Oh my goodness if I could choose zero stars I would !!!!! What a horrible experience ... once again, this is the third time that we have ordered food this month and each time it was just awful .. we went back a second and third time thinking maybe they were just having a bad day maybe there was a new cook but this seems to be the norm now absolutely awful food !!! The Stromboli was completely raw, meatless and tasteless. The pizza tasted like Ragu Sauce and rotten cheese !!! Tonight will certainly be the last night we ever order from this place ever again !!!!!
C B
Great subs here. I have been getting food here since I was a little kid and they were in their original location next to Paul Paskows liquor store where burger king is now. Their staff is friendly and good at their trade. Prices are fair. Never have had a bad experiance here in 30 years. You have to try their Godfather with everything!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Italian Sandwich, Godfather Wraps, Cheesesteak
Michael Terry
šŗš²
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Geordanio Adolphe
Best pizza at Monticello
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cody Fegley
We had pizza and garlic knots. I thought pizza was good my little 3 year old told the cook it was not. Staff were super friendly joked with our younger children and were overall very nice.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Rebecca Kemp
Got the amazing Godfather āwith everythingā to go. Got home to realize they never put oil and vinegar on it. Sad sad day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Julianna Stowers-Lopez
Worst eggplant parm sandwich ever!! Do NOT recommend. Soaked in grease!!! Mushy slop. š¤®
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Nathaniel Brady
Best pizza in monticello by far.
J.D. Ellis
Staff were super friendly. Cheesesteak was excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
just me kim
Best pizza place around.....delicious pizza , subs , chicken cutlets and the tacos are amazing
The Best. Ask for your choice hero on Toasted roll. Highly recommend The Godfather
Erit
Okay pizzeria. Had a large pie with chicken was average.
Collin Cross
My brother and I have been coming here since before we had teeth. We have been eating their godfather for 20 years and the sandwich never misses. Have been eating one once a month since the first taste. From babies gumming it to mush to full grown working adults coming for lunch. If your only ordering the godfather for yourself your in and out in less than 5 minutes. The owner is a bit of an ass on the phone but is hard working and knows how to make a customer happy. I hope I die before they close or Iāll be pissed.
Selene Inparadise
OMG. First time here, just passing through town. Got the meatball sub half - and itās huge! And the taste, itās exactly as I remember from my days growing up here. The texture of the hero was spot on!! Meatballs must have been cooking all day, delish!! If Iām still in town tomorrow, Iām coming back to try their eggplant parm!
Heather Marie
What happened to this place??!! I have been going to Giovanniās since I was a kid and it has always been a staple in our community.
The food was horrible. The onion rings were overcooked. The chicken parm hero was a good size but they added the parchment paper on hot cheese and it all tore off when the paper came off. The sauce was not good. My husband said his wrap was also not really good. I always recommend Giovanniās when my family visits from TN but I canāt recommend it any longer.
Oh my goodness if I could choose zero stars I would !!!!!
What a horrible experience ... once again, this is the third time that we have ordered food this month and each time it was just awful .. we went back a second and third time thinking maybe they were just having a bad day maybe there was a new cook but this seems to be the norm now absolutely awful food !!! The Stromboli was completely raw, meatless and tasteless. The pizza tasted like Ragu Sauce and rotten cheese !!!
Tonight will certainly be the last night we ever order from this place ever again !!!!!
Great subs here. I have been getting food here since I was a little kid and they were in their original location next to Paul Paskows liquor store where burger king is now. Their staff is friendly and good at their trade. Prices are fair. Never have had a bad experiance here in 30 years. You have to try their Godfather with everything!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Italian Sandwich, Godfather Wraps, Cheesesteak
šŗš²
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza at Monticello
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had pizza and garlic knots. I thought pizza was good my little 3 year old told the cook it was not. Staff were super friendly joked with our younger children and were overall very nice.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Got the amazing Godfather āwith everythingā to go. Got home to realize they never put oil and vinegar on it. Sad sad day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Worst eggplant parm sandwich ever!! Do NOT recommend. Soaked in grease!!! Mushy slop. š¤®
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Best pizza in monticello by far.
Staff were super friendly. Cheesesteak was excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza place around.....delicious pizza , subs , chicken cutlets and the tacos are amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The Best. Ask for your choice hero on Toasted roll. Highly recommend The Godfather
Okay pizzeria. Had a large pie with chicken was average.
My brother and I have been coming here since before we had teeth. We have been eating their godfather for 20 years and the sandwich never misses. Have been eating one once a month since the first taste. From babies gumming it to mush to full grown working adults coming for lunch. If your only ordering the godfather for yourself your in and out in less than 5 minutes. The owner is a bit of an ass on the phone but is hard working and knows how to make a customer happy. I hope I die before they close or Iāll be pissed.
OMG. First time here, just passing through town. Got the meatball sub half - and itās huge! And the taste, itās exactly as I remember from my days growing up here. The texture of the hero was spot on!! Meatballs must have been cooking all day, delish!! If Iām still in town tomorrow, Iām coming back to try their eggplant parm!
What happened to this place??!! I have been going to Giovanniās since I was a kid and it has always been a staple in our community. The food was horrible. The onion rings were overcooked. The chicken parm hero was a good size but they added the parchment paper on hot cheese and it all tore off when the paper came off. The sauce was not good. My husband said his wrap was also not really good. I always recommend Giovanniās when my family visits from TN but I canāt recommend it any longer.
Loading...