Caked Up Cafe

40 S Main St, New City
(845) 499-2929

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Confetti Cake Pop
My Birthday Cake
Cupcakes

Cookies, Brownies & Bites
Peanut Butter Fudge Cookie
Two peanut butter cookies filled with chocolate ganache and dipped in chocolate.
1/2 Pound Chocolate Chip
Classic gooey chocolate chip cookie.
Cosmic Brownie Bites
Brownie bottom with a cookie dough layer, topped with ganache and cosmic candies!
Rainbow Cheesecake Bites
Snickers Brownie Bites
Brownie base with layers of caramel, nougat, peanuts, and ganache.
Oatmeal Cream Pie
Two cinnamon oatmeal chocolate chip cookies filled with marshmallow buttercream.
Classic Brownie
Chocolate chip brownie.
Cake Pops
Confetti dipped in white chocolate OR Chocolate dipped in semi-sweet chocolate.
Twix Cookie Bar
Italian Rainbow Cookies
Traditional Italian rainbow cookies with almond, raspberry, & ganache.
Coconut Macaroons
Top of the Crumb
Little bites of the best part of the crumb cake. Just the crumb!

Crumb Cake
Classic Crumb Cake
8x8. Classic yellow cake topped with a thick layer of cinnamon streusel.
Italian Rainbow Crumb Slice
Rainbow cookie flavored slice of crumb cake.

Gourmet Cupcakes
Pack of Minis
12 pack of assorted mini cupcakes.
Cookie Dough Cupcake
Yellowcake filled and topped with cookie dough buttercream, and a mini chocolate chip cookie.
Strawberry Shortcake Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake filled with strawberry buttercream, topped with vanilla buttercream, and strawberry streusel.
Carrot Cupcake
Classic carrot cake filled and topped with whipped cream cheese buttercream and a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar.
Death by Chocolate Cupcake
Chocolate cake filled and topped with chocolate buttercream, and decorated with chocolate crunchies, chocolate sauce, and a chocolate bar.
Half Baked Cupcake
Your choice of vanilla or chocolate cake filled with cookie dough buttercream and topped with vanilla cream, mini brownie, and a cookie.
Unicorn Cupcake
Confetti cupcake with vanilla buttercream, unicorn sprinkle mix and a fondant unicorn horn.
Cookies & Cream Cupcake
Chocolate cake filled and topped with cookies and cream buttercream, and a chocolate sandwich cookie.
Maple Bacon Cupcake
Maple infused cake filled and topped with vanilla buttercream, with maple syrup, crispy bacon pieces and a stack of pancakes.
French Toast Cupcake
Cinnamon sugar cake infused with maple syrup, filled and topped with vanilla buttercream and cinnamon cereal.
Pretty Pink Princess
Pink velvet cake filled and topped with pink vanilla buttercream, decorated with edible glitter and a fondant crown.
Coconut Samoa Cake
Chocolate cake filled caramel and topped with coconut buttercream, toasted coconut, caramel, and chocolate drizzle.
Red Velvet Cupcake
Classic red velvet cake filled and topped with whipped cream cheese buttercream.
Confetti Cupcake
Confetti sprinkle cake filled and topped with vanilla buttercream and decorated with rainbow sprinkles.
Over the Rainbow
Blue velvet cupcake with blue vanilla buttercream, rainbow nonpareils and a candy rainbow on top!
Vanilla Vanilla Cupcake
Yellowcake filled and topped with homemade vanilla buttercream.
Classic Hostess
Your choice of chocolate or vanilla!
Reeses Pieces
Vanilla cupcake filled with Reeses pieces, topped with peanut butter buttercream and Reeses candies!
Vanilla Chocolate Cupcake
Yellow cake filled and topped with milk chocolate buttercream with seasonal sprinkles.
Vanilla Coconut Cupcake
Vanilla cake filled and topped with coconut buttercream and coconut flakes.
Chocolate Chip Pancake
Maple infused cake filled and topped with vanilla buttercream, covered in chocolate chips with a stack of pancakes.
Vanilla Caramel Cupcake
Vanilla cupcake filled with caramel, topped with vanilla buttercream and an extra drizzle of caramel.
Candles
Pack of assorted birthday candles.

6 Inch Cakes
Cookies and Cream Cake
Chocolate cake with layers of cookies and cream buttercream with chocolate drip.
Half Baked Cake
A layer of brownie sandwiched between layers of vanilla cake. One layer of brownie buttercream, and one layer of cookie dough buttercream.
Piñata Confetti Cake
Confetti cake, layers of vanilla buttercream, filled with candy and rainbow sprinkles.
Double Chocolate Cake
Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream and a chocolate drip.
Strawberry Cake
Layers of vanilla cake with strawberry buttercream filling.
Cookie Dough Cake
Vanilla cake with cookie dough buttercream.
Dulce De Leche Cake
Layers of vanilla cake with dulce de leech buttercream filling.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: nextdoor
Photo credit: nextdoor
+76 photos
Photo credit: nextdoor
+75 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We pass by the town every few months and never miss a stop at this bakery. They offer 3 gluten free options, which I have tried and really love— macarons, rainbow cake, and rainbow cheesecake. You can order some gluten free cupcakes/cakes a day or so in advance. I only ever need one and just ask if they have any extras. Their stuff is always so cute and delicious.
August 2025
Caked up provided a three trier cake for our wedding last week. So many people said it was the best cake they’d ever had!! Not only was the cake delicious but when we went to the shop for our tasting the owner couldn’t have been more sweet or generous. What an amazing place!
May 2025
I ordered customer cakes two years straight and wanted to say how great it is. I don’t know many places that do as good a job as Caked up getting all the details right. They are easy to deal with and Denise especially is great because she’ll sketch the design and sent it to you first. And it’s not just the design, the most recent cake we got also tastes really good.
March 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Ray's Pizza & Restaurant - 46 S Main St
Pizza, Italian
Domino's Pizza - 39 S Main St
Pizza, Chicken Wings, Vegetarian
Manny's Famous Deli - 50 S Main St
Deli

Caked Up Cafe

40 S Main St, New City, NY 10956
(845) 499-2929