New City Kosher Deli

282 S Main St, New City
(845) 639-4943

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Erica Brown

Stopped in to get my daughter matzah ball soup as she was not feeling well. Ordered two quarts to go. Only two medium Matzah balls in each quart. The rest of the soup felt like it was from Campbell’s. Mainly mini string noodles. I could have made better at home. Thought since I’m here I’ll try something famous. The man behind the counter said the corned beef was amazing. So I ordered that to go along with a veggie cake. Didn’t want all the carbs from a Knish. The man asked me if I like bread. And I was flustered. People standing behind me to order. I would have said yes on Rye please but he proceeded to just give me sliced corn beef as deli meat wrapped in paper, threw in a mustard and a pickle and charge me full price for a corn beef sandwich. The veggie cake was flaky crumbs with what tasted liked canned or frozen bag of peas and mini squared carrots. Was NOT good. The corned beef was tasty but dry and about the only thing I loved was the pickle and the mustard. I would have preferred to have been asked if I wanted my sandwich without bread?!?! And I left there with two soups, slices of corned beef, and a veggie cake for $49 dollars. I was floored. Next time I’ll make my own soup! Also as someone stated my stomach is off today. I made my own corned beef and Swiss (my own cheese) with mustard and today my stomach is burning. I don’t normally eat deli meats so perhaps that’s why. I would not go back simply for the price. The ordering process as I did not order a sandwich without bread and pay for one with. And there was one table there and it felt a weird vibe. There has to be a better place! I’m very upset that I got scammed out of a full sandwich also!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

randall marchena

I had high hopes for this kosher deli, but unfortunately, it fell far short of expectations. The food was mediocre at best – bland, dry, and lacking any real flavor. The chicken nuggest were frozen garbage. For the prices they charge, I expected much better quality. To make matters worse, at the end of our terrible meal, we were unable to use their bathrooms (men’s and women’s) due to cleaning that would last 15 minutes. When we politely asked to use one, the staff was incredibly snotty and dismissive, as if we were inconveniencing them by even asking. It's shocking in this day and age that a restaurant would overlook such a basic necessity while open for customers. Save yourself the trouble and find somewhere else that cares about both food quality and customer comfort. Very disappointing. I won’t be back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sam Lovi

Always happy with the food here!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pastrami Sandwich

Steve Howard

After not having tables available forever and take out only we were pleasantly surprised to see tables available. No table service so you order and pick a table. Counter person was extremely pleasant and accommodating. Food was hot and good so no complaints from me. Spread the word… you can now eat at a table.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Harrison Reiner

Best pastrami, corned beef and noodle pudding in the county. Their mushroom knishes are perfection. Their chopped liver is faultless. Excellent seven layer cake as well as yummy cherry chocolate covered marshmallow twists. My favorite chicken and tuna salad in the county. The quality of food here excels. It’s like Rockland’s own Katz’s deli. Shawna who works here treats you like family. Her level of service is so appreciated and she always makes me the best hot dog on a bun. So yummy. Do not miss.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lionel Vankline (mrlgvk)

Excellent sandwiches

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Corned Beef Sandwich, Pastrami Sandwich

S W

Great food and service. I usually get the knishes, chicken soup, and roast beef. Great quality.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Yosef K

If you are religious, this is not Kosher. They are open on shabbos and it’s misleading. Don’t eat treif.

Mike Prechtel

Take out only, but best food

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Corned Beef Sandwich, Hot Pastrami, Matzoh Ball Soup with Noodles, Pastrami Sandwich

S V

Great food and service. I usually get the knishes, chicken soup, and roast beef. Great quality.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Steve

Only suggestion is having a low sodium matzo ball soup so the consumer can adjust to taste. It’s way too salty.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 5

luis mosquera

Food is very good service is quick

Craig Jauvtis

Good food but they lose stars for not having sit down anymore. I understand not having table service anymore but at least let people eat there like a fast casual place.

Allan Dembowitz

Andrew is most accommodating. Will go the extra mile to get you what you need.

Alexander Lepes

Delicious! And super accommodating to special requests.

Loading...