Peach Pit Cafe
200 S Main St, New City
(845) 708-5312
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Great healthy food!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sweet Potato Fries, Avocado Bowl, Vampire Blood
Great smoothies has the beach bum
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tried vegan mac and cheese and vegan peach burger with fries. Loved the mac and cheese!
There was no wait and no one else in the restaurant. Although we were sitting to eat in, they packed out meals. Iced green tea and lemonade were good.
We wanted to try a smoothie or juice but it was $13.75 for a 16 oz -more than our meals separately and more expensive than NYC prices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Vegan
I’m not gonna write a length review. Loved this place for years. Great bowl every time. I’ve seen a lot of complains about the new location, my bowl was amazing. Nice people. Not much more to say!
Had you asked me the last I visited when they were at their previous location, I would’ve given 5 stars hands down! Idk what changed but I went to their new location for the first time yesterday and quality went way down. I used to get excited to stop here when I was in the area or sometimes drove 25 mins just for their pink mermaid bowl & several of their pizzas made with a thin crispy cauliflower dough, it was amazing! Yesterday, our experience was more than lacking. We ordered the Harvest “flat” with Brie cheese, fig jam, million dollar bacon & caramelized onions and a pink mermaid, both 2 of our usual faves here, price came to $40 with tip. The pizza was horrible and we only ate 2-3 slices bc we paid almost $50 for 2 items. We didn’t notice they changed their pizzas to a thick flat bread instead of the yummy & healthy thin style cauliflower dough. It was greasy and contained mostly cheese and had zero flavor profile bc the Brie was so overpowering. We didn’t see or taste any jam and this pizza used to be packed with flavor. Had we realized this was their new style we would never had ordered it (now you have to order the cauliflower for an extra charge, I double checked the menu to see if I had ordered the wrong thing & it stated this in small print). The bowl was made with the same pretty presentation but there was a noticeable difference in portion sizes, they used to really fill up the container to the point they were pressing the fruit on top down with the lid, our bowl yesterday had about a 1/4 of room to the top and the actual bowl was far less. I rarely write a bad review bc I believe in supporting local but I’m really hoping the owner’s will see and go back to the outstanding quality & portions that made this place a hidden gem. The new location is tucked away and if you’re not from the area, you won’t find it easily. Please go back to your old quality, we really loved coming here as a once in a while treat or something we’d get a hankering for and drive across Rockland to get but now I doubt we’ll be back. If your customers have to go somewhere else after ordering from you, something went wrong.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
THANK YOU for having VEGAN OPTIONS!
And they are even called out specially in their own sections of the menu! ❤️
Dietary restrictions: Vegan options
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vegan
Just had the best cauliflower crust pizza delivered. It was delicious!! Will definitely be ordering from here again. Ordered oats too for the morning they look equally scrummy.
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free cauliflower base was so delicious and crispy.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is so good. The flatbread was amazing and the burgers are to die for. The Vanilla Gorilla shake is the best. So so delish.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dave's Hot Chicken, Harvest Flat
Our office ordered from this place for the first time today and unfortunately, our experience was quite disappointing. The food was extremely salty, to the point where even the sweet potato fries were over-seasoned. The food overall has left us all feeling very nauseous.
I was dining at Peach Pit the other day, there was a very friendly redhead working there. She was so amazing. Despite the busy environment, they were incredibly efficient. Her positive attitude and professionalism truly stood out, making my dining experience enjoyable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Food is JUST okay. Quality not great as they claim and WAY overpriced. Takes too long to be made as I believe there is only one cook. Owner is beyond rude and most of the staff are as well. Wouldn’t reccomend and I’m sad Back To Earth closed as they were the only closer quality juice place. Ps- please don’t rep the Grateful Dead if you aren’t kind people!
***3 1/2 stars***
It's rare that I say this, but the biggest issue this place has is its atmosphere - it's incredibly dingy with minimal personality, and it's so drab that it actually takes away from what was a perfectly decent experience in every other way. I stopped by here for lunch yesterday, in the mood for an acai bowl (which are not easy to find around here unless you want to dole out for the Uber Eats, a risk anyway because it's not a guarantee the acai is still going to be pretty frozen. Believe me - I speak from experience.). Despite having a pretty decent idea of where Peach Pit was, it took a little bit of navigating to locate it. The strip mall it's in (which is honestly in need of a spiffy upgrade too; looks very 80s in a bad way) is VAST; I would guess there are close to 50 businesses in here, and Peach Pit is tucked away in a dark corner next to a now-closed boutique movie theater.
The young lad at the counter was perfectly nice (I actually thought it was cute that he was on his phone at a nearby table - why not? no one was in there - and BOLTED up and scampered to the counter when I opened the door) and efficient. The menu is a little odd; it feels very much like a poor man's Playa Bowls, in that you have acai bowl and smoothie sections, but there's also random breakfast sandwiches and lunch entrees. I'm a little leery of a place that doesn't seem to know exactly what it is, but I'd also point out that this area in northern Rockland is practically famous for combining as many random genres into its establishments as possible, especially the kosher ones (this is not kosher). Also eyebrow-raising for ostensibly a bowl place - there were literally only two acai bowl options, and considerably more pitaya and coconut bowl selections available. At least I didn't have to spend too much time reviewing the menu here.
Ultimately I went with the Coconutella acai bowl (strawberries, banana and nutella) without the coconut flakes. Honestly? It wasn't bad. The presentation factor that you get at Playa isn't really there, but that's not something to me that affects the quality and taste of what you're eating. Because the plastic bowl/container it's in is narrower than a mainstream option, you don't have the ability to get frisky with the design on the top layer; pretty easy fix if that's a legitimate issue for customers. It DID make it slightly more difficult to dig into the bottom tier where the actual acai is, but that's really not much of a complaint. All of the ingredients tasted fresh and it was a decent portion. I think it came to $16 for the large, which is on par with the competition.
A change of scenery would do this place absolute wonders - I obviously sampled a very small percentage of the offerings, but it's pretty clear that even getting some actual sunlight into the Peach Pit would make a big difference. Hopefully they can find a much better location in the future.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Hangover burger was fantastic. Looking forward to the next meal. Thank you guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food here is outstanding. I tried Dave's Hot Chicken Sandwich yesterday and it was off the hook, the honey Chicken Sandwich is a close runner up. This place is a must try, absolutely delicious.
Breakfast sandwich is delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...