Tosco's Pizzeria New Windsor

Good food good staff good owner just all around good with the community

I’ve had good experiences with Toscos in the past, but tonight was extremely disappointing. The customer service was terrible. The person who answered the phone was rude and dismissive. My delivery order was missing items, and when I called to address it, there was no effort made to correct the mistake. Unfortunately, I won’t be ordering from them again. I would strongly advise others to take their business elsewhere.

Solid pizza!

Super nice people and really good pizza.

I’m writing this review because my wife came in for a slice today. She got a vegetable slice and paid $5 for it! She would have gotten the chicken bacon ranch but that was $7! I know times a rough with inflation and all but there’s no way a small business is going to survive with prices that high. I’ve been going to this week establishment since the late 80’s when it was Sal’s. Still remember $6 pie. Although the quality of food has undoubtedly gone down it is still good and has still been my pizzeria of choice in the area but with these prices pizza which was once a great reasonably priced meals for anyone will soon be hard to find. I know it’s difficult to keep prices down but in writing this because I’m worried about one of the great American industry ending.

I ordered a butter garlic Parmesan wings. They gave me olive oil garlic Parmesan wings. Good thing I called to confirm before I ate them. I cannot have olive oil and they decided to make it with oil and those wings do not go with Oil . That’s what they are cold butter garlic, Parmesan

Always fresh and delicious
Thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice, Cannoli

Delightfully enjoyed a pizza from this place with my family and absolutely loved it! Reminds me of the delicious thin NYC pizza. Will most definitely return.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We order from door dash tonight; the pizza dough was not cooked all the way the pizza was paper thin with the consistency of cardboard. Chicken wings :( dry… and the garlic knots…Not; the were not cooked all the way and they looked like garlic fingers! Very disappointing we have gotten food from her through door dash a few times and have been to the location a bunch of times; NEVER has the food been this Bad! Nothing was even rised; like the dough was not ready!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

Always great food every time !!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First I want you to give a raise to the girl who works there. Every single time I’ve been there she is great, she has a smile on her even if she is tired, she will make sure you leave the place as a happy costumer. I usually go to the plaza because I do laundry next to this pizzeria and when I get hungry I go there. Food is great. I’m not a big fan of pizza but for some reason this place has the best pizza ever. The other guys that also work there are very nice and hard working people. I went last night and lost my wallet. This girl helped me looking around… basically great food and great costumer service. 5 out of 5 :)

the costner Service was bad. The lady seem very rude. they need a new counter girl. it seems like she’s miserable with her life

Food: 4

Service: 1

The Buffalo chicken pizza is truly amazing. Service was excellent. I found my new favorite pizza place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Friendly service and delicious pizza and food. My go to in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good pizza, but terrible customer service, I stop by today Friday with a friend but the lady in the front of the counter give us a bad attitude, when we ask for a few slices she look really mad and miserable ?I will never go back there.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1