurant. We will definitely come again. Take a look at the menu on the restaurant's website because the one on OpenTable was not accurate. Prices were lower at the restaurant website and were the accurate ones.
The service was awesome but the food was just ok. I don't think I would pick this place again. The only thing that was great was the appetiser kale salad and the French fries. It was disappointing
This was the best experience! The food was amazing and we had such a fun time. As soon as you walk in the staff was so welcoming! Ashley took care of us and made our night! She was so warm and fun. We had the absolute best night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is amazing. Great food with one of the only real smash burgers in town. Also great are their Buffalo Chicken Bites (basically an elevated version of boneless Buffalo wings) with a fancy blue cheese dip. Whatever you do don't sleep on any of their desserts! The head chef and owner Frankie makes some of the most delicious delectable desserts on Long Island! Anything on their dessert menu is straight fire!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip Cookie
This is my favorite restaurant in the hamptons. The food is always soooo good and the service is great. Highly recommend, I send all my friends here when they go out to montauk!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I highly recommend this restaurant. The food was unbelievable the service was exceptional the atmosphere of the restaurant is very warm ,cozy clean and very inviting. Everything from appetizers, main course and desserts were spectacular. Oh and can't forget the choice of great cocktails. They are having bingo Sunday night at 7 can't wait to go. Hope to see a you all there , you won't regret it.
The main entrees took 2 hours to come out, they spilled a drink on two of our dinner members, they added 20% gratuity and wouldn’t let us take it off, wouldn’t compensate us for the two hour wait for food, and the waiter was offended that we even asked. To add to it, half our guests hated their meal. Probably because half of it was sitting in the kitchen for an hour and then microwaved before being served.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Over the summer I dined at South Edison in Montauk multiple times and it was truly an exceptional experience. I’ve been looking to write this review for some time now!The menu featured an array of dishes that not only showcased culinary creativity but also highlighted the use of fresh, high-quality ingredients. Each bite was a burst of flavors, leaving a lasting impression.The ambiance at South Edison is unparalleled – a perfect blend of coastal charm and a laid-back atmosphere. The rustic yet modern decor creates a welcoming space that complements the seaside location. Whether you're looking for a romantic evening or a casual meal with friends, the restaurant's vibes cater to all.The service was impeccable, with a staff that exuded professionalism and genuine warmth. From recommendations to attentiveness, the team at South Edison made sure every aspect of our dining experience was top-notch.Overall, South Edison is a gem in Montauk, offering not just a meal but a memorable culinary journey. The combination of amazing food, great vibes, and excellent service makes it a must-visit for anyone seeking a delightful dining experience on the East End.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Alaska, Truffle Fries, Scallop Ceviche, Street Corn, Seared Rare Yellowfin Tuna, South Ed Baked Clams, Duck Fat Fries, Seared Yellowfin Tuna, Scallop Crudo, Scallops with Mushrooms, Lemongrass Local Fluke a La Plancha
The food is okay overall, nice environment, good service, but the gluten free chocolate chip cookie with hazelnut gelato is would literally make me drive out here.Dietary restrictions: They have a huge gluten free menu.
One of the best spots out in Montauk!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
keep an eye on the chef !!!! Frank amazing food great ideas wonderful drinks.. I had black and blue. scallops duck fat fries and rick shrimpDietary restrictions: I am gluten, soy dairy, and egg free… Frank marked up a menu for me. He’s so accommodating and wonderful.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Duck Fat Fries, Scallop Crudo
Friendly staff. Food was interesting and local but there was a very large group (half of restaurant) so the food came out cold. Would give them another chance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
First time dining at South Edison. It was recommended to me by a friend. The staff were friendly and professional. They made you feel like they were there for you. Great starting point by offering a creative, delicious and wide variety of cocktails. My group went with ordering several appetizers. Some of the apps that stood out were the fried olives (I never had fried olives. Which were good.), Crispy Rock Shrimp (Delicious! Better than shrimp.), Duck Fat Fries, Lamb Empanadas (S. Edison hit this one out of the park! Mmmmm Mmmm) and the Buffalo Chicken Bites ( the sauce was outstanding!). If you're ever in the neighborhood and you want some delicious and creative cocktails and good food. This is one of those places you need to try.
First time dining at South Edison. It was recommended to me by a friend. The staff were friendly and professional. They made you feel like they were there for you. Great starting point by offering a creative, delicious and wide variety of cocktails. My group went with ordering several appetizers. Some of the apps that stood out were the fried olives (I never had fried olives. Which were good.), Crispy Rock Shrimp (Delicious! Better than shrimp.), Duck Fat Fries, Lamb Empanadas (S. Edison hit this one out of the park! Mmmmm Mmmm) and the Buffalo Chicken Bites ( the sauce was outstanding!). If you're ever in the neighborhood and you want some delicious and creative cocktails and good food. This is one of those places you need to try.
Our daughter has Celiac disease and this was the spot for our family. Everything was offered mainly gluten free which was such a comfort for us. The duck was impeccable. Will be back for our next trip to montauk ?.