I was in Mt. Kisco and craving a good bagel, so after a quick Google search, I found this spot. They’ve since closed their downstairs storefront and now operate upstairs, mainly catering. The setup was easy enough to find, but the overall vibe felt a little limited.
I ordered a sourdough bagel with cream cheese and a plain croissant. Both were okay — fresh, toasted, and crispy (maybe a little too toasted). The croissant was huge, which was a nice surprise, but it wasn’t buttered, which I definitely prefer. I also wish they had more bagel options available when I went, and I’m personally not a fan of applying my own cream cheese — part of the bagel experience for me is having it done for you.
It also seems like the only add-on option now is cream cheese, which is a little disappointing if you’re hoping for a full sandwich or variety. On the plus side, there’s parking right outside, which is always appreciated. Overall, it wasn’t a bad experience, just not great either. I might give it another try someday, but it’s not at the top of my list.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Joselyn Bella
Everything frozen and they try to pass it as fresh … they are also never open.
Travis Hunter
Their bread is one of the great joys of Mount Kisco.
john marks
Bagels are great, but when are you guys open?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aeneas Eaton
Pastries are perfect, staff is incredibly kind! Everything is delicious
Food: 5
Service: 4
Miša Honzová
This place is absolute heaven 🤩
Leigh Clark
Amazing bakery. Everything is so good. Very friendly staff
Udayan Mittal
Very cute bake shop with great service and nice selection of treats for breakfast as well as delicious pastries. Lots of seats and a nice calm/relaxed vibe.
Patrick Robertson
Best pasties in the area. Devine. The coffee is delicious as well.
Marialisa Zywotchenko
My car seems to self drive to Bella's daily at this point. I'm obsessed. The chocolate croissant is to die for and the sandwich with burrata... mmmmm. I can't get enough. And if the coffee doesn't lift your spirits, the young woman who works there will. She is the sweetest creature on the planet. Just go and try some sourdough. YUM!
Our family is a big fan of this delicious bakery. There is always inviting aroma of freshly baked goods. Their selection is fantastic, from the soft, flaky croissants to the rich, decadent desserts. I tried their cinnamon rolls, white chocolate and raspberry cookies, both items were heavenly. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable, offering great recommendations. So happy this place is close to my home.
Natalia James
Fantastic bakery, and they brew Atomic coffee which is fabulous.
Sourdough bagels (everything and plain) are everything you want in a sourdough bagel - chewy and flavorful. “Cro-Bel” sandwich was tasty and generous portions.
The prices are on the higher side, but reasonable and I suspect is a reflection of the area and rents to run an independent shop.l in Westchester.
Well worth every penny, everything is thoughtful and perfectly executed. Will be visiting again!
Gustave Levy
If you leave less than a five star review for Bella’s, I wouldn’t trust you to breathe in and out.
One gentlemen wrote “baker has a lot to learn.” ….um what? This guy is a genius and Martha Stewart agrees!
If you’re complaining about the prices, then you should be complaining about the taxes in the town that the company is doing business in.
I would gladly pay $20 for any of the sandwiches that they offer and they priced them between $7 and $15.
Get your holiday orders in early.
Every sandwich is made with their bakery goods. I have never ordered a bad item.
I am not a coffee drinker, but I’m sure they have good coffee too
Walk across the parking lot to the commons park. There is a stream/pond where geese often hang out.
I was in Mt. Kisco and craving a good bagel, so after a quick Google search, I found this spot. They’ve since closed their downstairs storefront and now operate upstairs, mainly catering. The setup was easy enough to find, but the overall vibe felt a little limited.
I ordered a sourdough bagel with cream cheese and a plain croissant. Both were okay — fresh, toasted, and crispy (maybe a little too toasted). The croissant was huge, which was a nice surprise, but it wasn’t buttered, which I definitely prefer. I also wish they had more bagel options available when I went, and I’m personally not a fan of applying my own cream cheese — part of the bagel experience for me is having it done for you.
It also seems like the only add-on option now is cream cheese, which is a little disappointing if you’re hoping for a full sandwich or variety. On the plus side, there’s parking right outside, which is always appreciated. Overall, it wasn’t a bad experience, just not great either. I might give it another try someday, but it’s not at the top of my list.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Everything frozen and they try to pass it as fresh … they are also never open.
Their bread is one of the great joys of Mount Kisco.
Bagels are great, but when are you guys open?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pastries are perfect, staff is incredibly kind! Everything is delicious
Food: 5
Service: 4
This place is absolute heaven 🤩
Amazing bakery. Everything is so good. Very friendly staff
Very cute bake shop with great service and nice selection of treats for breakfast as well as delicious pastries. Lots of seats and a nice calm/relaxed vibe.
Best pasties in the area. Devine. The coffee is delicious as well.
My car seems to self drive to Bella's daily at this point. I'm obsessed. The chocolate croissant is to die for and the sandwich with burrata... mmmmm. I can't get enough. And if the coffee doesn't lift your spirits, the young woman who works there will. She is the sweetest creature on the planet. Just go and try some sourdough. YUM!
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious sourdough everything!
Best bakery in the area hands down.
Our family is a big fan of this delicious bakery. There is always inviting aroma of freshly baked goods. Their selection is fantastic, from the soft, flaky croissants to the rich, decadent desserts. I tried their cinnamon rolls, white chocolate and raspberry cookies, both items were heavenly. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable, offering great recommendations. So happy this place is close to my home.
Fantastic bakery, and they brew Atomic coffee which is fabulous.
Sourdough bagels (everything and plain) are everything you want in a sourdough bagel - chewy and flavorful. “Cro-Bel” sandwich was tasty and generous portions.
The prices are on the higher side, but reasonable and I suspect is a reflection of the area and rents to run an independent shop.l in Westchester.
Well worth every penny, everything is thoughtful and perfectly executed. Will be visiting again!
If you leave less than a five star review for Bella’s, I wouldn’t trust you to breathe in and out.
One gentlemen wrote “baker has a lot to learn.” ….um what? This guy is a genius and Martha Stewart agrees!
If you’re complaining about the prices, then you should be complaining about the taxes in the town that the company is doing business in.
I would gladly pay $20 for any of the sandwiches that they offer and they priced them between $7 and $15.
Get your holiday orders in early.
Every sandwich is made with their bakery goods. I have never ordered a bad item.
I am not a coffee drinker, but I’m sure they have good coffee too
Walk across the parking lot to the commons park. There is a stream/pond where geese often hang out.
Loading...