MARCH 15, 2025 - I decided to give Paisanos another chance as requested after my first review. I ordered large pepperoni pizza, fries and 2 drinks for delivery. They said 45 min. That was 2:50 pm. I called at 3:45 pm inquiring about my order. The person on the phone couldn't give me an answer. Someone else came on the phone to let me know that the order was delivered and did I check outside my door. The pizza and fries were outside the door on the ground and COLD. They delivered and didn't have the decency to ring the doorbell.
My first review, I said relationship with Paisanos was over. Now it is.
Daniel Philip
New Spot! great pizza, tasted really good and had loads of toppings. I liked the faint sweetness of the crust and the chicken tasted great. Tried the chicken bacon ranch and the chipotle chicken slice . Amazing
Michael Brangaccio
Ordered delivery from them twice. Both times over an hour before close. Took my order. Didn't show up both times. Stay away
William Daberkow
They stay open late on Christmas eve, to make sure we had food! They gave us free slices and the food was amazing
Maria Di Cara
The food is great here and I absolutely love the girl who answers the phone & takes the orders and does deliveries, she is so sweet and kind and the pizza here is really great. The dough smells wonderful and they do a great job with delivering in a timely fashion. Thank you so much Paesanos!
John resciniti
Eat there a few times, always delicious food
Parking: Easy peasy It’s on 304 by the hard wok buffet
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grilled Chicken Salad, House Salad, Slice of Pizza, Sicilian Pizza
Luke Jaeger
Great little pizza shop, the owner loves to make pizzas and you can often find some of his mad scientist creations in the front window. Always has some sort of classic desert in the fridge, store is always super clean. Great news shop and if you love pizza, gotta come try it.
My personal favorite: The SCAR. spinach, chicken (grilled), avocado, ranch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lesslie Meza
Paid for Chicken Alfredo. They forgot the chicken.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Esteban Table
Sauce is good. Crust is crispy. Garlic knots are HUGE! Workers are nice and friendly. Place is super clean. I got absolutely nothing to complain about
This chicken franchise sandwich is the cheapest sandwich ever. Half of this sandwich with barely any chicken. Literally just a bread sandwich. Service was bad- half out order was missing and we waited for them to make the other half. Obviously the food was cold and the girl had an attitude. Take your money elsewhere in New City because this was not worth it
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Taryn Brady
Came in the other day for a quick slice and was immediately served with a friendly smile from the girl that worked there. The slice was absolutely delicious (I think I got the margarita square?). Clean atmosphere and nice staff, can’t ask for much more! Thank you for a nice lunch
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen
Pizza is delicious ? pasta is better than any Italian restaurant in Middletown..the service is excellent..
Good pizza
MARCH 15, 2025 - I decided to give Paisanos another chance as requested after my first review. I ordered large pepperoni pizza, fries and 2 drinks for delivery. They said 45 min. That was 2:50 pm. I called at 3:45 pm inquiring about my order. The person on the phone couldn't give me an answer. Someone else came on the phone to let me know that the order was delivered and did I check outside my door. The pizza and fries were outside the door on the ground and COLD. They delivered and didn't have the decency to ring the doorbell.
My first review, I said relationship with Paisanos was over. Now it is.
New Spot!
great pizza, tasted really good and had loads of toppings. I liked the faint sweetness of the crust and the chicken tasted great.
Tried the chicken bacon ranch and the chipotle chicken slice . Amazing
Ordered delivery from them twice. Both times over an hour before close. Took my order. Didn't show up both times. Stay away
They stay open late on Christmas eve, to make sure we had food! They gave us free slices and the food was amazing
The food is great here and I absolutely love the girl who answers the phone & takes the orders and does deliveries, she is so sweet and kind and the pizza here is really great. The dough smells wonderful and they do a great job with delivering in a timely fashion. Thank you so much Paesanos!
Eat there a few times, always delicious food
Parking: Easy peasy
It’s on 304 by the hard wok buffet
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grilled Chicken Salad, House Salad, Slice of Pizza, Sicilian Pizza
Great little pizza shop, the owner loves to make pizzas and you can often find some of his mad scientist creations in the front window. Always has some sort of classic desert in the fridge, store is always super clean. Great news shop and if you love pizza, gotta come try it.
My personal favorite: The SCAR. spinach, chicken (grilled), avocado, ranch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paid for Chicken Alfredo. They forgot the chicken.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sauce is good. Crust is crispy. Garlic knots are HUGE! Workers are nice and friendly. Place is super clean. I got absolutely nothing to complain about
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Cheese Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
This chicken franchise sandwich is the cheapest sandwich ever. Half of this sandwich with barely any chicken. Literally just a bread sandwich. Service was bad- half out order was missing and we waited for them to make the other half. Obviously the food was cold and the girl had an attitude. Take your money elsewhere in New City because this was not worth it
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Came in the other day for a quick slice and was immediately served with a friendly smile from the girl that worked there. The slice was absolutely delicious (I think I got the margarita square?). Clean atmosphere and nice staff, can’t ask for much more! Thank you for a nice lunch
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is delicious ? pasta is better than any Italian restaurant in Middletown..the service is excellent..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not tastey
Loading...