Very friendly atmosphere. I was there on Monday night and they had live music it was one of the best bandsYou have to go there to belive
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Casey Vitti
Great bar. Got the French Dip and it was one of the best I've ever had. My wife loved her chicken sandwich. Large portions fair price and fresh beer taps. We be back again ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Bernath
Classic Montauk atmosphere with an outstanding menu and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
george mcphillips jr
Great local spot with ? food and great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian Dunlop
We've eaten here a few times across several years, food is always good. Service is friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: None that I could see
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Fish
Andrea Kuenzel
Worst food I had in a long time - stale oyster that must have sat shucked in the fridge for days, and a tiny not very fresh lobster roll without fries for $38. Even the fish & chips my husband had were kind of off tasting - fish not fresh and fries soggy. We went there for the Monday night’s live music which was excellent but next time I go I will just have a drink at the bar
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Steve Opacke
Good food. Live music. Fun place to go after a quick stop at Montauk brewery.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
James Myer
The fish & chips is the way to go: a generous portion of cod, and battered deliciously! Perfect after a long day out east ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony Barone
We had Baked clams, Mikes Chicken and a Kale salad. Clams were minced clams , over cooked, over seasoned. The chicken tasted like it was seasoned with Campbells soup.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Nicole Vinti
Chowder was pretty good, but everything else was terrible. Baked clams & crab cakes tasted the same using the same ingredients..the lobster roll was so salty, terrible experience.
Super atmosphere and our waitress was great We had ribs & lobster pasta both tasty and good selection of wines and beers Live music night lots of fun
Veronica Karpoich
My husband and I stopped in for a Saturday night dinner. The vibe was comfortable and the place had a good crowd at tables, so we were hopeful and sat at the bar. Unfortunately, the bartender was surly throughout our meal, and the food was disappointing. The photos of the food look very good online, but what you get pales in comparison. My husband’s fish tacos were mediocre, and my crab-stuffed flounder was covered in a red sauce that tasted like tomato paste from a can mixed with water. I don’t know how they have the nerve to charge $40 for that dish. We were both expecting so much more based on the reviews. The seafood tasted fresh enough and the bartender was finally nice when we were leaving, but I’d recommend you save your money and go elsewhere for a meal as neither made up for the rest of the experience.
Lou Corradi
Unfortunately, our food was disappointing. The fish in the Mahi Mahi tacos were not grilled but seemed "poached" leaving them rather flavorless. The shrimp with risotto cake was bathed in TOO much sauce and the risotto cake was basically a flat rice ball. The calamari appetizer was fine as well as the wait service. Food was served quickly and hot.But here's the biggest concern... They DO NOT have their menu posted on THEIR website! SERIOUSLY???WHY would any restaurant do something so absurd?We had to go to other web pages simply to find THEIR menu and those were no longer the active menu. Subsequently, the two dishes we thought we'd try were no longer available...AGAIN, WHY would ANY restaurant NOT have their menu on their OWN website... that speaks volumes!
Lindsay Wilson
We enjoyed the food, my burger was delicious. The owner (I’m assuming the owner) was very kind and went above and beyond for us. The 3 stars is because of the bartender. Normally I don’t like complaining because I work in the restaurant Industry and understand it can be rough, but all she did was complain and curse in front of us about her coworkers. We’d also ask for a drink and she wouldn’t even acknowledge us and would just hand us the drinks. We never knew if she even heard us or if we had to repeat ourselves. It kinda killed the mood for the evening and made us uncomfortable.
Caroline D.
I love visiting Tauk's when I'm in town! The best thing on the menu is their lobster grilled cheese on Texas toast which rivals all of the lobster rolls nearby. They also have local beer on tap and will have live music playing from time to time.
Very friendly atmosphere. I was there on Monday night and they had live music it was one of the best bandsYou have to go there to belive
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great bar. Got the French Dip and it was one of the best I've ever had. My wife loved her chicken sandwich. Large portions fair price and fresh beer taps. We be back again ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Classic Montauk atmosphere with an outstanding menu and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great local spot with ? food and great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We've eaten here a few times across several years, food is always good. Service is friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: None that I could see
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Fish
Worst food I had in a long time - stale oyster that must have sat shucked in the fridge for days, and a tiny not very fresh lobster roll without fries for $38. Even the fish & chips my husband had were kind of off tasting - fish not fresh and fries soggy. We went there for the Monday night’s live music which was excellent but next time I go I will just have a drink at the bar
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Good food. Live music. Fun place to go after a quick stop at Montauk brewery.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The fish & chips is the way to go: a generous portion of cod, and battered deliciously! Perfect after a long day out east ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had Baked clams, Mikes Chicken and a Kale salad. Clams were minced clams , over cooked, over seasoned. The chicken tasted like it was seasoned with Campbells soup.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Chowder was pretty good, but everything else was terrible. Baked clams & crab cakes tasted the same using the same ingredients..the lobster roll was so salty, terrible experience.
Restaurantji Recommends
Super atmosphere and our waitress was great We had ribs & lobster pasta both tasty and good selection of wines and beers Live music night lots of fun
My husband and I stopped in for a Saturday night dinner. The vibe was comfortable and the place had a good crowd at tables, so we were hopeful and sat at the bar. Unfortunately, the bartender was surly throughout our meal, and the food was disappointing. The photos of the food look very good online, but what you get pales in comparison. My husband’s fish tacos were mediocre, and my crab-stuffed flounder was covered in a red sauce that tasted like tomato paste from a can mixed with water. I don’t know how they have the nerve to charge $40 for that dish. We were both expecting so much more based on the reviews. The seafood tasted fresh enough and the bartender was finally nice when we were leaving, but I’d recommend you save your money and go elsewhere for a meal as neither made up for the rest of the experience.
Unfortunately, our food was disappointing. The fish in the Mahi Mahi tacos were not grilled but seemed "poached" leaving them rather flavorless. The shrimp with risotto cake was bathed in TOO much sauce and the risotto cake was basically a flat rice ball. The calamari appetizer was fine as well as the wait service. Food was served quickly and hot.But here's the biggest concern... They DO NOT have their menu posted on THEIR website! SERIOUSLY???WHY would any restaurant do something so absurd?We had to go to other web pages simply to find THEIR menu and those were no longer the active menu. Subsequently, the two dishes we thought we'd try were no longer available...AGAIN, WHY would ANY restaurant NOT have their menu on their OWN website... that speaks volumes!
We enjoyed the food, my burger was delicious. The owner (I’m assuming the owner) was very kind and went above and beyond for us. The 3 stars is because of the bartender. Normally I don’t like complaining because I work in the restaurant Industry and understand it can be rough, but all she did was complain and curse in front of us about her coworkers. We’d also ask for a drink and she wouldn’t even acknowledge us and would just hand us the drinks. We never knew if she even heard us or if we had to repeat ourselves. It kinda killed the mood for the evening and made us uncomfortable.
I love visiting Tauk's when I'm in town! The best thing on the menu is their lobster grilled cheese on Texas toast which rivals all of the lobster rolls nearby. They also have local beer on tap and will have live music playing from time to time.