I recently visited Andrews NYC Diner with my group for breakfast. I noted that they advertised chili on the menu outside. However, I was slightly disappointed to find that it wasn't available on the main menu and was not offered in the morning either. House-baked Muffin: I chose the pistachio flavour. To my surprise, the muffin was quite big and filling. Although it was primarily walnut, which makes sense given the high cost of pistachios, the muffin's vibrant green interior was striking. It came with jam and butter, but it was tasty enough on its own that I didn't need either. The service was generally attentive, though we experienced a slight hiccup initially while trying to order the chili. Also, I felt there weren't enough restrooms for its size. Thankfully, a staff member informed me about an additional restroom downstairs, which was a useful tip. Overall, despite a few minor issues, my experience was quite positive. The food, particularly the muffin, offered great value, and the overall atmosphere was welcoming. I would not mind returning to explore more of their full menu the next time I'm in the area.
Simon Hollis
Solid banana pancakes, better than expected tea. Good service given the business. Let down by the salty sausage and bland eggs.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Mathieu LEBER
A little expensive but the breakfast is good (for the US ?)
Dave Pike
Very busy but service always excellent!! Steak & eggs a class above. ? Can't wait to eat here next time in NYC again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sara Ferretti Photo
Very good, generous portions and prices half of those you find around. (With a Combo we ate two!) There is often a queue but it usually clears up within 10 minutes. ..The only flaw is the sausage, for those who are Italian and used to "the real ones" they won't appreciate it very much. The pancakes are delicious, soft and tasty, as is the French toast. Top eggs and mouth-watering bacon!
Olena Kunina
Nice and delicious! Thank you so much!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Kirsch
A real diner!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sampler
Katrin Kruppert
Quick and easy, but not tasty! We were there for dinner, had a burger, sandwich and pasta. Everything is quite simple, fries are totally soft and not crispy, everything is quite tasteless. But the place was clean and it was centrally located.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Daniel Graham
Fantastic food and staff. Really enjoyed breakfast here!
Muffins are delicious, super good. I had breakfast and it was good, the waiter was super good, coffee is very good. I will go back to have more muffins
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Blueberry
Sonia Fernandez
We are a family of tourists in Manhattan, we entered this place by chance, we saw that they had customers, that it looked clean, and that they had quite a few varied options for dinner and it was A GREAT SUCCESS. We ordered pizza, sandwich and sandwich... all delicious. Very good and fast attention. Price-quality very good for this city.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Salla Kalin
Tourist trap and bad service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Beni Danino
Nice staff. The service was good. The food is way over priced. Even for Midtown NYC.The food wasn’t bad but wasn’t great either. Fresh squeezed orange juice didn’t taste fresh squeezed. Spent over $45 for a simple breakfast. Breakfast combo for 1 and 2 cups of orange juice.There are many better options.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Eugene Lee
The lengthy morning wait in this place became a forgotten inconvenience the moment the food arrived. There's something about perfectly cooked bacon and eggs that sets the day off right. But it was the omelet that truly took me back. The Mexican omelet, in particular, was a standout, packed with flavor, the kind of breakfast I hadn't enjoyed in ages. The potatoes, too, were something special. There must be a secret ingredient in the New York air that makes potatoes taste better, and this place had it figured out. It’s rare to find a spot that gets it just right, making those potatoes a memorable part of the meal. It made me want to take up cooking lessons just to replicate that perfect taste. Amidst the bustling morning, our server, who I remember was Asian and I assume Japanese, added a layer of warmth to our experience. It’s wasn't every day I see such diversity in service here, and his professionalism and kindness didn't go unnoticed. Despite the rush, he made us feel welcomed and unhurried.Dietary restrictions: Those with gluten and dairy issues, might want to think about it.Kid-friendliness: There’s a lot of options for kidsWheelchair accessibility: It’s a very packed place with people all the time. Those were the wheelchair might struggle.
I recently visited Andrews NYC Diner with my group for breakfast. I noted that they advertised chili on the menu outside. However, I was slightly disappointed to find that it wasn't available on the main menu and was not offered in the morning either. House-baked Muffin: I chose the pistachio flavour. To my surprise, the muffin was quite big and filling. Although it was primarily walnut, which makes sense given the high cost of pistachios, the muffin's vibrant green interior was striking. It came with jam and butter, but it was tasty enough on its own that I didn't need either. The service was generally attentive, though we experienced a slight hiccup initially while trying to order the chili. Also, I felt there weren't enough restrooms for its size. Thankfully, a staff member informed me about an additional restroom downstairs, which was a useful tip. Overall, despite a few minor issues, my experience was quite positive. The food, particularly the muffin, offered great value, and the overall atmosphere was welcoming. I would not mind returning to explore more of their full menu the next time I'm in the area.
Solid banana pancakes, better than expected tea. Good service given the business. Let down by the salty sausage and bland eggs.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
A little expensive but the breakfast is good (for the US ?)
Very busy but service always excellent!! Steak & eggs a class above. ? Can't wait to eat here next time in NYC again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good, generous portions and prices half of those you find around. (With a Combo we ate two!) There is often a queue but it usually clears up within 10 minutes. ..The only flaw is the sausage, for those who are Italian and used to "the real ones" they won't appreciate it very much. The pancakes are delicious, soft and tasty, as is the French toast. Top eggs and mouth-watering bacon!
Nice and delicious! Thank you so much!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A real diner!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sampler
Quick and easy, but not tasty! We were there for dinner, had a burger, sandwich and pasta. Everything is quite simple, fries are totally soft and not crispy, everything is quite tasteless. But the place was clean and it was centrally located.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Fantastic food and staff. Really enjoyed breakfast here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food is less than average, good patio outside
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Muffins are delicious, super good. I had breakfast and it was good, the waiter was super good, coffee is very good. I will go back to have more muffins
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Blueberry
We are a family of tourists in Manhattan, we entered this place by chance, we saw that they had customers, that it looked clean, and that they had quite a few varied options for dinner and it was A GREAT SUCCESS. We ordered pizza, sandwich and sandwich... all delicious. Very good and fast attention. Price-quality very good for this city.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Tourist trap and bad service
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Nice staff. The service was good. The food is way over priced. Even for Midtown NYC.The food wasn’t bad but wasn’t great either. Fresh squeezed orange juice didn’t taste fresh squeezed. Spent over $45 for a simple breakfast. Breakfast combo for 1 and 2 cups of orange juice.There are many better options.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
The lengthy morning wait in this place became a forgotten inconvenience the moment the food arrived. There's something about perfectly cooked bacon and eggs that sets the day off right. But it was the omelet that truly took me back. The Mexican omelet, in particular, was a standout, packed with flavor, the kind of breakfast I hadn't enjoyed in ages. The potatoes, too, were something special. There must be a secret ingredient in the New York air that makes potatoes taste better, and this place had it figured out. It’s rare to find a spot that gets it just right, making those potatoes a memorable part of the meal. It made me want to take up cooking lessons just to replicate that perfect taste. Amidst the bustling morning, our server, who I remember was Asian and I assume Japanese, added a layer of warmth to our experience. It’s wasn't every day I see such diversity in service here, and his professionalism and kindness didn't go unnoticed. Despite the rush, he made us feel welcomed and unhurried.Dietary restrictions: Those with gluten and dairy issues, might want to think about it.Kid-friendliness: There’s a lot of options for kidsWheelchair accessibility: It’s a very packed place with people all the time. Those were the wheelchair might struggle.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Corned Beef, Muffins