Great pizza and calzone in a perfect location. The wine and Long Island ice tea were equally as good. The homemade mozzarella made the dishes!
Joshua
The first stop on our NYC pizza tour and it did not disappoint. This is a good spot in a good location. We just got a pizza, but the entire menu looked delicious. The pizza was excellent: just the right amount of cheese, the toppings were quality, and it was cooked just crispy enough to not scratch your mouth. 10/10, would definitely recommend.
Ty Lewick
We got both their sausage and pepperoni pizzas and they were delicious. But what you really need to do is get a order of their meatballs which are awesome but then dip your pizza crust in the meatball sauce 10 out of 10 highly recommend.
MarkoJ
The food was extremely first class. We had pizza and pasta dishes. The serving sizes were large and well worth it. When we are back in New York, this will be a regular stop.
Noriko
It was quiet enough to enjoy conversations. Food, drinks, and service were good. Only thing disappointing was a server couldn't take us to the table unless the majority of people are there. Some people were coming late for dinner, so others had to wait.
Lauren
We had a great experience. It was my husband, myself and our six year old. We sat upstair and had plenty of space. The food was amazing!
george
Last minute pizza cravings for my wife and I. The service was excellent and enjoyed the pizza.
KIM
Fabulous pizza! Fast service and wonderful location. Will make this a spot to visit each time we are here for a visit.
Drew
Fantastic service and wonderful food. Honestly, I am a huge critic of lasagna and theirs was great. I'm not gonna lie, the pasta sheets were a little too cooked, but everything else was amazing. The pizza is magic and the Caesar salad is heavenly.. 
EricR
Angelos was firing some amazing pies the night we we there. We were vacationing and had been to their other Central Park location on a previous trip, so we ordered a margherita pizza at the Late Show theater location and were not disappointed! The server was super nice and the manager was great too as he let me take a picture of the coal oven since we're pizza lovers! We went early at 5:30 which was a good time before any big crowds showed up.
Our food was good, the waiter was friendly. We were in and out very quickly although to be fair, we had an early dinner and the place was not nearly as busy at that time as I saw it other times when we walked by during our trip to NYC. It's a great spot for dinner if you are going to the Broadway Theater, just a few steps away! We had a 5PM dinner reservation on a Monday which was probably overkill, we were one of two families in there when we arrived but I didn't know and like I said, other times I saw a line out the door.
Yo mama
We both ordered pasta dishes and both were delicious! We had just been to the Stephen Colbert show and decided to try Angelo's. The pizza looked good but we were in the mood for pasta. My only suggestion would be that when the server brings bread and olive oil to the table that they explain how you should eat it. We guessed that you dip the bread in the olive oil but we weren't sure. Prices are a little high, but otherwise our experience was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Dubak
One of the best Pizza in my life.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jon Traylor
lol this place sucks.
אליאב ארבל
A couple with two children came with us who asked to sit on the entrance floor and for no reason they were told no and they had to leave.
We ordered a cherry tomato salad with cheese which came with one tomato cut into four and pasta which was very good.
Great pizza and calzone in a perfect location. The wine and Long Island ice tea were equally as good. The homemade mozzarella made the dishes!
The first stop on our NYC pizza tour and it did not disappoint. This is a good spot in a good location. We just got a pizza, but the entire menu looked delicious. The pizza was excellent: just the right amount of cheese, the toppings were quality, and it was cooked just crispy enough to not scratch your mouth. 10/10, would definitely recommend.
We got both their sausage and pepperoni pizzas and they were delicious. But what you really need to do is get a order of their meatballs which are awesome but then dip your pizza crust in the meatball sauce 10 out of 10 highly recommend.
The food was extremely first class. We had pizza and pasta dishes. The serving sizes were large and well worth it. When we are back in New York, this will be a regular stop.
It was quiet enough to enjoy conversations. Food, drinks, and service were good. Only thing disappointing was a server couldn't take us to the table unless the majority of people are there. Some people were coming late for dinner, so others had to wait.
We had a great experience. It was my husband, myself and our six year old. We sat upstair and had plenty of space. The food was amazing!
Last minute pizza cravings for my wife and I. The service was excellent and enjoyed the pizza.
Fabulous pizza! Fast service and wonderful location. Will make this a spot to visit each time we are here for a visit.
Fantastic service and wonderful food. Honestly, I am a huge critic of lasagna and theirs was great. I'm not gonna lie, the pasta sheets were a little too cooked, but everything else was amazing. The pizza is magic and the Caesar salad is heavenly.. 
Angelos was firing some amazing pies the night we we there. We were vacationing and had been to their other Central Park location on a previous trip, so we ordered a margherita pizza at the Late Show theater location and were not disappointed! The server was super nice and the manager was great too as he let me take a picture of the coal oven since we're pizza lovers! We went early at 5:30 which was a good time before any big crowds showed up.
Restaurantji Recommends
Our food was good, the waiter was friendly. We were in and out very quickly although to be fair, we had an early dinner and the place was not nearly as busy at that time as I saw it other times when we walked by during our trip to NYC. It's a great spot for dinner if you are going to the Broadway Theater, just a few steps away! We had a 5PM dinner reservation on a Monday which was probably overkill, we were one of two families in there when we arrived but I didn't know and like I said, other times I saw a line out the door.
We both ordered pasta dishes and both were delicious! We had just been to the Stephen Colbert show and decided to try Angelo's. The pizza looked good but we were in the mood for pasta. My only suggestion would be that when the server brings bread and olive oil to the table that they explain how you should eat it. We guessed that you dip the bread in the olive oil but we weren't sure. Prices are a little high, but otherwise our experience was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
One of the best Pizza in my life.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
lol this place sucks.
A couple with two children came with us who asked to sit on the entrance floor and for no reason they were told no and they had to leave.
We ordered a cherry tomato salad with cheese which came with one tomato cut into four and pasta which was very good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Loading...