Service was great, food was fantastic ! (even though they dont have a turkey club lol) I will 100% be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips, Fries, Quesadilla
L H
Visited new paltz for a few days and decided to stop off here for a midday pint after walking some of the rail trail.The Irish bartender was a pleasure to chat to, cheers!
Service: 5
Arun Lahiri
Great place for comfort food. Nice atmosphere. Staff extremely friendly and efficient. Food very well done and fresh. Loved the idea of Nachos featuring potato chips!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork Sandwich, Fries, Fish and Chips
Ben Brisson
We loved our meal here. We had fish & chips and a burger. Our waiter Pete was so friendly & accommodating. We would highly recommend this restaurant for a delicious meal & warm atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips
Nina R.
Yesterday, my sorority alumni met at Maggie Mae's for our fall luncheon. My seat had the perfect view of changing fall leaves. The weather here on Long Island was absolutely horrible. When I set out on my road trip upstate, I almost turned around and went home. I am so glad that I didn't! Not only did I share some funny memories and have some good laughs with my sisters of all ages, but I had an incredible lunch, followed by a dessert that almost literally blew me away! I'll post the pictures, but I'll tell you that I had a delicious chicken francaise with asparagus and the most wonderful mashed potatoes. I saved most of the potatoes for last, with a fair bit of the sauce. I only wish that I had brought a rubber scraper with me so I could get every last delicious speck of mashed potatoes. Then came my favorite part: dessert! The menu describesit as a rich chocolate Guinness cake with cream cheese frosting. Yelp reader, I am a Guinness girl. However, I could not begin to conceptualize how the two flavors would work together. Not only did they work together wonderfully, but the cream cheese frosting put an interesting sweet little twist on the flavor. I have a terrible sweet tooth. and when I find a sweet that I like, I just can't get enough of it. I wish I could have another piece of that cake right now...
Michael Watt
Nice place to visit. Our server was quite anxious to make sure we got what we wanted.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sharon M
We had a delicious lunch overlooking the golf course on a beautiful sunny day. We had called and asked to move our reservation up an hour and the owner graciously accommodated us. The owner also served our meal and he was very kind and attentive. We thoroughly enjoyed our meal at this charming restaurant.
Navigate530312
$135 per couple for a lunch which consisted of London Broil (not a great choice) with mashed potatoes and 3 asparagus. No salad or appetizer included. Also, there was no other choice offered for those who do not eat red meat. There wasn't even an hour of open-bar offered. These golfers play there and eat/drink there aferwards. They support this place and spend quite a bit all year. It's rather selfish and unfortunate that Garvin has forgotten the people who were there for him when he started out as a manager at Shay O'Brien
Anthony Meli
If they only still served the prime rib. (WAS) the best on the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christina Venuto
A beautiful spot with great outdoor seating. Our food was good, it would have been better if they hadn’t forgotten our children’s orders. Our service was poor. The table that came in after us was greeted and received water immediately. I had to ask twice (we also had to ask for our bill twice). My salad was served with no dressing. Not a huge deal but the server started blaming others rather than simply getting the dressing. My husband’s water was refilled but the server walked away prior to refilling mine. A couple entered well into our time there. They ate and left before we got our check (different server). It was a long, frustrating meal. I’ll add that the kid’s menu is verbal so we ordered not knowing the prices … it was very expensive for what they were served.
We were there for a post memorial gathering. Garvin and staff are top notch!
colleen w
Excellent food, nice view . Nice place to gather with family and friends to honor our aunt ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
George J
Went in for lunch after a round. Very good food and nice attentive! Staff. Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Larry K.
Maggie Maes has a beautiful location over the golf course. The service is great and the food is tasty.
ESB NYC
In the area and took a chance on this place, a lovely terrace looks out over the golf course but we ate inside. Fish & chips was very good, others enjoyed their meals. Our waitress was great but one problem is that she works alone and it seems the kitchen is understaffed too, it took about an hour for our food to arrive. Way too long. Otherwise a pleasant experience.Wheelchair accessibility: Up a flight of stairs, doesn’t seem accessible
Service was great, food was fantastic ! (even though they dont have a turkey club lol) I will 100% be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips, Fries, Quesadilla
Visited new paltz for a few days and decided to stop off here for a midday pint after walking some of the rail trail.The Irish bartender was a pleasure to chat to, cheers!
Service: 5
Great place for comfort food. Nice atmosphere. Staff extremely friendly and efficient. Food very well done and fresh. Loved the idea of Nachos featuring potato chips!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork Sandwich, Fries, Fish and Chips
We loved our meal here. We had fish & chips and a burger. Our waiter Pete was so friendly & accommodating. We would highly recommend this restaurant for a delicious meal & warm atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips
Yesterday, my sorority alumni met at Maggie Mae's for our fall luncheon. My seat had the perfect view of changing fall leaves. The weather here on Long Island was absolutely horrible. When I set out on my road trip upstate, I almost turned around and went home. I am so glad that I didn't! Not only did I share some funny memories and have some good laughs with my sisters of all ages, but I had an incredible lunch, followed by a dessert that almost literally blew me away! I'll post the pictures, but I'll tell you that I had a delicious chicken francaise with asparagus and the most wonderful mashed potatoes. I saved most of the potatoes for last, with a fair bit of the sauce. I only wish that I had brought a rubber scraper with me so I could get every last delicious speck of mashed potatoes. Then came my favorite part: dessert! The menu describesit as a rich chocolate Guinness cake with cream cheese frosting. Yelp reader, I am a Guinness girl. However, I could not begin to conceptualize how the two flavors would work together. Not only did they work together wonderfully, but the cream cheese frosting put an interesting sweet little twist on the flavor. I have a terrible sweet tooth. and when I find a sweet that I like, I just can't get enough of it. I wish I could have another piece of that cake right now...
Nice place to visit. Our server was quite anxious to make sure we got what we wanted.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had a delicious lunch overlooking the golf course on a beautiful sunny day. We had called and asked to move our reservation up an hour and the owner graciously accommodated us. The owner also served our meal and he was very kind and attentive. We thoroughly enjoyed our meal at this charming restaurant.
$135 per couple for a lunch which consisted of London Broil (not a great choice) with mashed potatoes and 3 asparagus. No salad or appetizer included. Also, there was no other choice offered for those who do not eat red meat. There wasn't even an hour of open-bar offered. These golfers play there and eat/drink there aferwards. They support this place and spend quite a bit all year. It's rather selfish and unfortunate that Garvin has forgotten the people who were there for him when he started out as a manager at Shay O'Brien
If they only still served the prime rib. (WAS) the best on the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A beautiful spot with great outdoor seating. Our food was good, it would have been better if they hadn’t forgotten our children’s orders. Our service was poor. The table that came in after us was greeted and received water immediately. I had to ask twice (we also had to ask for our bill twice). My salad was served with no dressing. Not a huge deal but the server started blaming others rather than simply getting the dressing. My husband’s water was refilled but the server walked away prior to refilling mine. A couple entered well into our time there. They ate and left before we got our check (different server). It was a long, frustrating meal. I’ll add that the kid’s menu is verbal so we ordered not knowing the prices … it was very expensive for what they were served.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
We were there for a post memorial gathering. Garvin and staff are top notch!
Excellent food, nice view . Nice place to gather with family and friends to honor our aunt ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went in for lunch after a round. Very good food and nice attentive! Staff. Highly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maggie Maes has a beautiful location over the golf course. The service is great and the food is tasty.
In the area and took a chance on this place, a lovely terrace looks out over the golf course but we ate inside. Fish & chips was very good, others enjoyed their meals. Our waitress was great but one problem is that she works alone and it seems the kitchen is understaffed too, it took about an hour for our food to arrive. Way too long. Otherwise a pleasant experience.Wheelchair accessibility: Up a flight of stairs, doesn’t seem accessible
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pulled Pork Sandwich, Fries