Plaza Diner

271 Main Street Plaza Diner, New Paltz
(845) 255-1030

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Eric Ennenga

I never knew they made ravioli out of rubber or chicken both were disgusting I remember going here as a kid and it being great

Ana M

Reliable food. Need more servers.

Kristen Ondy

Other reviewers were right - portions are definitely small for premium diner prices. I got a grilled cheese which was just bread and two cheese slices for $8.50. One kids pancake in a Mickey Mouse shape was $9. Kids size Apple juice for $4. Servers were nice but service was slow considering it was a Sunday and it wasn’t busy. Overall, a decent stop if you have to, but bypass if you have other options.

Miko Blakeman

Went for breakfast. As soon as I walked in it smelled like straight urine, I don’t know what that was about. Anyway, ordered the burrito and a vegetable omelet and let me just say they were the most flavorless unseasoned sad overpriced food I’ve ever had. I have absolutely no clue how this place has been open so long…5.50 for a singular small orange juice is insane. The waitress was nice though.

Carl Lahmeyer

Way over priced food ok

シBLUE BLOXY

The service was slow and we waited about 15 minutes to get menus and then again another 15 to order. Food took a while to come out and when it did the burgers we ordered felt small. It was at this point where the lack of service got weird because new people would come in and she would attend them immediately and have there food out within 10 minutes and she would constantly check on them. Food was mediocre and service was poor.

Emma Haynes-Ocana

We had gotten into a car accident nearby and the tow truck guy took us to this diner to wait for our ride. In the meantime we went inside this diner to get food-and the lady who was working in the diner was extremely rude and barely acknowledged us. We didn’t even feel comfortable to stay here and left. Awful atmosphere and awful service.

Sarah Po

We wanted to have a quick bite before the movies, and very happy we came here. Our waitress was super nice and helpful. The kids coloring activity was really entertaining. My philly cheesesteak wrap was delicious. If you haven't been here in a while, give it another try.

Lyndon Knotts

The prices are ridiculously high. For 2 people to have breakfast eggs Benedict, breakfast combo French toast with eggs and sausage Coffee and apple juice. $49.18 I highly suggest going grocery shopping and having change leftover to enjoy your breakfast.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Jesse Napolitano

Had to be 80+ degrees in there. Slow service, with half the staff sitting at the counter not working. The food was like middle school cafeteria level.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

S R

No Organic bread choices nor gluten free. No real "health conscious choices at all". Prices a bit high for the quality but certainly not bad! Overall-ok.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Barry Kesten

The food was ok I do wish the service was a little faster it took like 13 mins the place was a little dirty it is also a little expensive I would recommend coming on your on otherwise it will be very awkwardly quiet

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

Harvey Coles

Clean Diner with typical diner atmosphere . It was an excellent spot to charge the Tesla. Stations were in view at all times.

Parking: Tesla chargers

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

SPM

Had the worst dining experience at this diner in my life. Only giving it one star to be able to post. My family and I stopped here for lunch in between a wake and funeral service. Three of 4 orders came out at different times with a long wait time. My order never made it to the table, a simple turkey club. I told the waitress when it's ready I'll take it to go but I should not have to pay for it. She returned and said the owner would not take it off the check if I took it... What a terrible experience, this establishment should not be in business. Never again!!

Laura García Francisco

Serve took her long to take our order we wait 30 min for coffee after they give you actitud terrible experience

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...