New Paltz Bagel Cafe
NY-299 &, New Paltz Plaza Ste 3, New Paltz
(845) 255-4594
Customers' Favorites
Poppy Seed Bagel Cream Cheese
Meat Lovers Everything Bagel
Plain Bagel with Butter
Menu
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
First time inate there was last Sunday and I was absolutely blown away with the everything bagel with veggie cream cheese I had ! Absolutely the best bagels in town by far! Will be coming back as a regular customer !!!
Great bagels, I really enjoyed the bacon egg and cheese sesame bagel sandwich. The shop is very old school, with the classic “mom and pop” feel. Their bagels are delicious and always fresh. The only negative aspect is that they don’t take card, which is very inconvenient, especially for larger orders. There is also no signage that I recall outside the store that alerts of this, only one inside. Despite this, I had a pleasant experience there.
It’s fresh every time. Every single time. The nova is sliced to perfection. We travel from New Windsor to get there. Can’t find anything half as good in the Newburgh area. The only thing wrong with this place is they seriously need a better vent fan. The air is terrible inside.
You May Also Like
Rocco's Pizzeria - 4 New Paltz Plaza
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegan
Great Wall Kitchen - 9 New Paltz Plaza
![]()
Chinese, Seafood, Soup
Plaza Diner - 271 Main Street Plaza Diner
![]()
Diner, Vegan, Vegetarian