Siena's Pizza

321 Broadway, Monticello
(845) 791-7662

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ayesha Daniels

Undercooked wings or bad chicken I have a sour stomach as well as my sister after eating one wing won’t order under the quality of the food and service has declined

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Glenn Sohm

Ordered two pizzas for takeout. It was quick and both pizzas were exactly what I expected.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tyler Person

Order a half plan half bruschetta pie. They put maybe two tablespoons of bruschetta on the pizza. When the slices that were in their display case were COVERED with. Thinking they would make them similar I ordered. Got home opened the box. It’s essentially a plain pizza. When I called and asked why she said that’s what you get and if you don’t like it come bring your pizza in and we will refund you. Like how about you make the pizza correctly. On the last few years this place has gone so far down hill I am disgusted with it. Been going here for 20 years and I have to say they don’t give a damn about anything anymore. Will never go back based on my last few experiences. So glad I paid en extra 8 dollars for one quarter of a tomato chopped up.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jennifer George

Best pizza in Monticello for sure. They offer many choices and their Chicken BBQ pie is amazing. Been coming here for many years now and it’s always great.

During the summer the area is congested but still worth it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alicja

Delicious pizza in good price 😋

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Paul Gianquinto

A great place for pizza. Forced to downsize and the atmosphere has suffered. Friendly owners. Fair prices. Always great pizza. Nice specials too.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Barb Simpson

The best pizza around!!! Try the bruschetta pizza- I haven’t found any place that can beat or even match it!!! Deserves 5 stars!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

fred vairo

Best pizza in Monticello. Food is delicious.

Michael Rider

A great friendly place.

Edwin

Their pizza is wonderful, but the rude women that run the counter cannot even accept constructive criticism. My pizza was made wrong. I was told to bring the pizza back. They will give me my money back and never to come there again I have spent probably 200 pies in the past couple of years from there And this is how they treat you . I asked for the manager to call me and I was told they don’t call people .

cateyes Morrow

They're spicy buffalo chicken really good and I highly recommend

Michael Holland

Great pizza. It's not doughy or under cooked. If you ask them to leave your order in the oven longer for a crisspier taste, they will accommodate. They are always prepared for your order. The place is clean and no flies inside the pizza case. That's right. I've went to other pizza restaurants and there's flies everywhere.

Kayla R

The chef Jose is amazing, literally the best food we've had in a very long time

Carmen Alexi

I'm pretty certain they gave me a pie that had been sitting there all day for slices. Pretty bad service with an attitude..ordered a medium cheese pizza late on a Sunday. They gave and charged me for a large. When I complained the rude lady (in keeping with all these reviews) said I can take it back and give u ur money knowing full well nothing is open on Sunday in this town. I won't be going back been living here 7 years without patronizing them so no big loss for me.. Buyer beware!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

AJ MrMischievous Stone

excellent pizza and friendly service.

Loading...