Andy was so wonderful to work with! He truly went above and beyond with what he delivered. The cake he created was so perfect especially with the elements he chose for my fiancés Physical Therapy cake. He actually chose all the elements he works with his clients on a daily basis. I initially wanted to do a different cake and then changed it a few days before it was supposed to be delivered to the PT theme and Andy accommodated these changes. He made the whole process so special and fun and just so simple that I didn’t have sacrifice on the flavors and design. I wanted birthday cake and cookies and cream and didn’t think it would be possible and he suggested to make the cake with both flavors which we ended up doing. My fiancé loved the cake so much and felt so special on his day with the design Andy made that the cake was a gift in itself. There are no words to describe how grateful I am to work with him and his level of dedication. I plan to work with again on other special occasions. My fiancés reaction says it all in this photo. Seriously go work with Andy like now he provides the best value in the city for the price and for his amazing artistry and delicious cakes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Madelyne Sanchez
I don’t always post reviews but Andy, if I can give you 100 stars, I will absolutely do it. I ordered a 3 tier NYPD cake with 3 different flavors, and it was the highlight of the party. Normally I would order cakes but it’s either delicious and low in performance in design, or high performance in design but horrible in flavors. Andy’s cake was both DELICIOUS AND PERFECTLY EXECUTED IN DESIGN!!! He was also super responsive and delivered the cake on time for the party, I will be ordering again from you!!
Service: 5
Andrew Baker
Andy created an epic In-n-Out Burger themed cake for my birthday. He exceeded my expectations in every way - the design and execution were phenomenal. In addition the cake tasted fantastic! If you are thinking of a custom cake Andy is your man - don't go anywhere else. A+++
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Megan Baumer
The cake was absolutely perfect and so good!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ilene Whittaker
AndyCakes created an absolutely beautiful wedding cake for our celebration. It was exactly what we wanted. Andy is so talented and responsive . He really listened and understood what we wanted and somehow nailed our vision . We love how the cake turned out and it was delicious. 10 out of 10!! Elevated, unique and fresh are just a few of the words that come to mind in describing the beautiful cake that AndyCakes created. Thank you for making our celebration one to remember .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Benjamin Aronovitz
Extremely easy to work with and a phenomenal cake. Will be working with Andy again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Teresita Camacho
We would like to thank Andy Cakes NYC for the exquisite cake he created for our daughter's Lion King Broadway debut. The cake was not only visually stunning, but the flavors were also a perfect blend. We were particularly impressed with the smooth ordering process, even though we ordered from out of state. The cake was delivered promptly, and the professionalism of Andy Cakes NYC was evident throughout the entire experience.
Teresita Camacho
We would like to thank Andy Cakes NYC for the exquisite cake he created for our daughter's Lion King Broadway debut. The cake was not only visually stunning, but the flavors were also a perfect blend. We were particularly impressed with the smooth ordering process, even though we ordered from out of state. The cake was delivered promptly, and the professionalism of Andy Cakes NYC was evident throughout the entire experience.
Jasmine Essien
The entire experience with Andy from the first email to when the cake was delivered was fabulous. It was as if Andy was in my head and was able to capture my vision for the cake without having to worry. BUT the best part was not only seeing how beautifully created the cake was….it was actually eating it! EVERYONE….I mean everyone kept asking, WHO MADE THIS CAKE. It tasted as if the angels decided to spend a day on earth and give us a preview of how good cake is in heaven. Usually, you would have to pick…between a beautiful cake vs. a cake that tastes good. But with Andy, you literally get both. I promise, unless Andy decides to move out of the country, I will have him make every single cake for any occasion I will have in the future. And I HIGHLY recommend putting your trust in him for your cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elizabeth Joseph
Andy is very kind and easy to work with. He was flexible and accommodating when we had to make some last minute changes. Our cake turned out beautiful and it was delicious! It was exactly what I envisioned.
I found Andy Cakes on Instagram and inquired about a custom order for my baby shower. He was super responsive, helpful and made suggestions to enhance my ideas for the cake. His work is so beautiful and everyone was raving about how delicious the cake was! In my experience cakes usually either look pretty or taste good.. this was both! Everyone was so impressed, and the cake really made my day. He matched the animals to my theme decorations and still honored the vintage style I was initially drawn to. It was both playful and classic, I still can’t get over it.
Thank you Andy! I will be referring everyone I know your way, and using you for all things cake from this point forward!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Deborah Kaye
The Hippo Cake was THE BEST CAKE EVER! Hit of the party and the best tasting cake everyone had ever tasted! A universal treat. Rave reviews by every one at the party. It had all of the birthday man’s favorite hobbies and then some- exquisitely executed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anna Rudy
Andy was an absolute delight to work with! He was so enthusiastic about making a golden vintage heart cake I requested for my sister's 30th birthday, and he had no problem making it gluten free. The cake turned out GORGEOUS, even better than expected. These pictures don't even show the full extent of how shiny and glittery it was. It was also delicious, even for someone who isn't gluten free! It truly made my sister's day special. Thank you so much, Andy!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Noelia Ballenilla
Absolutely loved my birthday cake! So girly and pink!
Service: 5
cassidy nyfield
Andy is the absolute best. Our cake was SO amazing! Better than every inspo pic I shared with him and it also tasted incredible. Would recommend Andy without a doubt!
Andy was so wonderful to work with! He truly went above and beyond with what he delivered. The cake he created was so perfect especially with the elements he chose for my fiancés Physical Therapy cake. He actually chose all the elements he works with his clients on a daily basis. I initially wanted to do a different cake and then changed it a few days before it was supposed to be delivered to the PT theme and Andy accommodated these changes. He made the whole process so special and fun and just so simple that I didn’t have sacrifice on the flavors and design. I wanted birthday cake and cookies and cream and didn’t think it would be possible and he suggested to make the cake with both flavors which we ended up doing. My fiancé loved the cake so much and felt so special on his day with the design Andy made that the cake was a gift in itself. There are no words to describe how grateful I am to work with him and his level of dedication. I plan to work with again on other special occasions. My fiancés reaction says it all in this photo. Seriously go work with Andy like now he provides the best value in the city for the price and for his amazing artistry and delicious cakes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I don’t always post reviews but Andy, if I can give you 100 stars, I will absolutely do it. I ordered a 3 tier NYPD cake with 3 different flavors, and it was the highlight of the party. Normally I would order cakes but it’s either delicious and low in performance in design, or high performance in design but horrible in flavors. Andy’s cake was both DELICIOUS AND PERFECTLY EXECUTED IN DESIGN!!! He was also super responsive and delivered the cake on time for the party, I will be ordering again from you!!
Service: 5
Andy created an epic In-n-Out Burger themed cake for my birthday. He exceeded my expectations in every way - the design and execution were phenomenal. In addition the cake tasted fantastic! If you are thinking of a custom cake Andy is your man - don't go anywhere else. A+++
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cake was absolutely perfect and so good!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
AndyCakes created an absolutely beautiful wedding cake for our celebration. It was exactly what we wanted. Andy is so talented and responsive . He really listened and understood what we wanted and somehow nailed our vision . We love how the cake turned out and it was delicious. 10 out of 10!! Elevated, unique and fresh are just a few of the words that come to mind in describing the beautiful cake that AndyCakes created. Thank you for making our celebration one to remember .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Extremely easy to work with and a phenomenal cake.
Will be working with Andy again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We would like to thank Andy Cakes NYC for the exquisite cake he created for our daughter's Lion King Broadway debut. The cake was not only visually stunning, but the flavors were also a perfect blend. We were particularly impressed with the smooth ordering process, even though we ordered from out of state. The cake was delivered promptly, and the professionalism of Andy Cakes NYC was evident throughout the entire experience.
We would like to thank Andy Cakes NYC for the exquisite cake he created for our daughter's Lion King Broadway debut. The cake was not only visually stunning, but the flavors were also a perfect blend. We were particularly impressed with the smooth ordering process, even though we ordered from out of state. The cake was delivered promptly, and the professionalism of Andy Cakes NYC was evident throughout the entire experience.
The entire experience with Andy from the first email to when the cake was delivered was fabulous. It was as if Andy was in my head and was able to capture my vision for the cake without having to worry. BUT the best part was not only seeing how beautifully created the cake was….it was actually eating it! EVERYONE….I mean everyone kept asking, WHO MADE THIS CAKE. It tasted as if the angels decided to spend a day on earth and give us a preview of how good cake is in heaven. Usually, you would have to pick…between a beautiful cake vs. a cake that tastes good. But with Andy, you literally get both. I promise, unless Andy decides to move out of the country, I will have him make every single cake for any occasion I will have in the future. And I HIGHLY recommend putting your trust in him for your cake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andy is very kind and easy to work with. He was flexible and accommodating when we had to make some last minute changes. Our cake turned out beautiful and it was delicious! It was exactly what I envisioned.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I found Andy Cakes on Instagram and inquired about a custom order for my baby shower. He was super responsive, helpful and made suggestions to enhance my ideas for the cake. His work is so beautiful and everyone was raving about how delicious the cake was! In my experience cakes usually either look pretty or taste good.. this was both! Everyone was so impressed, and the cake really made my day. He matched the animals to my theme decorations and still honored the vintage style I was initially drawn to. It was both playful and classic, I still can’t get over it.
Thank you Andy! I will be referring everyone I know your way, and using you for all things cake from this point forward!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Hippo Cake was THE BEST CAKE EVER! Hit of the party and the best tasting cake everyone had ever tasted! A universal treat. Rave reviews by every one at the party. It had all of the birthday man’s favorite hobbies and then some- exquisitely executed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andy was an absolute delight to work with! He was so enthusiastic about making a golden vintage heart cake I requested for my sister's 30th birthday, and he had no problem making it gluten free. The cake turned out GORGEOUS, even better than expected. These pictures don't even show the full extent of how shiny and glittery it was. It was also delicious, even for someone who isn't gluten free! It truly made my sister's day special. Thank you so much, Andy!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely loved my birthday cake! So girly and pink!
Service: 5
Andy is the absolute best. Our cake was SO amazing! Better than every inspo pic I shared with him and it also tasted incredible. Would recommend Andy without a doubt!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...