Kelly Banks Cakes

73 West St, New Berlin
(607) 372-5267

Recent Reviews

Brandon Woodcock

If you need a wedding cake or a dessert made for a special event then look no further then Kelly Banks. Her abilities are endless and she can do whatever you need, you just have to ask. I have the pleasure of working with Kelly multiple times throughout the year at our wedding venue and she always delivers wonderful pieces. Give her a call!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nadine He

Ordered some cupcakes for my sister: I live in Seattle, she lives in New Berlin. Kelly put together a box of beautiful cupcakes and delivered them at lightspeed.I should add that my sister's birthday is on Valentine's Day, so that makes Kelly's work even more impressive!!

David Merrill

We ordered three pies for Thanksgiving. Two were gluten free. They were all delicious. Kelly is and will be out Baker of choice from now on.Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free is available and delicious.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amanda Sutherland

I had my wedding last weekend (10/14/2023) and couldn’t have asked for a better bakery to do our desserts!! Kelly completely nailed my vision for the French macarons, cupcakes and cookies for guests. Kelly was very responsive to all of our questions during our planning process and incredibly accommodating with requests. Thank you so much for making our wedding so special!! 10/10 would highly recommend her!!

Annie W

Kelly is great, she made my Dad's 60th a few years ago and everyone raved about it. So yummy! Fast forward years later and Kelly is doing my wedding cake for me, she is so awesome, super nice and makes delicious cakes, cookies, etc for any occasion, go check her out!! I can't wait to see my wedding cake!!

Savanah Mecchella

Kelly completely delivered our vision! Everything we asked for she was able to put together beautifully for us. Not only was our vision executed perfectly but the guests at our wedding were raving about how good the cake was all night!

Karina Franceschini

I am always very skeptical when it comes to bakery cakes, because to me they’re always dry. Wow, was this NOT the case with Kelly Banks Cakes! I contact Kelly last minute because my husband and I decided to move our wedding up by three months. Lucky for us, Kelly was available! When my mom and I went for a tasting, Kelly gave us 4 different flavored cupcakes that were all delicious. For our wedding cake, we got three layers: chocolate, vanilla, and red velvet with a cream cheese buttercream icing. We wanted our cake to be simple with a few flowers on it, and Kelly absolutely nailed it. The cake was beautiful, but it tasted even better than it looked! I highly, highly recommend Kelly Banks Cakes!

Dr. Richard Baker

Good prices. Friendly service

Gwyneth Garland

DELICIOUS AND BEAUTIFUL CREATIONS BY SUCH AN AMAZING PERSON!

Richard Baker

Good prices. Friendly service

Load More