Caked Up Cafe
40 S Main St, New City
(845) 499-2929
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
I actually was in Lavalette NJ. I wasn’t happy with the bakery out there, so I went almost another hour out my way to try this bakery from just a picture. The bakery was beautiful. Very inviting. The workers were friendly and patient because there were so many items , I did not know what to choose. The cupcakes were outrageous, the crumb cake out of this world . Everything there was so enticing. I recommend this bakery to all. You will not be disappointed. The artwork on the cupcakes truly was amazing. Love it. Thank you for making my team at work happy when I gave they wash a cupcake.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They made a beautiful cake for my mother's 70th birthday- it was absolutely gorgeous! It was a 2 tier cake- top tier chocolate cake with raspberry filling and bottom tier vanilla cake with cannoli filling. Everyone was raving about the cake all night from how beautiful it was, to how amazing it tasted. The butter cream was slightly sweeter than I prefer for my own taste- but overall it tasted great and was gorgeous! Thank you again for helping make my mother's 70th birthday that much more special for her! I couldn't figure out how to post a picture of the cake with my review, but it was gorgeous!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
The taste of their peanut butter cookie with chocolate in it and dunked in chocolate is so disgusting. It tastes like pure chemicals. I cannot get the disgusting taste out of my mouth. I've never ever been so grossed out by a cookie. It was very stale. Same with their iced coffee. My husband had to throw it out. What a shame! I can still taste the chemical cookie flavor. Gross.
Food: 1
Always beautiful and delicious cakes from Cakedup. Our family uses cakedup for every special occasion and they never disappoint!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They did my son 20th birthday cake and it was delicious ? ? and my love son his cake so much..And now I can't for them to make my daughter graduation cake.. ❤️ ? ? ❣️
They did an amazing job with our wedding cake for 150 people! Beautiful decor, better than we asked for and tasted great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’m so glad I chose caked up for my baby girl’s first birthday. The cake was simply gorgeous and perfect in every way. Thanks you guys!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Did phenomenal job with my daughter's birthday cake, beyond amazing cake, they made a fantastic delicious mermaid cake , came out above my expectations , everyone loved it in the party. I can’t thank you enough, you made that day extra special!
Caked up provided a three trier cake for our wedding last week. So many people said it was the best cake they’d ever had!! Not only was the cake delicious but when we went to the shop for our tasting the owner couldn’t have been more sweet or generous. What an amazing place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Caked Up, you’ve outdone yourselves once more! We presented you with an extraordinary challenge - a brick-shaped cake that holds immense sentimental value as a part of our heritage. And boy, did you deliver! Not only did it resemble a brick flawlessly, but it was also the most delectable “brick” we’ve ever tasted.The three layers of vanilla cake with Dulce de Leche filling were a match made in heaven. The flavors melded together seamlessly, creating a taste sensation that left everyone in awe. The photo truly doesn’t do justice to the incredible craftsmanship and mouthwatering deliciousness of this cake.Thank you, Caked Up, for taking our impossible idea and turning it into a culinary masterpiece. You’ve made our family reunion an unforgettable event, and we’re incredibly grateful for your talent and dedication!
Restaurantji Recommends
Such great cookies here! And they’re so sweet and kind here. Great customer service, I’m traveling from California and I came because the great reviews. Delicious, highly recommend!
My favorite sweets spot around! I always get my fave strawberry cheesecake cupcake and it never disappoints. Everyone in the shop is so kind and I have to shoutout Brendan and Sam for always going above and beyond. I love it here ?
Nice place. I love their desserts. Especially their extensive array of macaroons. Friendly staff.
Look no further for designer cupcakes and cakes! Delicious and beautiful. Great customer service.
You will not be disappointed, the staff is friendly and courteous. The food is exceptional
Loading...