Giovanni's

4457 NY-42, Monticello
(845) 794-8668

Recent Reviews

Sort by
just me kim

Best pizza place around.....delicious pizza , subs , chicken cutlets and the tacos are amazing

John Brewer

The Best. Ask for your choice hero on Toasted roll. Highly recommend The Godfather

Erit

Okay pizzeria. Had a large pie with chicken was average.

Collin Cross

My brother and I have been coming here since before we had teeth. We have been eating their godfather for 20 years and the sandwich never misses. Have been eating one once a month since the first taste. From babies gumming it to mush to full grown working adults coming for lunch. If your only ordering the godfather for yourself your in and out in less than 5 minutes. The owner is a bit of an ass on the phone but is hard working and knows how to make a customer happy. I hope I die before they close or I’ll be pissed.

Selene Inparadise

OMG. First time here, just passing through town. Got the meatball sub half - and it’s huge! And the taste, it’s exactly as I remember from my days growing up here. The texture of the hero was spot on!! Meatballs must have been cooking all day, delish!! If I’m still in town tomorrow, I’m coming back to try their eggplant parm!

Heather Marie

What happened to this place??!! I have been going to Giovanni’s since I was a kid and it has always been a staple in our community. The food was horrible. The onion rings were overcooked. The chicken parm hero was a good size but they added the parchment paper on hot cheese and it all tore off when the paper came off. The sauce was not good. My husband said his wrap was also not really good. I always recommend Giovanni’s when my family visits from TN but I can’t recommend it any longer.

Barbara

They can't even make a salami and cheese sandwich. Poor. They don't even thank you for a 25% tip for Poor food and service

Pearly White

My favorite sandwich shop in the area..
A must stop you will always return.
Àwsome staff and food .
I have been visiting this place since opening day.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ian Constable (martial arts)

Vegetarian options: Salads

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup

Norma Rodriguez

Good food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Galen Booth

We were staying at the nearby Hampton Inn and ordered a large pizza with extra cheese and thin crust. The pizza was ready when promised and the register help was very cheerful. However, the "extra" cheese was barely "extra" and was not plentiful. Moreover, the part of the pizza with the toppings looked like the hubcap surrounded by the tire. The toppings did not reach the edge of the pizza by 1 1/2 to 2 inches. When we order a pizza, we expect pizza and not excessive crust. They probably save a lot of $ everyday by skimping on toppings and leaving empty all that extra crust. The rest of the pizza was mediocre. I will not order from them again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Shep

Visiting from Florida, and wanted some real NY pizza. We were not disappointed! Nothing fancy here, just a basic pizzaria. Got the cheese slices. The crust was crispy, and sauce was tasty. I even got to compliment the pizza maker (Giovanni?), who said he's been making pizza "for a long time". It shows.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Steven Onorato

Messed up both my sandwiches and then told me the guy doesn't clean the grill ...omfg did she just tell me that...im grossed out...the chicken was stringy...definitely old...the place is a mess...and watch them take your money, answer the phone, open the deli cooler..and touch all your ready to eat foods with the same gloves...disgusting...will never go back..they are gonna get someone sick if they didn't already

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: The Godfather Sub, Sandwich, Chicken Parmesan Sub

Mike Matera

Great place for pizza! I had the mushroom slice and my friend got pepperoni & bacon. Highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Elizabeth Figueroa

Hero’s are delicious and filling. Lots of options plus they have pizza , soup, daily specials and other menu items. The Godfather is a must to try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meatball Sub, The Godfather Sub, Sandwich, Roast Beef Sub

Loading...