Best pizza ever! Awesome buffet and great wing night on Wednesday!
Carl L
6/22/25-5* Server, food, & atmosphere. A must stop just off SR 8 between Utica & SR 20. Stop once and you will return, like we did
Laura Critelli
I don’t understand the negative reviews. This is by far my favorite tomato pie and I am a total tomato pie snob. lol. Picking one up to share with my dad in a couple hours. It’s consistently the BEST.
Susan June (Suzie)
I have gone here since I was a small child. I am never disappointed. If you haven't been, just do it! Great service, great food.
abriana tidmore
Disgusting pizza delivered through door dash looks like they didn’t care just as long as it got out the door burned the pepperoni and undercooked the pizza 10/10 do not recommend
Canadaprintings
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
We had the pleasure of working with Tony’s Pizzeria, and they were absolutely fantastic customers! They ordered our Pizza Chef Inflatable from CanadaPrintings, and their enthusiasm and professionalism made the process smooth from start to finish.
Tony’s Pizzeria is not just a great business to work with, but they also truly care about their brand and their customers. If you’re looking for a place with delicious pizza, a welcoming atmosphere, and a team that goes the extra mile, Tony’s is the spot!
Highly recommended—both as a business and as a top-notch pizzeria! 🍕🔥
⸻
Matt Loiacono
The buffet is OUTSTANDING!!! Tons of options!
Jack Smith Fan Club
the owners are Trump supporters and our vocal about it on Facebook. if they don't have the intelligence to keep their business from alienating possible customers, the pizza likely sucks anyway
elite9800
Pizza is so gross. Little Caesars is 3x better than tonys and little Caesars is garbage so there you go ?
This was my first time ordering from here and I used DoorDash, I had ordered pizza and wings and when I received it the pizza was so sloppy made as if it was rushed, there was barely any cheese on it was mostly sauce was highly disappointed couldn’t even eat it.
Food: 1
Service: 2
Amanda
I recently visited Tony’s Pizza with my elderly mother, and unfortunately, we had a very upsetting experience. My mother had an accident on her way to the bathroom, and rather than helping us or handling the situation with compassion, the waitresses were incredibly unprofessional. They openly laughed, made rude comments, and even encouraged other patrons to do the same by mentioning how bad it smelled.
This behavior was not only hurtful but deeply humiliating for my mother, and it left us both feeling disrespected and embarrassed. I understand accidents happen, but the lack of empathy and basic human decency from the staff was unacceptable. I hope Tony’s will take this as a learning opportunity to train their employees on how to treat customers with kindness, especially in sensitive situations.
Service: 1
K-love
We were just visiting from Florida, but everything we had was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Don Walker
Realized, my family and I have been coming here for 40+ years and still love it!
Always delicious pizza. Wings were crispy.
Best pizza ever! Awesome buffet and great wing night on Wednesday!
6/22/25-5* Server, food, & atmosphere. A must stop just off SR 8 between Utica & SR 20. Stop once and you will return, like we did
I don’t understand the negative reviews. This is by far my favorite tomato pie and I am a total tomato pie snob. lol. Picking one up to share with my dad in a couple hours. It’s consistently the BEST.
I have gone here since I was a small child. I am never disappointed. If you haven't been, just do it! Great service, great food.
Disgusting pizza delivered through door dash looks like they didn’t care just as long as it got out the door burned the pepperoni and undercooked the pizza 10/10 do not recommend
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ We had the pleasure of working with Tony’s Pizzeria, and they were absolutely fantastic customers! They ordered our Pizza Chef Inflatable from CanadaPrintings, and their enthusiasm and professionalism made the process smooth from start to finish. Tony’s Pizzeria is not just a great business to work with, but they also truly care about their brand and their customers. If you’re looking for a place with delicious pizza, a welcoming atmosphere, and a team that goes the extra mile, Tony’s is the spot! Highly recommended—both as a business and as a top-notch pizzeria! 🍕🔥 ⸻
The buffet is OUTSTANDING!!! Tons of options!
the owners are Trump supporters and our vocal about it on Facebook. if they don't have the intelligence to keep their business from alienating possible customers, the pizza likely sucks anyway
Pizza is so gross. Little Caesars is 3x better than tonys and little Caesars is garbage so there you go ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
This was my first time ordering from here and I used DoorDash, I had ordered pizza and wings and when I received it the pizza was so sloppy made as if it was rushed, there was barely any cheese on it was mostly sauce was highly disappointed couldn’t even eat it.
Food: 1
Service: 2
I recently visited Tony’s Pizza with my elderly mother, and unfortunately, we had a very upsetting experience. My mother had an accident on her way to the bathroom, and rather than helping us or handling the situation with compassion, the waitresses were incredibly unprofessional. They openly laughed, made rude comments, and even encouraged other patrons to do the same by mentioning how bad it smelled.
This behavior was not only hurtful but deeply humiliating for my mother, and it left us both feeling disrespected and embarrassed. I understand accidents happen, but the lack of empathy and basic human decency from the staff was unacceptable. I hope Tony’s will take this as a learning opportunity to train their employees on how to treat customers with kindness, especially in sensitive situations.
Service: 1
We were just visiting from Florida, but everything we had was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Realized, my family and I have been coming here for 40+ years and still love it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Wings, Everything Wings, Garlic Wings
BEST chicken wing pizza
Delicious blueberry cheese cake
Fresh hot peperoni roll
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brownie, Cherry Cheesecake, Cannoli
Loading...