Carmela's Restaurant Pizzeria
1021 NY-17K, Montgomery
(845) 457-3021
Customers' Favorites
Mussels Marinara
Chicken Milanese
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Marsala
Limoncello Cake
Caeser Salad
Baked Ziti
Menu
Photos
+42 photos
+41 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
waitress was nice but was extremely slow and there are not many tables in there. You can tell the cheese on the stuff shells was old. The stuffing of the shells was def frozen , pasta shells were cooked okay the outside was warm inside was piping hot so probably microwaved , salad was old no flavor and had no crunch it was soggy bread was good even though it was brought almost at the end and I had to ask for it because she forgot it. salad came with the dinner not first and the...
My wife and I love Carmela's for date night. Large menu. Fantastic dinners. The chef does an amazing job with the sauces for all dishes. We also order pizza and drive past many other places to get from Carmela's. Great friendly service. Orders are always accurate. We have catered a house party and they helped ensure the accurate order and helped us load up the car.
You May Also Like
Chinatown Kitchen - 1025 NY-17K
![]()
Chinese
Strada Grill - 1011 NY-17K
![]()
Diner, Coffee & Tea, Pet Friendly
That the tomato sauce is very bland. I appreciate it is not super sweet and more balanced with sweet/acidity. I have ordered the parm again and it’s good, not great. I do appreciate that the cutlets have a bit of crispness. Thinner pieces of chicken would
Make it better. The pizza was good the first time I tried it, could have been bc I was starving. The time after that...