17 Best Greek Restaurants near Mount Sinai

“As someone who worked in the food industry and owned my own restaurants, I can’t say enough about this particular establishment. The food is not just good, it's truly excellent, showcasing a commitment to quality that is hard to find. The service matches the quality of the food—it's consistently great, reflecting the professionalism and courtesy of the staff. They possess excellent manners and are clearly dedicated to ensuring that all customers’ needs are met. While it’s understandable that some patrons may occasionally feel overlooked, especially during busy times, it's important to recognize that the staff can only attend to one table at a time. However, rest assured that eventually everyone is attended to, ensuring that each guest's experience is pleasant and satisfying.“

“Work day Dinner for 2
Fast Quick service *****
Gyro - D lish *****
Spanakopita best ever **********
Quick easy Pick up and go
Cost $$$$$$ No complaint$
We lost Greeks Island of Holbrook (sad )
As one chapter closed and New one opens“

“I definitely recommend this place. Being Greek & growing up with Greek food throughout my life, I can tell you that you will get good authentic Greek food here. I have also ordered from them twice on Uber Eats. It's hard to find good Greek food restaurants that you can get food delivered on Uber Eats. Their portions are generous & the salad is fresh!. Their Bifteki is awesome! Not all Greek restaurants out on Long Island have Bifteki. I opted for the Bifteki (Beefteki) bowl over Greek salad! And their warmed pita bread with the seasoning on it is so good. I will definitely order from them again.“

“Love this place! Such a homely feel and the food reminds you of a delicious home cooked meal. I suggest it to anyone and everyone who wants to eat great Cypriot cuisine and support a local restaurant!!“

“First time there last night. Delicious food, huge servings, prices great! Best chick pea salad appetizer and Greek salad . Lamb chops big portion and delicious with green beans with peppers and onion vegetable and lemon potato wedges. Highly recommend glad our friends brought us there. Wish I lived closer“

“Generous portions and food is always fresh and very good. Definitely recommened!!“

“We picked up Lunch today for the first time. Everything was delicious and had so much flavor. Staff were super friendly and sweet. Definitely will be back“

“Gilshar Greek Cafe is a local favorite in Port Jefferson Station, NY. The restaurant offers a pleasant dining environment inside Port Plaza, with well-arranged tables and greenery that create a relaxing vibe. Service was quick and friendly.

I tried the Lamb Gyro Combo with fries and Greek salad. The salad was fresh and traditional, albeit missing red onion and oregano. The French fries were simply seasoned with Greek spices, but the lamb gyro was fantastic, generously sized and packed with flavorful, rotisserie-cooked lamb. Overall, the prices are reasonable, and the portions are great. I’ll definitely come back!“

“I have been a Patron of Valoupitta’s Restaurant for nearly 20 years, they are so quick to complete my orders and their food never Disappoints me! The restaurant atmosphere is cozy and casual, it always feels welcoming! I will always recommend them, there Servings are generous and their prices can’t be beat!
Excellent all around“

“Best Greek restaurant ever - falafel sandwich is to die for!“

“The gyros are HUGE and extremely delicious!!!!“

“Best restaurant diner around. Fabulous food. Best Greek salad spinach pie I have ever had. Homemade dressing is incredible!!!!! 5 stars all the way!!!! I will be going there all the time!!! Thank u so much!!!! Very satisfied customer Sue miranda“

“Delicious pizza!! Highly recommend to anyone who loves a good slice! Nelson and his staff make amazing food! Great service and always very friendly! May God continue to bless your business!!“

“Awesome variety of food and service always with a smile. Would definitely recommend ❤️“

“This place has really good food!! I'm really picky too, it was so friggin good. They had a deal going where you choose your foods and they make you a platter/dish of food that I could not finish in one sitting, neither could my unc lol it was a lot of good food..did I mention it was only $7 a plate?! Usually $10, which is still totally worth it. I also tried their fries, OMG they're like Checkers Rallys fries but thicker!! So delicious and fresh!! All the food was fresh and the restaurant was immaculate. I will be going back here to eat. Hey, if you live near there...you're foolish to not eat there. I gave them 5⭐“

“You can not beat this food. Cost value best Mexican / post gym meal around. Thank you so much for the great food and service“

“Thank selden pizza for donating to Hueber family!💙💛“