Fisher's does not serve coffee of any kind except for cold brew used in espresso martinis. Servers pleasant. Seats (benches) need cushions (ouch). Menu different and food very good. Prices pretty in line with other local restaurants except maybe for the 90.00 steak And 90.00 whole fish THEY REALLY NEED TO BUY A COFFEE MAKER
I cannot say enough great things about this restaurant. The food, service, atmosphere is always incredible whenever we go. The mussels, steak tartar, and ribeye are a must order when you go here. Benjamin was a phenomenal server. Also, the wine selections are fantastic. Highly recommend this restaurant. Best meal I've had all year in Montauk.
KarenT
We almost did not go in for dinner. That would have been a mistake. The service was super friendly from the moment we walked in. They all knew it was my son's birthday. We ordered the steak tartar, the rosti potato pancake and the shrimp toast. Yum thumb for all. Then the Swedish meatballs, crispy cod and the salmon. All delicious. The salmon was great, but expected. Portions are generous. Dessert was the waffle and chocolate cake. They were ok, I'm not a big dessert person, I could have gone for another rosti. If I had to say one thing not favorable it would be that we felt a bit rushed, but I get it. Montauk in the summer, you've got to make your money and serve the crowds. Well worth it here. Tack!
New favorite restaurant in Montauk. The mussels and steak tartare were phenomenal. Best mussels we have ever had. There is also a great wine and drink menu. Can't wait to go back.
StanP
It took and hour between finishing our appetizers and our dinner arriving after complaining. Giving us free French fries and vegetables did not make up for the wait. Food was superb, but they will close if kitchen cannot send food out on time. Wait staff super apologetic but not acceptable even in Montauk.
NYCfoodreviews
Atmosphere was lovely so was the service. However the food was not great. The aged steak fir two was over-salted, so was the fish for two. The tomato/onion salad had tomatoes that were not fresh. The fisherman's appetizer was underwhelming. Overall its a good concept but the execution is not there yet.
Honestly, this place is next level. I have eaten at some of the best restaurants in the world and most of the restaurants in the Hamptons. This food is exquisite. Not only is the food top level, the service and friendliness of the staff is unmatched. Perhaps it's because the culture in western Sweden is different as most of the staff is from that area, but I cannot help but notice how friendly and welcoming everyone was. I wish it was a year-round institution, but I understand why they are seasonal. Hope to get back here again before they close in September.
This restaurant is incredible! Drinks were great and food was outrageous. As a party of 8 the staff was very attentive and extremely kind. Highly recommend the salmon - it was out of this world!
CandiceH
I am not even sure where to begin other than saying this was the best meal and restaurant experience I have had in a decade. The food was incredible from taste to portion to presentation. The service was perfectly timed without being intrusive and the staff were so kind! They were happy to tell their story and share opinion on Swedish cuisine. The decor and ambiance were my favorite (second to the food of course). Highly highly highly recommend.
welovefood
Great mixture of flavors and fresh ingredients. Drinks at the bar ahead of time we're amazing with the freshest juices around. Really enjoyed the experience and Fisher's great service. A hidden gem in Montauk!
Clean, open, bright, sunny restaurant. Swedish influence in the food. Friendly service - well informed. Small menu but covers all types of food. Freshly prepared and delicious. Good selection of wine and beers.
Mindy Y.
Located at the marina, this cafe is great for a casual breakfast. The egg wraps are very good and the coffee there is good enough for a snob like me.
Fisher's does not serve coffee of any kind except for cold brew used in espresso martinis. Servers pleasant. Seats (benches) need cushions (ouch). Menu different and food very good. Prices pretty in line with other local restaurants except maybe for the 90.00 steak And 90.00 whole fish THEY REALLY NEED TO BUY A COFFEE MAKER
I cannot say enough great things about this restaurant. The food, service, atmosphere is always incredible whenever we go. The mussels, steak tartar, and ribeye are a must order when you go here. Benjamin was a phenomenal server. Also, the wine selections are fantastic. Highly recommend this restaurant. Best meal I've had all year in Montauk.
We almost did not go in for dinner. That would have been a mistake. The service was super friendly from the moment we walked in. They all knew it was my son's birthday. We ordered the steak tartar, the rosti potato pancake and the shrimp toast. Yum thumb for all. Then the Swedish meatballs, crispy cod and the salmon. All delicious. The salmon was great, but expected. Portions are generous. Dessert was the waffle and chocolate cake. They were ok, I'm not a big dessert person, I could have gone for another rosti. If I had to say one thing not favorable it would be that we felt a bit rushed, but I get it. Montauk in the summer, you've got to make your money and serve the crowds. Well worth it here. Tack!
New favorite restaurant in Montauk. The mussels and steak tartare were phenomenal. Best mussels we have ever had. There is also a great wine and drink menu. Can't wait to go back.
It took and hour between finishing our appetizers and our dinner arriving after complaining. Giving us free French fries and vegetables did not make up for the wait. Food was superb, but they will close if kitchen cannot send food out on time. Wait staff super apologetic but not acceptable even in Montauk.
Atmosphere was lovely so was the service. However the food was not great. The aged steak fir two was over-salted, so was the fish for two. The tomato/onion salad had tomatoes that were not fresh. The fisherman's appetizer was underwhelming. Overall its a good concept but the execution is not there yet.
Honestly, this place is next level. I have eaten at some of the best restaurants in the world and most of the restaurants in the Hamptons. This food is exquisite. Not only is the food top level, the service and friendliness of the staff is unmatched. Perhaps it's because the culture in western Sweden is different as most of the staff is from that area, but I cannot help but notice how friendly and welcoming everyone was. I wish it was a year-round institution, but I understand why they are seasonal. Hope to get back here again before they close in September.
This restaurant is incredible! Drinks were great and food was outrageous. As a party of 8 the staff was very attentive and extremely kind. Highly recommend the salmon - it was out of this world!
I am not even sure where to begin other than saying this was the best meal and restaurant experience I have had in a decade. The food was incredible from taste to portion to presentation. The service was perfectly timed without being intrusive and the staff were so kind! They were happy to tell their story and share opinion on Swedish cuisine. The decor and ambiance were my favorite (second to the food of course). Highly highly highly recommend.
Great mixture of flavors and fresh ingredients. Drinks at the bar ahead of time we're amazing with the freshest juices around. Really enjoyed the experience and Fisher's great service. A hidden gem in Montauk!
Restaurantji Recommends
Clean, open, bright, sunny restaurant. Swedish influence in the food. Friendly service - well informed. Small menu but covers all types of food. Freshly prepared and delicious. Good selection of wine and beers.
Located at the marina, this cafe is great for a casual breakfast. The egg wraps are very good and the coffee there is good enough for a snob like me.