The steak was tasty and tender. I appreciated the service and atmosphere more than the food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ken
We went on a snowy Sunday evening and were so pleased that they stayed open. We were warmly greeted and promptly escorted to our table. The menu was filled with a varied selection for whatever you're in the mood to eat, and plenty of wine and beer options. Our meals were cooked to perfection and very tasty. We very much enjoyed the atmosphere, to include a well-appointed bar that was appropriately secluded from the dining room. The big deal, for those who grew up in and around the Mount Kisco area, is the huge mural of turn-of-the-century Mount Kisco.
Linda
Service attentive and food was very good. Very pleasant experience, noise level was a bit high at times.
Diane
The brunch menu is fabulous. We had classic eggs Benedict and banana pancakes. Service very good. Attentive waiter. Very good choice for Sunday brunch.
Carl Bertoni
This is one of the best restaurant in MT Kisco for years. 1000% recommended. Food is amazing and place is very warm and comfortable to eat at the bar or sit at a table. The kitchen manager Zaman is one of a million, only sends the best quality items out. MUST GO!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ELLEN
We had drinks and happy hour menu first then ordered dinner from the regular menu. Everything was great including the service. Always a pleasure.
Regina
Our reservations were for 3PM so the restaurant, at that time, was not filled up so we enjoyed a quiet late lunch/early dinner. I ordered the soup of the day and it was hot and delicious and my Filet Mignon sandwich was very good and the Creme Brulee was perfect and my coffee was fresh and hot. Also, I had one of the special Mocktails, Blood Orange Juice, Orange Juice, Lime and Grapefruit sparkling water and it was so delicious. Unfortunatley, the waitress was trying to rush the courses because they had to close out the lunch or something with a shift change and that was not appreciated and annoying. Thank you.
lynn
Best fried calamari in Westchester! Cesear salad was very good, loved the fettuccini with shrimp & scallops and the fish was delicious.
Nik S.
Today as soon as we sat down within five minutes, we got a waitress that we asked a simple question to and immediately she started huffing and puffing and rolling her eyes. We asked her if the burgers were flame broiled, or grilled since my mom has really bad reflux. Clearly bothered by the question and not knowing what flame broiled is (as she admitted), we asked her to go to the kitchen and confirm if she could, since my mom really wanted the burger, only if it was grilled. She proceeded to walk away, continuing to roll her eyes and give bad attitude. Less than five minutes later, we were given a new waitress. We asked to speak to the manager and apoke to a tall, thin guy with gray hair and blue eyes. When we told him what happened with our experience with her he simply just stated “well that’s not like her”. He explained that her dog passed away yesterday which we responded that it’s terrible to hear the news, however, she really shouldn’t be acting like that towards customers. We asked the other waitress that we got if she requested to switch from us because she seemed incredibly annoyed that we asked her one question. All he said, was that she works there full-time and this usually isn’t like her and didn’t even say the words I’m sorry once. We explained to him that obviously we can understand. However, it still doesn’t give her the right to treat paying customers like that. Again, got no apologies and nothing further from him. I explained to him that when I have a bad day at work, I’m not able to go around Acting rude to people at my job despite things that go on in my personal life. To that he replied that she’s “trying to work through it”. Upset with the way that he handled it as a manager again, still with no apologies or anything, I replied that she shouldn’t be trying to “work through it” if this is how she’s going to handle herself at work. He should’ve just sent her home for the remainder of the day if she needed time to herself. Maybe she couldn’t afford to skip a day of work, not everyone can go a day unpaid so I recognize that….but if she really is one of your long term full time employees and you value her then just let her go the remainder of the day paid and figure it out yourself if they’re understaffed and help out a bit. To be honest even if she recognized it and came over and apologized and said “sorry my dog just passed away and I’m just trying to distract myself and make some money here at work at the same time let me check on that for you” or “I’m not having the greatest day, I apologize” then it’d be a different story. It’s just the staff that makes it the worst experience every single time. The last time I went there, I was alone over the summer back in June and you could see from the conversation with my wife that even then they had messed something up yet again. Unfortunately, we will never be eating here again and really wish that the manager had handled it in a different way. We weren’t even looking for any money off of our bill because we already paid and tipped the other new waitress in full. Over the summer I got someone who ended up not even being the manager and helped more than the actual manager. This place needs to figure out their stuff with customer service and workflow, unfortunately. By the way my wife’s burger came out with bacon when she never asked, come to find out they come back and admit it’s the wrong order and all they did in the back was pull off the bacon with the imprints still on the cheese. My mom asked for mayo on the side (not given) and only tomato (given all the toppings BUT tomato). I would hope restaurants know about potential food allergies god forbid by now considering it’s the year 2025 going into 2026 and we didn’t even tell the manager that part or show him the text chain from my most recent time prior….
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Roberta
We had a very good dinner at Lexington Square Cafe. The service was excellent and we really liked the food. I would recommend it if you are in the Mount Kisco area.
Always love coming to this restaurant. However, my main course was not very good. The vegetables were significantly over cooked to the point of being soggy. The same with featured fish.
Bonnie
Our dinner at Lexington Square Cafe was exceptional. We had a family member with severe Celiac disease and they were very accommodating and reassuring. All the food was flavorful and the portions were generous. We will definitely be back.
Siby
We always love the food and service here and the space is beautiful. The recent renovations are very nice.
Melanie G
A few issues with noise level, uncomfortable table, broken toilet and how a dish was served. BUT...the service is excellent and prices fair.
Nancy
Lexington Square Cafe never disappoints! Delicious food, lots of choices and great service. What more do you need?!
The steak was tasty and tender. I appreciated the service and atmosphere more than the food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
We went on a snowy Sunday evening and were so pleased that they stayed open. We were warmly greeted and promptly escorted to our table. The menu was filled with a varied selection for whatever you're in the mood to eat, and plenty of wine and beer options. Our meals were cooked to perfection and very tasty. We very much enjoyed the atmosphere, to include a well-appointed bar that was appropriately secluded from the dining room. The big deal, for those who grew up in and around the Mount Kisco area, is the huge mural of turn-of-the-century Mount Kisco.
Service attentive and food was very good. Very pleasant experience, noise level was a bit high at times.
The brunch menu is fabulous. We had classic eggs Benedict and banana pancakes. Service very good. Attentive waiter. Very good choice for Sunday brunch.
This is one of the best restaurant in MT Kisco for years. 1000% recommended. Food is amazing and place is very warm and comfortable to eat at the bar or sit at a table. The kitchen manager Zaman is one of a million, only sends the best quality items out. MUST GO!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had drinks and happy hour menu first then ordered dinner from the regular menu. Everything was great including the service. Always a pleasure.
Our reservations were for 3PM so the restaurant, at that time, was not filled up so we enjoyed a quiet late lunch/early dinner. I ordered the soup of the day and it was hot and delicious and my Filet Mignon sandwich was very good and the Creme Brulee was perfect and my coffee was fresh and hot. Also, I had one of the special Mocktails, Blood Orange Juice, Orange Juice, Lime and Grapefruit sparkling water and it was so delicious. Unfortunatley, the waitress was trying to rush the courses because they had to close out the lunch or something with a shift change and that was not appreciated and annoying. Thank you.
Best fried calamari in Westchester! Cesear salad was very good, loved the fettuccini with shrimp & scallops and the fish was delicious.
Today as soon as we sat down within five minutes, we got a waitress that we asked a simple question to and immediately she started huffing and puffing and rolling her eyes. We asked her if the burgers were flame broiled, or grilled since my mom has really bad reflux. Clearly bothered by the question and not knowing what flame broiled is (as she admitted), we asked her to go to the kitchen and confirm if she could, since my mom really wanted the burger, only if it was grilled. She proceeded to walk away, continuing to roll her eyes and give bad attitude. Less than five minutes later, we were given a new waitress. We asked to speak to the manager and apoke to a tall, thin guy with gray hair and blue eyes. When we told him what happened with our experience with her he simply just stated “well that’s not like her”. He explained that her dog passed away yesterday which we responded that it’s terrible to hear the news, however, she really shouldn’t be acting like that towards customers. We asked the other waitress that we got if she requested to switch from us because she seemed incredibly annoyed that we asked her one question. All he said, was that she works there full-time and this usually isn’t like her and didn’t even say the words I’m sorry once. We explained to him that obviously we can understand. However, it still doesn’t give her the right to treat paying customers like that. Again, got no apologies and nothing further from him. I explained to him that when I have a bad day at work, I’m not able to go around Acting rude to people at my job despite things that go on in my personal life. To that he replied that she’s “trying to work through it”. Upset with the way that he handled it as a manager again, still with no apologies or anything, I replied that she shouldn’t be trying to “work through it” if this is how she’s going to handle herself at work. He should’ve just sent her home for the remainder of the day if she needed time to herself. Maybe she couldn’t afford to skip a day of work, not everyone can go a day unpaid so I recognize that….but if she really is one of your long term full time employees and you value her then just let her go the remainder of the day paid and figure it out yourself if they’re understaffed and help out a bit. To be honest even if she recognized it and came over and apologized and said “sorry my dog just passed away and I’m just trying to distract myself and make some money here at work at the same time let me check on that for you” or “I’m not having the greatest day, I apologize” then it’d be a different story. It’s just the staff that makes it the worst experience every single time. The last time I went there, I was alone over the summer back in June and you could see from the conversation with my wife that even then they had messed something up yet again. Unfortunately, we will never be eating here again and really wish that the manager had handled it in a different way. We weren’t even looking for any money off of our bill because we already paid and tipped the other new waitress in full. Over the summer I got someone who ended up not even being the manager and helped more than the actual manager. This place needs to figure out their stuff with customer service and workflow, unfortunately. By the way my wife’s burger came out with bacon when she never asked, come to find out they come back and admit it’s the wrong order and all they did in the back was pull off the bacon with the imprints still on the cheese. My mom asked for mayo on the side (not given) and only tomato (given all the toppings BUT tomato). I would hope restaurants know about potential food allergies god forbid by now considering it’s the year 2025 going into 2026 and we didn’t even tell the manager that part or show him the text chain from my most recent time prior….
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
We had a very good dinner at Lexington Square Cafe. The service was excellent and we really liked the food. I would recommend it if you are in the Mount Kisco area.
Restaurantji Recommends
Always love coming to this restaurant. However, my main course was not very good. The vegetables were significantly over cooked to the point of being soggy. The same with featured fish.
Our dinner at Lexington Square Cafe was exceptional. We had a family member with severe Celiac disease and they were very accommodating and reassuring. All the food was flavorful and the portions were generous. We will definitely be back.
We always love the food and service here and the space is beautiful. The recent renovations are very nice.
A few issues with noise level, uncomfortable table, broken toilet and how a dish was served. BUT...the service is excellent and prices fair.
Lexington Square Cafe never disappoints! Delicious food, lots of choices and great service. What more do you need?!
Loading...