Star Island Grill

59 Star Island Rd, Montauk
(631) 317-0370

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Baked Stuffed Clams

Sweet Potato Fries

Bang Bang Shrimp

Onion Rings

Fish Tacos

Photos

+43 photos

+42 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Doordash

Recent Reviews

Such a lovely venue. This charming yacht club offers a respite from the more heavily touristed areas of Long Island and has a more local feel. The staff were very welcoming and the chef was brilliant too. The restaurant has been recommended to us by Viking Fleet, as somewhere to bring our catch for cooking. We had caught around 5 good sized Porgies and a couple of Sea Bass. The chef turned these into dishes from around the world. Tempura, fish tacos, bang bang salad and a Chinese...

August 2025

We have been going to see Tom at Star Island Grill for quite some time....whether we have fish or not....
He and his crew have treated us to an amazing meal and friendship, each time...
Tonight, he had time to prepare something a little different.... the night before, we were talking about things we like.... and tonight, he prepared 3 dishes with all we talked about... absolutely over the top flavor and quality!
All dishes were Fluke....
1)...

July 2025

They will cook your catch !!
Have them make some fish tacos, some general Tsao and some tempura, all 3 ways are delicious!!
The view of the marina from the restaurant is beautiful, and the service is top notch!
We were a group of 12, and everyone loved the experience

August 2024

More Reviews

Restaurants in Montauk, NY

Star Island Grill

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Star Island Grill