Amor Y Amargo

95 Avenue A, New York
(833) 328-4588

Recent Reviews

Sort by
george candler

A standout cocktail bar that offers a refreshingly unpretentious atmosphere and a deep dive into the world of Italian Amari. Despite focusing on a single core theme, the drink menu showcases remarkable diversity. Prices are fair, and the overall experience is one of the most distinctive the city has to offer.

Luisa Burri

David is a bartending GOD. He knew what we wanted before we did. And it was crazy busy and he greeted everyone and kept our waters so full. Come to this play for the vibes and the service and the INCREDIBLE drinks!

Ryan S

AJ gave my girlfriend and I such a good experience. Wish we had more time or we would have came back the next day. Tried VEP Green Chartreuse. Talked genepy. THEY HAVE ANGO ON DRAFT. Enough said 10/10

Martin Halupka

It's a small yet quaint bar. It was the perfect place to finish my trip with my son and toast our last nigh in NYC.

Anisha Kumra

The bartender was rude. Place was cute. Servers were weird to everyone.

Beau Von Hoffman

We constantly are frequenting this beautiful space of which there are two on both corners of the corner. AJ was wonderful and stayed very kind and understanding when we arrived 10 minutes before last call. Thank you AJ for doing this and making us the best of drinks. As always, we shall return.

Isabel Amé

David only makes delicious drinks.

Jonathan Reed (J.R.)

intimate, great vibe with awesome bartenders - not sure there's a better bar in the country for amaro lovers. sharpie's mustache (10/10), long game (9/10), James Run Free (9/10).

Brandon Hunley

Ok, so I tried to take photos, and as you can see the setting of the bar was not good and I was not going to be the guy to turn on his flashlight in the super cool cocktail place. This is the BEST cocktail bar I have ever been to. And I’m a little mad I did not find it earlier in my trip. When I return to NYC I plan on ending every night here. Truly a wonderful experience.

Katie H

very unique bar with incredible cocktails, friendly & knowledgable bartenders, and an extensive amaro selection (also available for purchase to take with you). it's a very small space, with an intimate, unpretentious vibe. just don't expect to get a seat!

Eli Fisher

A friend recommended it but we couldn’t go because they didn’t follow the advertised hours and closed early.

Green Touch

The staff here is both friendly and incredibly knowledgeable, and the selection of amari and bitters is truly impressive, offering a wide array of options to explore and enjoy. A definite must-visit in NYC.

Khoi Pham

What an absolutely special spot. If you didn't like bitters before, you will now. The classic 8 Amaro Sazerac was so smooth and the new seasonal Double Down was pleasantly earthy. The staff is the best, so kind and friendly. Seats at the bar will eventually clear up as the night progresses but you may have to stand around for a bit.

Olivia N

Overall rating: 4.8

This is already a clearly popular place, so don’t need to say much. Even just being in a standing room, the server was so nice! When a spot cleared up, he shuffled us towards a standing area with a bar-like table. I only got one drink and it was delicious! Seems like a great pre-game spot if I’m going out in the area. It was getting too crowded for me around 9:30pm bc I’m an oldie so I just got one drink. But I liked the vibe!

Sai Ramachandran

The energy and the aura is perfect for a fun casual date night! Their old fashioned is definitely top 3 in the city and it isn’t 2 or 3. Highly recommend getting the old fashioned

Loading...