16 Handles

170 S Main St, New City
(845) 634-1616

Recent Reviews

Brenda Carrasquillo

Parking: the staff is great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies & Cream, Yogurt Cup

Ann Kelly

Very friendly and helpful staff!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Waffle Cone, Yogurt Cup

Rus W.

Cool and fun place! First time we tried a ice cream/ yogurt place. Lots and lots of choices and a large selection of toppings. The employees were very friendly, helpful and explained the process to us in a pleasant manner. Just a local hang out for the teenagers in the area, which is okay but does get rather loud.

Mary Trezza

Yum, yum, yum

Adam Hussein

Well lit, clean, fully staffed and tasty!

Ñuñu S

Overall a good place. Employees could be a little more friendly.. and do less staring unless I ask you for help… what’s the point of tipping if they won’t even smile at the end of your transactionsmh ??‍♀️ makes me feel weird about even returning. I am sure there are great places in NJ.

Ali K

I was looking for a new ice cream place to try out and stumbled upon this place. They have a wide variety of frozen yogurts as well as a good range of topping options which gives you the utmost freedom to create whatever delicious yogurt you crave.

Jamila W.

The ice cream is fine. But here was my experience: my son and I walked in and got our own cup, went and got our own ice cream, put all of our own toppings onto the ice cream by ourselves, put the ice cream onto the scale for it to be measured, was never asked if we needed help, was never offered assistance, was never addressed in anyway whatsoever, and when the total came up on the screen, it asked if I wanted to leave a tip? A TIP!! FOR WHAT??!!! All of these places that have human beings working working with any kind of food at all now assume that you can just ask everybody to tip to get even more money, that we don't have, so that we can pay your employees for you?!! So you don't have to pay them as much?! We're all in hard times!! Perhaps the management would like to be able to give their employees more money and so they put the tipping option there. But it's not my responsibility to make sure that your employees have a livable wage. It's your responsibility to do that!! Not only that, at most establishments now we have to pay your credit card fees!! You cannot continue to bleed the middle class to death and expect that we won't have a massive economic collapse on our hands. It may seem like a small thing, but the constant social pressure to tip a person who is staring right at you is utterly preposterous an exhausting! So to you, 16 handles, I say, pay your employees enough and get that tip option off the screen!! And I'm going to Dairy Queen!!!!

Sara

By far my favorite ice cream place ?

Julie W.

The flavors are very tasty, the inside looks good, and the staff are friendly. Got the pistachio, cheesecake, mango, and raspberry pomegranate, a little bit of everything. It is delicious, though a little bit on the expensive side as the yelp dollars tell you (it's $.80 an ounce, and we did like for egg sized for pumps) and it came out to $7. still was nice to try and tasty.

Leonard Friedman

Fun place for froyo and toppings. Be careful as you pay by weight and can easily get expensive.

nym0m0f4

Second visit and very pleased. Expensive, but the options for dairy and non-dairy better than other local shops. They had four non-dairy of which two are specifically oat milk. We should have asked whether they rotate the oat milk to vanilla because there are so many topping but some don’t go well on pumpkin or coffee oat milk. They charge by weight after toppings. The staff is friendly. Between the amount of flavors, dairy, non-dairy, sorbet, and every topping imaginable there is something for everyone. Will be back again, just cost makes it less frequent.

Nash Williams

I drove 20 minutes for frozen yogurt and I had my mind set on cheesecake and peanut butter. The website was specific but wrong. I opted for chocolate and peanut butter and was pleasantly surprised how good they were. It wasn’t what I wanted but it will do. I guess calling ahead would be prudent if you want something specific that’s listed on the site. $6 for a half full small cup. Not cheap. I’ll probably explore other places before heading back.The store was clean, organized and the staff was friendly.

Linda W.

Not the best I've had but also not nearly the worst. Just plain OK. I had the watermelon sorbet (pretty good) & Tahitian vanilla bean (odd taste, but ok) with rainbow jimmies. Probably not my new hang out. The search for decent froyo continues...

Nash W.

I drove 20 minutes for frozen yogurt and I had my mind set on cheesecake and peanut butter. The website was specific but wrong. I opted for chocolate and peanut butter and was pleasantly surprised how good they were. It wasn't what I wanted but it will do. I guess calling ahead would be prudent if you want something specific that's lists on the site. $6 for a half full small cup. Not cheap. I'll probably explore other places before heading back. The store was clean, organized and the staff was friendly.

Load More