Caked Up Cafe

40 S Main St, New City
(845) 499-2929

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Gunsaakhi Kaur

The workers weren't caked up and I wasn't very happy about that.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

fabilicious22

The cake looked super cute from the outside! But the cake itself was dry the frosting was overly sweet… litterally no one wanted to take cake home which is a first for me! If all you care about is looks then I would say go for this place.

Denisse Castillo

Thank you for making our gender reveal cupcakes. They were beautiful and perfect 🤩.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Row

We pass by the town every few months and never miss a stop at this bakery. They offer 3 gluten free options, which I have tried and really love— macarons, rainbow cake, and rainbow cheesecake. You can order some gluten free cupcakes/cakes a day or so in advance. I only ever need one and just ask if they have any extras. Their stuff is always so cute and delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joe Kelly

Great place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Francisco Mercy Paras

WOW! THIS IS THE BEST CAKE SHOP EVER! ONCE I ATE THE CAKE, I GOT CAKED UP! IT REALLY IS TRUE!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

P Miller

Caked up provided a three trier cake for our wedding last week. So many people said it was the best cake they’d ever had!! Not only was the cake delicious but when we went to the shop for our tasting the owner couldn’t have been more sweet or generous. What an amazing place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

S “SKJ” J

I ordered customer cakes two years straight and wanted to say how great it is. I don’t know many places that do as good a job as Caked up getting all the details right. They are easy to deal with and Denise especially is great because she’ll sketch the design and sent it to you first. And it’s not just the design, the most recent cake we got also tastes really good.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lo Mein

Gorgeous confections, there’s no doubt there.

Their items are literally way too sweet, between the cake and then the frosting, my goodness. So the downside is being able to actually enjoy eating a piece.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Denise Marie LaRocca

The absolute BEST cakes and desserts! These people are literally artists with their cakes. So delicious! You won't be disappointed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Craig Schiedlo

This is the best bakery. Everything is so good. They have the best rainbow cookie ever! You have to try the cheesecake rainbow cookie. You don’t like cheesecake they have a crumb cake rainbow cookie. That is also incredible. This place has everything that you could want for a nice sweet treat. I drive over an hour just to be able to come here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Oksana Sokolova Law

It is one of the best places to come for coffee and cake! It was freezing cold outside and when I walked in. My heart was getting warmer as I was greeted by the greatness of people working here. I do appreciate everyone who works here so much. Highly recommended!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christina Geoghegan

The cookies, cakes and cupcakes are always delicious. The shop itself is adorable. They have such a fun assortment of ready make cupcakes, they are a fan favorite in my house. Their cakes are beautiful, whether it be custom orders or their ready made items. Recently, with the chaos of the holidays, I completely forgot to preorder a custom birthday cake for my daughter. The owner’s mother did me an enormous favor and was accommodate a last minute request for a birthday cake for my 2 year old. ( and in the midst of such a busy season) She saved the day! I have always been a fan of their desserts, but the level of service I received recently in going far above and beyond to help me out of this jam has given me a whole new appreciation for this bakery!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Emily Blades

I ordered gender reveal cupcakes from Caked Up and was not disappointed! The cupcakes were ordered as a game to reveal the gender, so I needed a specific amount of pink filled cupcakes and blue filled cupcakes, as well as a vegan cupcake for my mom too (majority needed to be filled with the true gender)! They followed my specific instructions 100%, even down to leaving the order slip out of the package to not give anything away! I am SO thrilled and impressed with this bakery and couldn’t be more thankful that they made my gender reveal so much fun and special. And the cupcakes were delicious! Thank you Caked Up!!!! I am so excited for my little girl 🩷

Kenny Malm

Everyone is always so friendly and helpful. Every tasty treat here is a work of art. A true local treasure.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cupcakes, Confetti Cake Pop, My Birthday Cake

Loading...