Umberto's Of New Hyde Park

633 Jericho Turnpike, New Hyde Park
(516) 437-7698

Recent Reviews

OpenTable Diner

The food was good. Our table was chilly. One meal was late. We never got bread. Cappuccino was NOT decaf. Appetizers were small for the price. We had to ask for utensils. Staff seemed to be running around disorganized. This may be a management and training issue.

OpenTable Diner

Always outstanding food and service! Staff and managers are the best!


Celebrated my sister in laws birthday, food was delicious, our waiter was superb, everyone was so very nice and friendly! Lovely place, will recommend and absolutely go again!!!

OpenTable Diner

The waiter was so accommodating to our party. He was so nice and we felt very comfortable and welcomed there. The food was all excellent. I am definitely coming back!

OpenTable Diner

Excellent food as always and their staff is always making sure if we needed anything.

Jenna Odett Laskin

Great casual Italian / pizza option pre or post UBS arena event

OpenTable Diner

Great service and food


Service is superior. Food is always good and piping hot. Great wine selection. The matradi Cheech is always making sure customers are happy. My only complaint, is the extra fee for credit cards. I frequent many restaurants, and all the better ones don't charge for credit. I'd feel much better if you would just add it into the plate cost.


Always the Best, can never go wrong for a fabulous Italian meal with the greatest service. Just awesome !


The place is nice and the employees are friendly, however, it took them 30 minutes to come over and take our order and it took over an hour to receive our food. The food was very good, just not worth waiting over an hour for.


Excellent Christmas Eve meal! The special pasta with a half lobster and clams was excellent.

OpenTable Diner

Christmas Eve


The food and services were excellent which made for a memorable family gathering.


Always great food and pizza. The only thing we went Christmas eve and it was a fixed menu.


We went to Umberto’s last night with friends for a kickoff dinner to start the holiday season. The place was packed but the service was top notch. Our server Will was phenomenal. We ordered a lot of food and he wrote nothing down, his mind is like a steel trap. He was on point and we received everything we ordered with no problem. I commend Will and all of the other staff for their hard work, especially during this crazy time. We’ve been eating at Umberto’s for decades and will always continue to do so.

Load More