Petey Wheaty’s

145 S Main St, New City
(845) 708-5030

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Alan Varghese

Pretty good ice cream (Gillette creamery) at very good prices (Waffle cone with 3 scoops for $6.65). They have 12 flavors of hard ice cream, a couple of soft-serves and vegan sorbets. The staff is really friendly, have plenty of parking, some outdoor seating and they allow sampling.They are also a eatery and sell Brownies/cake, hotdogs, sandwiches, burgers, cafe items etc.Our favorite flavors were the Death my chocolate and Toasted mount (coconut and what felt like almond joy bits). The cappuccino and black raspberry chip (vegan and regular) were also good.

Heather Koubek Jameson

Tried Taquitos take out here and it was delicious! Freshly made, reasonably priced and so tasty!! We will be back!

Manish Rajguru

Great service and delicious ice creams. A variety of choices with some dairy free options too. The also have a bunch of hot food as well.

John Meagle

Absolutely awesome spot! Wide variety of flavors to choose from. I went with classic vanilla soft serve ? ?? super friendly and kind staff that really cares about their product and delivers the best costumer experience you could reasonably expect at an ice cream shop ; 100% recommend. Had to make an addition to this review. I wish I could give more than 5 stars! The owner of this establishment can rest assured that when he can’t be on site his business is in more than capable and caring hands. She noticed I was having a longggg day and was pretty tired and blessed me with a FREE cup of the cappuccino ice cream ? just what I needed perfect pick me up at the end of a long hot day!

Vikram

Great ice cream and other snacks and food. Peaty is a gracious host and loves dogs! Our boy got a pup cup on the house and loved every lick of it :) thank you for a wonderful summer afternoon peaty!!

Joe Swiss

5/5. Ice cream was always amazing but the new Mexican menu is great! Love these tacos, can’t wait to come back!!

Shelby Davis

The best homemade ice cream in Rockland county. My family and I come here regularly and every time we absolutely enjoy the ice cream. The owners are so nice and always make sure to give us a delicious complementary cookie with our ice cream. Amazing service, ice cream, and food. Highly recommend!

Layla Castro

This place is so good! They have many flavors and have vegan non,dairy and low calorie ice cream. I love this place and will always come back!

Nicholas Lea

Quality Ice cream and food! Amazing service! Wonderful staff! Highly recommend

Russell Sternlicht

Really good ice cream selection of unique flavors

Deja

Update: I have gotten numerous perspectives and they were all appalled that they call that a large ice cream cup. Not much bigger than a sauce cup. I did not want cookies and cannot eat gluten. I wanted a proper large vanilla soft serve. On top of that the taste was not up to par, and most of it was melted within minutes due to how they shoved it in the cup. I will have to take the trip to Ernie’s ice cream in Suffern today.I am so disappointed. I ordered a large soft serve ice cream. I received what is a definite small cup. I went back to confirm that I received the large as it was smaller than the hard ice cream regular size. They said that it was in fact the large. $6 for this. I’ll leave it at that.

Joe Bavazzano

Great service and ice cream. Everyone is always friendly!

Krista Cardillo

This place is a must try if you haven't yet! The owner Peter was the nicest guy and truly cares about his customers. There is such a wide selection of ice cream and food options on the menu. Lunch/Dinner and dessert in one stop! He made us ice cream sandwiches with freshly baked chocolate chip cookies and threw in some extra cookies to go. The price was beyond reasonable compared to most places in Rockland. Go check it out!

Dave Hedden

Love the flavors. Graham slam is our favorite.

J S

Great ice cream, many flavors and they sell food...

Loading...