New York Pizzeria
$ • Pizza, VegetarianAbout New York Pizzeria
Customers' Favorites
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Boneless Buffalo Wings
Bacon and Tomato Pizza
New York-Style Pizza
Chicken Saltimbocca
Chicken Florentine
Mozzarella Sticks
Eggplant Parmesan
Chicken Marsala
Chicken Riggies
New York Pizzeria Reviews
232 ratings
Share your opinion about New York Pizzeria
Very Friendly atmosphere, Food was AMAZING! We had tonight's special chicken, Amelia, which was awesome. Going through New Berlin this is a must stop. Family owned restaurant very friendly.. they also have the best wine in town.
Such a charming restaurant with an amazing staff. The food was outstanding, especially the vodka sauce pasta. If I didn't live 15 hours away, it would be my favorite go to restaurant.
My partner and I always try to stop here when we’re up in the area. The pizza and main dishes are well made and seasoned. I tried the chicken piccata with broccoli the other night and it was delicious! They have a cooler full of assorted drinks and a small selection of tasty wines for take home too!
The restaurant is always clean as are the bathrooms.
The service is consistently spot on. I always enjoy a hello and chat from Rosario. He has great staff that make...read full review
The restaurant is always clean as are the bathrooms.
The service is consistently spot on. I always enjoy a hello and chat from Rosario. He has great staff that make...read full review
Hours
| Monday | 10:30AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 10:30AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 10:30AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 10:30AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 10:30AM - 9PM |
New York Pizzeria is a classic Italian spot known for its good food at good prices. The menu features popular dishes like chicken parmesan, antipasto salad, pizza, and wings, all prepared with fresh, flavorful ingredients. Customers particularly enjoy the bacon and tomato pizza and yummy heros. This family-owned restaurant is run by friendly staff, including Rosario, who always makes guests feel welcome with a hello and a chat. Many customers describe the atmosphere as amazing, nostalgic, and like home, making it a perfect stop for travelers passing through. The restaurant is always clean, with plenty of parking on both sides of the street, and is kid-friendly, welcoming families with children. The owners, especially Frank, are known for their kindness and for treating diners like family. The menu also includes a cooler with assorted drinks and a small selection of tasty wines for take-home. Many customers say the food tastes like authentic Italian, with some comparing it to the best Italian food they've had, even during military service in Italy. The stuffed pizza has been described as heavenly and very filling, while the pizza varieties by the slice are plentiful and delicious down to the last bite of crust. Overall, New York Pizzeria continues to impress with its delicious meals, warm atmosphere, and a sense of pride in its family history, offering a great experience for anyone looking for a feel-good, delicious meal in New Berlin.