Crotty's Cheesesteaks

8 Eastchester Rd, New Rochelle
(914) 636-7000

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Traditional Cheesesteak Slider No Onions & Scoop of French Fries
Cheesesteak Disco Fries
Cheesesteak Cheesesteak
Cheesesteak Egg Rolls
The Rocky Cheesesteak
Baked Stuffed Potato
Mozzarella Sticks
Cheesecake Bites
The Traditional
The New Yorker

Menu

Featured items
Tator Tots
Bite-sized shredded golBite-sized shredded golden potato balls!
Cheesecake Bites
battered Cheesecake balls, covered in powdered sugar, topped with chocolate and caramel syrup
Chicken Fingers
Homemade chicken fingers, fried crispy golden brown & served with Buffalo sauce and carrot & celery coleslaw.,
Mozzarella Sticks
Fries
HALF A POUND of crispy & fresh fries! Whiz +$2 Bacon +$2
Bottle Soda
Bottles are - Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Canada Dry Seltzer Water, POLAND SPRING Water, Ginger ale, Snapple Lemon Iced Tea, Snapple Mango Madness, Snapple Apple, Snapple Kiwi Strawberry & Orange Soda, Sprite & Gatorade
Mac & Cheese
Crotty's uses 3 different cheeses and a homemade cheese sauce, topped with Shaved Parmesan, to take this mac and cheese OVER THE TOP!
Can of Soda
Various Flavors - Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Crush Orange Soda, Brisk Ice Tea, Sprite, Brisk Ice Tea
Fried Pickles
We love the salty pickle taste with the crunchy breadcrumb coating. What's not to love about a fried pickle? We serve ours with a tangy ranch dressing!
Philly Cheesesteak Eggroll
Golden-brown Egg Roll, stuffed with Steak, Whiz, Caramelized Onions

Cheesesteak Sandwich
The Traditional
Whiz, Caramelized Onions
Custom Sandwich
Create your own combination by choosing a protein and then adding to it with our range of fresh ingredients!
The New Yorker
Caramelized onions, grilled tomatoes, cheddar cheese
The French Dip
Provolone cheese, side of warm au jus for dipping
The Steakhouse Cheesesteak
Gorgonzola Cheese, Caramelized Onions & Side of warm Au Jus for dipping
The Rocky Cheesesteak
Toasted Garlic Hoagie, Black Angus Beef, Home Made Marinara Sauce, Melted Mozzarella Cheese, and Fresh Basil, Topped with Shave
The Club
lettuce, tomato, mayo, American cheese, crispy bacon
The Sicilian
Broccoli rabe, Italian hot peppers, grilled tomatoes, basil, provolone cheese
The Vegan Cheesesteaks
Beyond Meat, Caramelized Onions, Vegan Cheese on a Toasted Hoagie
The Irishman
Crispy bacon, caramelized onions, mushrooms, brown gravy, cheddar cheese
Caesar Wrap Cheesesteak
Served on a Bed of Fresh Romaine, Imported Shredded Parmesan Cheese, Topped with Crotty's Creamy Caesar Dressing. *Can be served cold
The BBQ Pit
Signature BBQ Sauce, Your choice of Cheese& tangy BBQ chips for you to crumble on top <b>Select Cheese but there is NO charge</b>
Caprese Cheesesteak
Fresh Basil, Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Tomatoes & Balsamic Glaze
Combo

EXTREME Cheesesteak Sandwiches
The Alpha Wolf
Large order of Crispy Bacon, Provolone Cheese, Onion Rings, Jalapeño Peppers, Signature Creamy Onion Vinaigrette
The Mac & Cheese
Mac & cheese, double order of crispy bacon, whiz
The Philly Hangover
Two Fried Eggs, American Cheese, Crispy Bacon, French Fries, Crispy Onions and Peppers
The Hot Cheeto
Grilled Onions, American Cheese topped with crushed Flamin' Hot Cheetos
The Nacho
Salsa, Caramelized Onions, Jalapeño Peppers and heavy Whiz, topped with crumbled Doritos
The Wild Buffalo
Hot & Spicy Buffalo Sauce, Jalapeño Peppers, Onion Rings, Blue Cheese, Carrot & Celery Slaw

Salads
Caesar Salad
Chopped Romaine hearts, Shaved Parmesan, freshly toasted Croutons, topped with our Homemade Savory Caesar Dressing
Cobb Salad
Shredded Iceberg Lettuce, Chicken, Bacon, Tomatoes, Eggs, Red Onions, Crumbled Blue Cheese
Signature Salad
Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Dried Cranberries & Sunflower Seeds topped with Gorgonzola cheese

Extras
Fries
HALF A POUND of crispy & fresh fries! Whiz +$2 Bacon +$2
Onion Rings
A perfectly seasoned large order of Onion Rings. Comes with Crotty's Signature Creamy Onion Vinaigrette
Mozzarella Sticks
Mac & Cheese
Crotty's uses 3 different cheeses and a homemade cheese sauce, topped with Shaved Parmesan, to take this mac and cheese OVER THE TOP!
Tator Tots
Bite-sized shredded golden potato balls! Whiz+$2
Philly Cheesesteak Eggroll
Golden-brown Egg Roll, stuffed with Steak, Whiz, Caramelized Onions
Chicken Fingers
Homemade chicken fingers, fried crispy golden brown & served with Buffalo sauce and carrot & celery coleslaw.
Fried Pickles
We love the salty pickle taste with the crunchy breadcrumb coating. What's not to love about a fried pickle? We serve ours with a tangy ranch dressing!
Disco Fries
Fried potatoes, brown gravy, caramelized onions, whiz
Pigs in blankets
A party favorite! Mini hot dogs wrapped in a Golden Puffed Pastry
Bag of Chips
We offer an assortment of chips! Please call for our most current offerings: 914-636-7000.
Mac & Cheese Bites
Cheesesteak Disco Fries
Crispy Fries, Brown Gravy, Caramelized Onions, Whiz & your choice of protein.

Dessert
Cheesecake Bites
Deep-fried, battered Cheesecake balls, covered in powdered sugar, topped with chocolate and caramel syrup
cannoli
Crotty's Signature Egg Cream
Delicious chocolate beverage made the old-school way! *Also available in Vanilla!
Mr Beast Chocolate Bars
Cakebites Classic Italian Rainbow Cookie

Beverages
Bottle Soda
Bottles are - Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Canada Dry Seltzer Water, POLAND SPRING Water, Ginger ale, Snapple Lemon Iced Tea, Snapple Mango Madness, Snapple Apple, Snapple Kiwi Strawberry & Orange Soda, Sprite & Gatorade
Can of Soda
Various Flavors - Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, Crush Orange Soda, Brisk Ice Tea, Sprite, Brisk Ice Tea
2 Liters
2 Liters are - Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Crush Orange Soda, Schwepps Ginger ale & Brisk Ice Tea
Snapple
Bottle Water
Crotty's Signature Egg Cream
Delicious chocolate beverage made the old-school way! *Also available in Vanilla!

Specials
Big Dudes Meat & Potatoes
Now this one is EXTREME!! Brought to you by the Creative Minds behind "Big Dudes Big Foods". This limited time (and specially priced!!) Cheesesteak has Black Angus Beef, Sausage, Bacon, Tator Tots, Onion Rings, Provolone and Whiz on a Toasted Garlic Hoagie. Get it before it's gone…
Crispy Stuffed Baked Potato
Our hearty ONE POUND Stuffed Baked Potato is piled high inside a Crispy Shell with our butter cream mashed potatoes. Delicious on its own or stuffed with your choice of additions. Always served with sour cream & au jus on the side!
Buffalo Chicken Mac
Crispy chicken tossed in buffalo sauce on top of noodles with housemade cheese sauce!
The Double Philly Burger
Crispy Black Angus Double Beef Patties, American Cheese, Pickles, Diced white onion, House Seasoning and " Crotty's Secret Sauce" on a toasted bun.
The Iona gael Cheesesteak
Traditional Cheesesteak, Eggs, French Fries and Topped With Salt, Pepper and Ketchup
Caesar Wrap Cheesesteak
Served on a Bed of Fresh Romaine, Imported Shredded Parmesan Cheese, Topped with Crotty's Creamy Caesar Dressing. *Can be served cold
The Double Philly Burger Combo
Black Angus Beef Patties, American cheese, pickles, diced white onion, House Seasoning and " Crotty's Secret Sauce" on a toasted bun.
Cheesesteak BLT
Black Angus Beef on a Toasted Garlic Hoagie with Lettuce, Tomato, Crispy Bacon, American Cheese & a Tangy Tartar Sauce
The Spring Fling Cheesesteak
Bacon, Ranch dressing, smothered with Swiss Cheese and fresh Avocado. * can be served hot or cold

Catering
Crotty's Cheesesteaks Server
Would you like help at your party? No problem! We can provide a Crotty's Server to help with set-up, serving, cleanup and anything else you might need assistance with to make your party a huge success! *Please select number of hours. $30/hr
utensils/napkins
Homemade Mozzarella Sticks Served with Marinara Sauce
Cheesecake Bites
battered Cheesecake balls, covered in powdered sugar, topped with chocolate and caramel syrup
Pizza
Hot & Fresh Pizzeria Pizza. $100 minimum on Crotty's food to order.
Philly Cheesesteak Eggrolls & Soft Cheese Dip
Golden-brown Egg Roll, stuffed with Steak, Whiz, Caramelized Onions.
Cheesesteak Sliders
Delicious Mini Cheesesteak Sliders! Black Angus Beef, Caramelized Onions & Whiz on Fluffy Mini Buns. Served by the dozen.
Platters of Hoagies
Choice of Protein (Black Angus Beef, Grilled Chicken, Pulled Pork and/or Vegan Beyond Meat (V) ) Topped with Caramelized Onions and Smothered in Cheese Whiz on a Toasted Garlic Hoagie
Chicken Fingers
Homemade chicken fingers, fried crispy golden brown & served with Buffalo sauce and carrot & celery coleslaw.,
Build Your Own Cheesesteak Kit
Enjoy our Cheesesteaks at your next party with a Build Your Own Cheesesteak kit. Comes with: – 15 Hoagies – Caramelized Onions – Your choice of Protein – Large Container of Whiz
French Fries
HALF A POUND of crispy & fresh fries!
Tator Tots
Bite-sized shredded golBite-sized shredded golden potato balls!
Pig in Blanket
A party favorite, Mini Hot Dogs! Served with Sauerkraut and Sabrett Red Onions on the side.
Homemade Onion Rings Served with Crotty's Signature Dressing
A perfectly seasoned large order of Onion Rings. Comes with Crotty's Signature Creamy Onion Vinaigrette,
Traditional Mac N Cheese
Crotty's uses 3 different cheeses and a homemade cheese sauce, topped with Shaved Parmesan, to take this mac and cheese OVER THE TOP!
Mac N Cheese Bites
Melty, crispy, golden-brown and full of flavor. Served with Whiz on the side.
Wire Basket & 2 Sterno Set-Up
Having a party and wanting to make sure your food stays piping hot? A Wire-Basket and Sterno set-up will keep all of your hot food nice & hot! We recommend one set-up per hot food tray. The set up is your to keep.
Creamy Carrot and Celery Slaw
Signature Salad
Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Pears, Dried Cranberries & Sunflower Seeds topped with Gorgonzola cheese
The Caprese Salad
Fresh mozzarella, thinly sliced tomato, iceberg lettuce and topped with fresh basil and a balsamic glaze.
Slider
Savory Mini Beef Patties on Fluffy Buns. Served with Lettuce, Tomato & Ketchup. $3.5 a piece. Minimum of 24.
Caesar Salad
Chopped Romaine hearts, Shaved Parmesan, freshly toasted Croutons, topped with our Homemade Savory Caesar Dressing
Cobb Salad
Shredded Iceberg Lettuce, Chicken, Bacon, Tomatoes, Eggs, Red Onions, Crumbled Blue Cheese
Fried pickles
We love the salty pickle taste with the crunchy breadcrumb coating. What's not to love about a fried pickle? We serve ours with a tangy ranch dressing!
Private Party Package
Enjoy a private Chef at your next party! Our exclusive Private Party Package features everything you need for your Event to a huge success - The Food, The Grill & The Chef! Nothing for you to do but to show up and enjoy. <b> Contact [305-915-3123], [email protected]</b>
The EXTREME Party Package
40 Cheesesteak Sliders, 5o Boneless Chicken Bites in Hot Sauce, Three 2 It Sodas, Full Tray Mac N Cheese and a Full Tray Salad.
The Party Package
20 Cheesesteak Sliders, 25 Boneless Chicken Bites in Hot Sauce, Two 2 It Sodas, Full Tray Mac N Cheese and a Full Tray Salad
Game Day Package 1
20 Cheesesteak Sliders, Large Mac N Cheese, 2 Large Mozz Sticks, Two 2 Itr Sodas and a Choice of 1/2 tray of Salad or Fries.

Packages
Get Well Soon Package
Looking to provide some much-needed nourishment & comfort food? Our Get Well Soon package has you covered! Each hand-packed box contains, famous Traditional Cheesesteak & an order of our deep fried Cheesecake Bites.
Family Summer Special
- 4 Traditional Shortys Cheesesteaks - Macaroni & Cheese - Signature Salad with Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Pears,Dried Cranberries & Sunflower Seeds topped with Gorgonzola cheese - Cheeseca - 4 Traditional Shortys Cheesesteaks  - 16oz contain
Saint Paddy's Day Lunch Box

All Day Breakfast
Philly Breakfast Burrito
Scrambled eggs, cheesesteak, sauteed green peppers, onions, breakfast potatoes and Monterey jack cheese wrapped in a warm flour tortilla.
Bacon Me Crazy Combo
Two Eggs over medium, Bacon & Mozzarella on a Bun with a side of House-Made & Perfectly Seasoned Home Fries.
Side of Home Fries
Homemade and Hand-Cut Breakfast Potatoes. Fried up and Seasoned to Perfection
Build Your Own Omelette
A Fresh & Fluffy Omelette - Customized with our wide array of Meats, Cheese and Veggies
Crotty's Classic BLT
Crispy Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayo on a Fresh Roll

Kids
Upside Down Grilled Cheese with a scoop of French Fries
Traditional Cheesesteak Slider (no onions) & scoop of French Fries
Chicken Nuggets with a scoop of French Fries

The Best Macaroni & Cheese Place
Classic Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce (3 different cheeses!) and topped with Shaved Parmesan Cheese $14.50
Parmesan & Garlic Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Sauce which is blended with Garlic and Parmesan Cheese
Chicken Teriyaki Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce and topped with our tangy Teriyaki Chicken
Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese:
Garnished with Blue Cheese to the description.
Sloppy Joe Mac & Cheese:
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce and topped with our hearty Sloppy Joe Meat
BBQ Pulled Pork Mac & Cheese:
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce and topped with our Slow Cooked BBQ Pulled Pork
Bacon Lovers Mac & Cheese:
Elbow Pasta smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce and topped with Crispy Bacon
Fajita Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce and topped with Black Angus Beef, Onions, Peppers, and Jalapenos, topped with tortilla chips
Cajun Mac & Cheese:
Elbow Pasta smothered in our Spicy & Cheesey Sauce
Pesto Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta in a Creamy Pesto & Cheese Sauce
Cheesesteak Mac & Cheese
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Signature Cheese Sauce with Black Angus Beef, Caramelized Onions and Whiz.
Fresh Veggie Macaroni & Cheese
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Homemade Cheese Sauce and Piled High with our Chef's selection of Fresh Veggies
Chili Macaroni & Cheese
Elbow Pasta Smothered in our Homemade Cheese Sauce and Loaded up with our famous Black Bean Chili

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: foursquare
Photo credit: facebook
+47 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+46 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I have been here multiple times and gotten an array of different cheesesteaks. The Crottie Hottie is by far my favorite as I have a love for spice. The steak melts in your mouth, with the beautiful symphony of the hot/sweet peppers, carmelized onions and the melty cheese. One of the best cheesesteaks I have ever had. HIGHLY RECOMMEND… 10/10
March 2025
This place has been one of the best additions to the Westchester food scene in recent memory. These are by far the best cheesesteaks that I’ve ever had anywhere in the tri-state area. We no longer have to suffer by ordering subpar cheesesteaks from pizzerias or diner….this is the new king of cheesesteaks around here.

Very generous portions of meat & cheese, and the bread might be the secret ingredient too.

Fries are excellent.
Onion...
February 2025
Crottys Cheesesteaks are unlike you ever hand before. They are delicious comfort food. So many versions to choose from the Paulie, AlphaWolf, Hotty Crotty. Each sandwich a gourmet guilty pleasure!! You can have a different cheesesteak every day of the week!. You have to try their fried pickles!

Dietary restrictions: You can customize and substitute ingredients
January 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Pardon My Cheesesteak - 8 Eastchester Rd
Cheesesteaks
Kokum Grill & Wok - 2 Eastchester Rd
Indian, Asian Fusion, Caterers
Chicken Joe's New Rochelle - 768 North Ave
Chicken, Fast Food

Crotty's Cheesesteaks

8 Eastchester Rd, New Rochelle, NY 10801
(914) 636-7000