Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Italian Eatery

A plain Brooklyn and a white. Done in 25 mins. Still hot and stretchy cheese when I got it home. This pizza is blazin'.

Brought back memories of the old neighborhood. Mama Ts is mah new fave!

Total trash...dont order this crap!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Grandpa are the best

What i ordered: large pizza with pepperoni, sausage, onions, green bell, black olives, and mushrooms, well done and extra marinara

What i got: all of the toppings were splattered on one third of the pizza, some slices had only a small clump of either pepperoni or black olives. no onions at all. underside of the pizza was still dough. the mushrooms were all burnt. and the sauce is watered down, so it soaked the sauce into the soft dough underneath and made it so wet that when you lift a slice, the cheese slides right off and leaves you with a soggy flatbread piece. it wasnt even cut evenly, i had to use a knife to finish the job.

the inside of the building was nice enough but i got the feeling that nobody wanted to be there on a friday evening right before fourth of july. i get that, but that still affects my review score.

gave this place a try wanting something different, but...eh. there's a much better, consistent pizzeria almost next door.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 2

Visited on 6/28/26 for the 1st time was recommended to try ....
Ordered a Meatball parm hero and oh my goodness it was super yummy. The bread was very fresh as well... It was very good and I'll definitely be back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I use to love the pizza so I decided to buy a slice and it was terrible. Presentation,taste and quality is terrible

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

I always order thru delivery, excellent place, sometimes Pizza or meals

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Always good food & customer service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mama’s Theresa’s in New Windsor is a fantastic spot for both takeout and dining in with the family. The food is always fresh, flavorful, and consistent—everything tastes like it’s made with care, not rushed out of a kitchen.

The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, perfect for a relaxed family meal. On top of that, the service is excellent—staff is friendly, attentive, and makes you feel right at home from the moment you walk in.

If you’re in the area and want great Italian food without the headache, this is definitely a go-to spot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I have been a loyal customer for as long as I can remember. My family and I dine at your restaurant at least once a week and frequently place takeout orders as well. Because of this, I feel it’s important to share an ongoing concern.

The dining room has been consistently extremely cold due to NO HEAT. Recently, I came in to eat with a friend and could not tolerate sitting in the back area because of the conditions. It was uncomfortable enough that it affected our dining experience.

I find it concerning that a business continues to operate its dining room under these conditions, especially during colder weather. Beyond the impact on customers, I also genuinely feel for the employees who are expected to work in such an environment.

I hope this issue can be addressed promptly, as I enjoy your restaurant and would like to continue dining in comfortably.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Mama Theresa’s Pizza in New Windsor is an absolute GEM!
From the first bite, you know this is real, old-school Italian pizza done right. The crust is perfectly thin with just the right chew, the sauce is rich and flavorful without overpowering, and the cheese is fresh, melty, and generous. Every slice tastes like it was made with love and pride.
Beyond the pizza, the entire menu delivers—classic Italian comfort food that feels homemade, portions that satisfy, and flavors that keep you coming back. The staff is warm, friendly, and welcoming, making you feel like family the moment you walk in.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice, feeding the family, or ordering for a gathering, Mama Theresa’s is consistently excellent. This is hands-down one of the best pizza spots in the Hudson Valley. If you haven’t been yet, you’re missing out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I come here a ton. Lived in the city for years near some iconic pizza restaurants that I would frequent, and this pizza is right up there with them in my book. Fresh, great tasting pizza/food/ingredients, always have Manhattan Specials (hard to find up here), and most importantly the owners and staff are great people that deliver a family atmosphere and service with a smile! Thank you!!

Always excellent

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good food and very large portions

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

All italian food at great pricing.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4