Nice staff but we sat inside and every single table was dirty. We wiped down a spot to sit. Place was empty, plenty of time for them to clean the tables. Pizza by the slice was not impressive. Could not recommend.
Im paralyzed
Great service and food was great
Kelly Mendez
This place was exceptional. The food and the service was great!! Who would’ve thought fettuccini Alfredo, Mac & cheese bites, wings & wraps would be soooooo GOOD from a little pizza shop. Me & A group of friends were in New Paltz for a weekend get away and if we ever come back, we will deff come back. Thank you guys!!!
Ryan Teeler
Food was amazing, staff was friendly and attentive. Vegan options for my wife and daughter made it an easy choice. Will definitely be back.
Zoe MaryAnn Tozzi
The food is delicious and the counter guys are so nice! This place offers EVERYTHING you want in a "pizza place" but it's so much more!
Ethan Ely
Good pizza. Friendly crew. Will pizza again!
Bob Clarke
Best pizza and garlic knots ever
Nazia
My brother goes to school in New Paltz and always raves about this place. We decided to give it a shot on our weekend trip upstate and let me tell you this was way beyond my expectations. They served us our pizza and burgers fresh off the grill. The pizza crust was crisp and just perfect. I can’t stop thinking about it!
Ava Terifay
The only good thing was the fries. Hawiian pizza was not made correctly, toppings were cold and fell off. Macaroni and cheese was cold underneath.Wings were not seasoned other than the sauce.Service was slow and bad. Would not recommend to a friend.
Natalie K.
Pizza is always fresh and hot. The staff is always friendly. This is our go to pizza place. Garlic knots are the bomb diggedy. Thank you, Flames!
Best slice in New Paltz, the cheese slice is easily one of the best in the Hudson Valley... Specialty pies are never dissapointing.. parms are on point. Meatball and red onion pie just might be the best pizza I've ever had.
Jason Ziegelhofer
Wow great chicken parmesan specialty pizza. The crust, marinara, cheese and breaded chicken were tasty and well seasoned. Last week I had a meatball parmesan and the meatballs are handmade with seasoning and onions. Great flavors, will definitely be ordering again.
Nechama Anolik
Really yummy vegan pizza!
Rich Augustine
very good pizza staff is A+
zead ramada
If you wanna talk pizza, it’s the best around no question!
Nice staff but we sat inside and every single table was dirty. We wiped down a spot to sit. Place was empty, plenty of time for them to clean the tables. Pizza by the slice was not impressive. Could not recommend.
Great service and food was great
This place was exceptional. The food and the service was great!! Who would’ve thought fettuccini Alfredo, Mac & cheese bites, wings & wraps would be soooooo GOOD from a little pizza shop. Me & A group of friends were in New Paltz for a weekend get away and if we ever come back, we will deff come back. Thank you guys!!!
Food was amazing, staff was friendly and attentive. Vegan options for my wife and daughter made it an easy choice. Will definitely be back.
The food is delicious and the counter guys are so nice! This place offers EVERYTHING you want in a "pizza place" but it's so much more!
Good pizza. Friendly crew. Will pizza again!
Best pizza and garlic knots ever
My brother goes to school in New Paltz and always raves about this place. We decided to give it a shot on our weekend trip upstate and let me tell you this was way beyond my expectations. They served us our pizza and burgers fresh off the grill. The pizza crust was crisp and just perfect. I can’t stop thinking about it!
The only good thing was the fries. Hawiian pizza was not made correctly, toppings were cold and fell off. Macaroni and cheese was cold underneath.Wings were not seasoned other than the sauce.Service was slow and bad. Would not recommend to a friend.
Pizza is always fresh and hot. The staff is always friendly. This is our go to pizza place. Garlic knots are the bomb diggedy. Thank you, Flames!
Restaurantji Recommends
Best slice in New Paltz, the cheese slice is easily one of the best in the Hudson Valley... Specialty pies are never dissapointing.. parms are on point. Meatball and red onion pie just might be the best pizza I've ever had.
Wow great chicken parmesan specialty pizza. The crust, marinara, cheese and breaded chicken were tasty and well seasoned. Last week I had a meatball parmesan and the meatballs are handmade with seasoning and onions. Great flavors, will definitely be ordering again.
Really yummy vegan pizza!
very good pizza staff is A+
If you wanna talk pizza, it’s the best around no question!