Silkie's Saloon

454 Main St, New Rochelle
(914) 633-1857

Recent Reviews

Anjoli F.

SO MUCH POTENTIAL!!!!!!! The ambiance was amazing, unlike anything I've seen in NR. It's like a seedy, gothy, divy, weirdo handout. All things I love. However, things all of a sudden halted for me the 2nd the bartender told my date they had to order something despite me ordering a $15 cocktail. My immediate thought was to say, "Okay, we'll be on our way then." I didn't like that my date was pressured into ordering something. THEN she hits us with "cash only." Ugh. The cocktails. She was majorly pushing these concoctions she'd made up and said every single cocktail was $15, so we might as well go with the boozier one (as opposed to what we wanted which was something simple like gin & tonic), so we relented. They were OK. Would never order again, though. Other than the desperation and pushiness of the bartender, the ambiance was great! Fun clientele and gothy decor. If she had just eased up, I would honestly have this place be my go-to bar in town as opposed to never wanting to go again. Shame.

Johann Ibis

Hey, during dinner at the diner I said a few things to you that at the time I thought were in jest, but in hindsight, I realize were teetering on hostile and passive-aggressive. I'm not making excuses or saying it was OK, but I'm not perfect either, and I believe it came from a place of insecurity. You, you're mother, Mike, and Reshat all went out of the way for me; and it really meant more than you can imagine. You were wonderful, cordial, and kind and I'd like to apologize for some of the slights or jokes I made. When no relationship has been established which might foster such banter, that flavor of interaction can come off as tasteless, hurtful and offensive. I suppose, at my core, acceptance from you and your family was so important I became insecure. So if I can get a redo on a few dialogs I'd like to say,"you made it into Boston University at 16 and earned a PHD? That's really incredible and it blows my mind you're so brilliant. Though I can't lay claim to supporting you through your journey in achieving your accolades I'm still so proud of you for reasons I really don't understand myself. You have 2 boys? I'm sure they're wonderful, and brilliant as well and I'm truly elated you shared that with me. I know we may not share the same perspective on "the situation," but to me, that makes me an uncle. That truly makes my soul sing. I've never had nephews before. You love Jewish art? Jewish art is great! The ability of an arrangement of paint on canvas to evocate feelings into your spirit is truly a gift, and an essential quality of person's humanity. Everyone, including myself are fans of art whether we've ever stopped to really think about it and acknowledge the fact or not. You had ambitions to go to med school or be a lawyer and veered into academics instead? That's beautiful; persue your dreams no matter which direction the wayward winds of fate may blow them. Life, if you're fortunate, is uncontrollable entropy, so to land in academics through the maelstrom is incredible, whatever your profession, being able to support a healthy family is a miracle in itself these days. Please continue being awesome, and please, please forgive anything I said that had a snide tone. I promise I am prioritizing emotional maturity in my journey, I'd love for you, in some capacity to be involved in it.Again,Infinitely grateful,Johann Ibis

samuel roy

Met the kindest bar owner. SHE made me feel welcomed and i enjoyed the drinks. GREAT PLACE!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Jason O.

Stopped in after a wedding reception, easily one of the best bar experiences I've had in NYC I'd recommend a visit on off hours.

Alyssa S.

First of all most of the people thatcome here are underage. Second she tries to force you to order her original drink "Rumba" and then forces you to leave a tip. If you don't tip her she posts a close up of your face on her instagram. Third, anything you try to play or touch she has to tell you her "rules" and looks at what your doing every second (not allowing you to actually enjoy). She also forces you for a picture on her phone which she posts on her instagram to make it look like she has patrons. Don't come here. Unless you enjoy a sugary diabetic drink and want your actions watched every second.

Ashley Heather Zydel

2:00am! We had the worst travel day ever. Came here for a night cap and we LOVED it! Silkie is quirky and has stories and makes everything herself! We got amazing drinks, food, and a great time! Plus Sabrina the dog is absolutely fab!

Fernando

Most trash bar I’ve ever been to. Horrible customer service, the owner is a super rude grandma who wants people to purchase her garbage 15 dollar “rumba” drinks that aren’t even worth the hype. She takes random pictures of people to post on her IG in an attempt to make it seem like her bar is packed when it’s actually empty. Don’t waste your time here, way better bars in the area!

Resilient

The owner is a rude elderly women. All she does is complain about how folks don’t tip. Uh, maybe it’s because of your rudeness? I gave it a two because it’s a nice spot for introverts like me and the fried wings were decent.

Eddiee Jarvis

Horrible service! Rude grandma of an owner. $18 Tito’s soda. And garbage rumba punch made from the “99” brand flavors for $15. This isn’t the city. Also if you wanna play pool she pretty much makes you listen to her list of 100 rules before she lets you. Don’t waist your time, or your money. That is all.

Edward J.

The only reason this place gets 1 star is for the lovely porn in the bathrooms. That is all.

Aniko Magyar

This bar is an institution in New Rochelle. Its owner and operator Silkie does a great job cultivating a fun environment for all patrons. The drinks (especially Silkie’s signature rumba) are phenomenal, and the snack baskets are delicious. There are a pool table, and dart board. The bathrooms are decorated… interestingly. In October 2022 Larry Sharpe met some supporters here during a stop on his campaign for NY Governor.

Carrie Ann R.

This place is disgusting and dirty and should be shut down! I went there last week with a friend and the place is crawling with roaches! The old lady that runs it takes your picture as soon as you walk in...very weird Honestly I think that perhaps maybe she wants to say that her place is very active but actually it was empty'...on a Saturday night no less! My friend and I just wanted to have a drink after a party so stopped here for a nightcap. Very weird vibes. Thought it was just us until we used the restroom! Saw roaches crawling all over! That was it! I can't stand roaches and when I saw that I knew my instincts were right! Needless to say we left there fast after that!

max ruddy

This is largely in argument with some recent negative reviews, this is largely because they make accusations of fake alcohol and whatnot. From stories of the incidents the individuals who made the review where rather heavy set or overweight, and as many will tell you such individuals require more alcohol in order to have a good time. From personal experience I can say that 2 of her specialty “rumbas” get me where I need to be (I’m 200 pounds for context), I enjoy the vibes and the drinks, so please disregard this slander and get a damn rumba and ignore this clear anti-silky slander.

Yung H.

This place has terrible vibes. Do not let the owner and her very few customers make you feel like this is some exclusive New Rochelle high society bar. I met friends here who were uncomfortable as soon as I met up with them. The owner scorned us once she saw I had a sip from my friends average cocktail. Going off about how now she's giving out "$30 drinks for $7.50". Why would you even brag about that? Never thought I'd spend a holiday weekend getting disciplined by an ancient bartender. Goodbye forever.

Sarah M.

She's a really mean old lady that doesn't know how to run a business. She sells this rum punch and I gave a sip to my friend to try it. Silkie screamed at me that im not allowed to give my friend a sip because she will "lose money." What kind of bar doesn't let you give your friend a sip of your drink? That's not even the end of it, my 2 friends then had to go to the bathroom and took their drinks with them. Silkie chased them down to the bathroom asking them why they didn't leave their drinks at the bar and that no one will drug them... so weird. There were only 3 other men in the whole entire bar.. obviously they are going to take our drinks with them. She takes pictures of every single person that walks in to make it look like she actually has business but it's completely dead. If you want to have a fun night avoid this place at all costs.

Load More